HomeMy WebLinkAboutCorrespondence - #19Araiza, Fatima
From: Victor D Mendez <
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 4:14 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Hernandez, Johnathan; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza,
David; Phan, Thai; Lopez, Jessie; eComment
Subject: No on Resolution on Gaza Conflict - Item #19 - Meeting Date 12/5/23
I respectfully request that the Council Vote No on furthering discussion on the reference
Item # 19.
My position is based on the premise that after a conscientious and confusing recall
election, the debate to put non -citizen voting on the ballot, and most recently, the effort
to relocate the Mental Health Association, the citizens of Santa Ana could use a political
respite.
I wish to state that the sponsoring Councilmembers have every right to voice their
positions on affairs of the world and in some cases much good can come about by
raising awareness of larger issues within the Chamber.
I recall how, over 40 years ago, the effort to end Apartheid in South Africa came from
local government procurement and state investment policies, among other efforts.
At this time, there is progress toward peace in Gaza. We have a President, Secretary of
State, and both houses of our Congress working on this 24x7.
This can change, but our Federal government, where responsibility rests within the US
for this conflict, is not indifferent.
I am not sure what the City resolution can truly accomplish as its goal is not clear:
however, it could further exacerbate the citizens who are looking for some level of
normal functioning in the workings of Santa Ana City government.
If one wishes to condemn the violence and the conflict, there are numerous venues,
beyond the Council chamber, to do this. The First Amendment applies to all without
qualification or reservation.
As someone who marched against the injustices, inequities, violence, and corruption of
the VietNam war over 50 years ago, I will not deny what I did in the past to others who
wish to follow their values and ideals here in the present.
This would be something I am always against - hypocrisy.
Additionally, if one is truly interested in ending violence, we can begin with our own
neighborhoods where violence with a regularity that is not acceptable.
1
VICTOR D MENDEZ
Ward 3
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:17 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 7:03 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Chanel Barnoy
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Irvine, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at Santa
Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame Israel in
the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating violence
against innocent civilians. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured
nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may
exacerbate tensions and contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of
supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:17 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 7:07 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dan Beitor
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
Comments or questions
Hi,
As a Jewish resident of Irvine I was shocked horrified to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a vote at Santa Ana's
upcoming city council meeting.
This proposed resolution is completely one -side, using multiple false narratives to place all blame in the current war on the state
of Israel, as it struggles to repel Hamas terrorists who publicly strive to destroy it and commit genocide against all of its citizens,
as well as all Jews worldwide.
Yes — loss of life is tragic no matter where it occurs, but none of those lives would have been lost had Hamas not set upon
massacring, raping and kidnapping so many innocent civilians on October 7 who had done nothing but exist.
Nothing in this resolution will work towards promoting or ensuring a better life for the people in Gaza, who have been forcefully
ruled by Hamas for nearly 20 years, an organization that has used all of its resources to promote their destructive campaign
against Israel, at the expense of its own people. If Hamas chose to lay down their weapons tomorrow and urge its population to
live peacefully alongside Israel, Gaza could become a thriving and successful state.
Not only will this biased resolution do nothing to promote peace or tolerance, it will only serve to further inflame the hate and
antisemitic atmosphere now on open display against our Jewish community. How can our locally elected officials be so complicit
in furthering and even promoting this hate, when you are all sworn to fight against any bias and stand up to all kinds of hate?
Maybe that just doesn't apply to us Jews...
I urge you to think hard about your moral and social compass, and consider whether you want to stand with promoters of lies
and extreme hate by approving this resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:19 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 7:54 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Robin Itzler
Email
Address
Cypress, California 90630
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear All,
When the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, the world did not demand that the United States "ceasefire."
The very next day DEMOCRAT President Franklin Roosevelt went before Congress and asked for a declaration of war - and got
it.
When Muslim terrorists attacked America on September 11, 2001, REPUBLICAN President George W. Bush told the American
people that our country would retaliate for what happened - and we did.
I hope the Santa Ana City Council does the right thing and shows their support for Israel. That nation was ATTACKED by vicious
Palestinian Hamas where 1200-1400 Israelis were murdered, thousands were raped or tortured, and many were kidnapped.
Israel responded as any nation would and should.
There are 49 nations in the WORLD with a majority Muslim population. NOT ONE WANTS TO TAKE IN THE GAZAN PEOPLE.
Not one Muslim nation anywhere in the world wants the Gazans. Why? You know the answer why ...
Israel will continue to fight for her survival. The U.S. House of Representatives just voted 412-1 in support of Israel. The City of
1
Santa Ana should do the same.
Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Robin Itzler
Long-time Orange County Resident
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:21 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 8:44 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Suzanne Stern
Email
Address
Newport Beach, California 92660
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Suzanne Stern
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:22 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 8:49 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Ceciila Goodman
Email
Address
Cypress Point Lane
Newport Beach, California 92660
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
1
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Cecilia Goodman
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:24 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:04 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Deborah Cherem
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92603
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Hispanic and Jewish resident of Irvine I was shocked and horrified to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a
vote at Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting.
This proposed resolution is completely one -side, using multiple false narratives to place all blame in the current war on the state
of Israel, as it struggles to repel Hamas terrorists who publicly strive to destroy it and commit genocide against all of its citizens,
as well as all Jews worldwide.
Yes — loss of life is tragic no matter where it occurs, but none of those lives would have been lost had Hamas not set upon
massacring, raping and kidnapping so many innocent civilians on October 7 who had done nothing but exist.
Nothing in this resolution will work towards promoting or ensuring a better life for the people in Gaza, who have been forcefully
ruled by Hamas for nearly 20 years, an organization that has used all of its resources to promote their destructive campaign
against Israel, at the expense of its own people. If Hamas chose to lay down their weapons tomorrow and urge its population to
live peacefully alongside Israel, Gaza could become a thriving and successful state.
Not only will this biased resolution do nothing to promote peace or tolerance, it will only serve to further inflame the hate and
antisemitic atmosphere now on open display against our Jewish community. How can our locally elected officials be so complicit
in furthering and even promoting this hate, when you are all sworn to fight against any bias and stand up to all kinds of hate?
Maybe that just doesn't apply to us Jews...
I urge you to think hard about your moral and social compass, and consider whether you want to stand with promoters of lies
and extreme hate by approving this resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:25 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:06 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Pamela Algo
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Members of the Santa Ana City Council,
I am reaching out with an urgent appeal regarding the resolution on Israel set for vote in the upcoming council meeting. As a
resident deeply invested in the welfare and integrity of our community, I find it necessary to express my strong concerns about
this resolution.
The draft of the resolution, as it stands, seems to present a notably one-sided view of the Israeli -Palestinian conflict. This
approach not only oversimplifies a complex international issue but also risks propagating a narrative that could fuel divisiveness
and antisemitism in our community. It is imperative that any statement or resolution from our council reflects a balanced
understanding and does not unintentionally align with extreme and misleading viewpoints.
I urge the council to reconsider the implications of passing this resolution. It is essential that our community's actions and
statements promote peace, truth, and mutual understanding, rather than contributing to the spread of bias and conflict.
As decision -makers for our community, you bear the responsibility of ensuring that our actions and endorsements as a city are
grounded in fairness and informed perspective. I respectfully request that the council reevaluates this resolution to better reflect
these values.
Thank you for considering my perspective on this critical issue. I trust that the council will make a decision that truly represents
the best interests of all members of our community.
Sincerely,
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:26 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:13 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Magen Jacobs
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear council members,
As a Jewish resident of Santa Ana, I am deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame
Israel in the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating
violence against innocent civilians. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have
endured nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel.
Approving this biased resolution may exacerbate tensions and contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere.
I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
Sincerely,
Magen Jacobs
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:27 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:21 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Lindsey Hamilton
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92618
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Members of the Santa Ana City Council,
I am reaching out with an urgent appeal regarding the resolution on Israel set for vote in the upcoming council meeting. As a
resident deeply invested in the welfare and integrity of our community, I find it necessary to express my strong concerns about
this resolution.
The draft of the resolution, as it stands, seems to present a notably one-sided view of the Israeli -Palestinian conflict. This
approach not only oversimplifies a complex international issue but also risks propagating a narrative that could fuel divisiveness
and antisemitism in our community. It is imperative that any statement or resolution from our council reflects a balanced
understanding and does not unintentionally align with extreme and misleading viewpoints.
I urge the council to reconsider the implications of passing this resolution. It is essential that our community's actions and
statements promote peace, truth, and mutual understanding, rather than contributing to the spread of bias and conflict.
As decision -makers for our community, you bear the responsibility of ensuring that our actions and endorsements as a city are
grounded in fairness and informed perspective. I respectfully request that the council reevaluates this resolution to better reflect
these values.
Thank you for considering my perspective on this critical issue. I trust that the council will make a decision that truly represents
the best interests of all members of our community.
Sincerely,
1
Lindsey Hamilton
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:27 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:25 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Phyllis Roberts
Email
Address
Laguna Hills, California 92653
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Please vote against this resolution. This is completely one sided and offensive. Please study your history before this gross
condemnation.
Upload a file
• Santa-Ana-City-Council.docx
1
November 29, 2023
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the
Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be considered at the December 6, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false
equivalency between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent
crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing,
genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and
the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas
accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their
nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful
condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase
"Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6 million Jews and
countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that
the resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Phyllis Roberts
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:28 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:25 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Julia Burton
Email
Address
Tustin, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I am writing to you as a concerned resident regarding the upcoming vote on the proposed resolution that has been a topic of
much discussion in our community. It has come to my attention that this resolution may have unintended consequences,
particularly in terms of its portrayal and implications regarding Israel.
