Correspondence- #22 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Latino Health Access p A`( ,NO 450 W. Fourth Street, Suite 130 H ALT �y/ " Santa Ana, CA 92701 ACC ,, iii 714-542-7792 www.latinohealthaccess.org October 18, 2022 Mayor Sarmiento and City Councilmembers 20 Civic Center Plaza Santa Ana, CA 92701 1�1 gjj .)sant�.t...ana o g RE: Santa Ana Police Oversight Commission and Agenda Item 22 Dear Mayor Sarmiento and City Councilmembers, Latino Health Access works with community residents to support physical, emotional, and social wellbeing. Our goal is to facilitate opportunities for residents to take ownership of their wellbeing, including by participating civically in decisions that affect their health. We believe that residents know the solutions that work best for their community, and have heard the community express these needs to the city, which is why we are concerned with the actions proposed under Item 22 in the city council agenda. Latino Health Access is writing to respond to the October 18, 2022 City Council agenda item 22, "Police Review Commission Draft Ordinance Discussion," and Exhibit 1. We commend the City Attorney's willingness to meet with community-based organizations to discuss our policy recommendations. We also commend the City Council for directing city staff to examine the Police Oversight Ordinance drafted and supported by community-based organizations. We are concerned, however, that the policy language of Exhibit 1 profoundly differs from the model policy that was discussed by the City Council on July 29, 2022, supported and written by community-based organizations. The Exhibit 1 policy language will establish an oversight model that largely mirrors the City of Anaheim's Police Review Board, which a majority of this council and the community have rightly labeled as insufficient. The Police Oversight Ad Hoc Committee previously recommended a hybrid investigation-focused and auditor/monitor-focused model of police oversight. The policy language of Exhibit 1 will fail to accomplish the Ad Hoc Committee's recommendation and the City Council's goal to establish an effective police oversight model. We cannot support the ordinance as written unless the fundamental police oversight provisions, listed herein, are included in the policy. We urge the City Council to introduce pivotal amendments to establish an effective police oversight commission. Structural Failures of Exhibit I Policy Language As previously stated, an ineffectual and powerless police oversight model will be far more detrimental to the residents of Santa Ana than simply not having any police oversight, as it will give the false impression that meaningful accountability and investigation into police misconduct is occurring and potentially stall more effective reform methods. This is not acceptable for Santa Ana residents who largely prefer investigation-focused and auditor-focused models.' 'Kpetman,Roxana. (2021,August 3)."Santa Ana to Host Virtual Forum on Police Oversight." The Orange County Register.h�t� ��v�v o�u q,�tcrconi/202I �)8/0/sa�,rnta� a�rna� to host vgrtua L:L. 111 bran q�ogA�� ova u�q�ln 1 PREVENTION EDUCATION ACTION