I believe it is crucial for such resolutions to be balanced and considerate of the complex realities of international conflicts. The
current draft, as I understand it, seems to adopt a one-sided narrative that does not fully capture the intricacies of the Israeli -
Palestinian conflict. Such a perspective may inadvertently foster misconceptions and could contribute to a rise in tension and
antisemitism within our community.
It is my sincere hope that the Santa Ana City Council will consider these factors carefully. An ideal resolution would be one that
promotes understanding, peace, and coexistence, rather than deepening divisions. It is essential to approach these sensitive
matters with a view towards constructive dialogue and reconciliation.
I respect the challenges involved in addressing such complex international issues at the local government level. However, I urge
you to reconsider the current stance of the resolution to ensure it aligns with values of fairness, truth, and community harmony.
Thank you for your attention to this matter and for your ongoing service to our community.
Sincerely,
Julia Burton
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:32 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:40 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Avi Ron
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92618
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
Comments or questions
-riv xnair 5--n-O:
As a Jewish resident of [location], I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame
Israel in the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating
violence against innocent civilians. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have
endured nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution
may exacerbate tensions and contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications
of supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:33 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 9:52 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Tomer Krispin
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of orange county, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting.
The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame Israel in the ongoing conflict. While
acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating violence against innocent civilians.
This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured nearly two decades of
Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may exacerbate tensions and
contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere.
I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:33 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 10:08 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Yuval Domb
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Orange County I was shocked horrified to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting.
This proposed resolution is completely one -side, using multiple false narratives to place all blame in the current war on the state
of Israel, as it struggles to repel Hamas terrorists who publicly strive to destroy it and commit genocide against all of its citizens,
as well as all Jews worldwide.
Yes — loss of life is tragic no matter where it occurs, but none of those lives would have been lost had Hamas not set upon
massacring, raping and kidnapping so many innocent civilians on October 7 who had done nothing but exist.
Nothing in this resolution will work towards promoting or ensuring a better life for the people in Gaza, who have been forcefully
ruled by Hamas for nearly 20 years, an organization that has used all of its resources to promote their destructive campaign
against Israel, at the expense of its own people. If Hamas chose to lay down their weapons tomorrow and urge its population to
live peacefully alongside Israel, Gaza could become a thriving and successful state.
Not only will this biased resolution do nothing to promote peace or tolerance, it will only serve to further inflame the hate and
antisemitic atmosphere now on open display against our Jewish community. How can our locally elected officials be so complicit
in furthering and even promoting this hate, when you are all sworn to fight against any bias and stand up to all kinds of hate?
Maybe that just doesn't apply to us Jews...
I urge you to think hard about your moral and social compass, and consider whether you want to stand with promoters of lies
and extreme hate by approving this resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:34 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 10:08 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Stav Ozdoba
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92618
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Irvine, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at Santa
Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame Israel in
the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating violence
against innocent civilians. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured
nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may
exacerbate tensions and contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of
supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:37 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 10:20 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Eli Gabay
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92604
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Irvine , I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at Santa
Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame Israel in
the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating violence
against innocent civilians. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured
nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may
exacerbate tensions and contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of
supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:38 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2023 10:35 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Daniel Treves
Email
Address
IRVINE, California 92618
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Irvine, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at Santa
Ana's upcoming city council meeting. which effectively condones a jihadist organization that burns babies alive, slits pregnant
women, and jeopardizes their own people to further their ISIS Nazi cause . The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false
narratives that unfairly blame Israel in the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize
the role of Hamas in initiating violence against innocent civilians. Our local goverments need to focus on promoting civilization
and humanity, for our own sake, and promote those who target progress, individual freedoms, and civilization at large.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:40 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 6:17 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Tali Gles
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92603
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Irvine, I was shocked horrified to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a vote at Santa Ana's
upcoming city council meeting.
This proposed resolution is completely one-sided, using multiple false narratives to place all blame in the current war on the
state of Israel, as it struggles to repel Hamas terrorists who publicly strive to destroy it and commit genocide against all of its
citizens, as well as all Jews worldwide.
Yes — loss of life is tragic no matter where it occurs, but none of those lives would have been lost had Hamas not set upon
massacring, raping and kidnapping so many innocent civilians on October 7 who had done nothing but exist.
Nothing in this resolution will work towards promoting or ensuring a better life for the people in Gaza, who have been forcefully
ruled by Hamas for nearly 20 years, an organization that has used all of its resources to promote their destructive campaign
against Israel, at the expense of its own people. If Hamas chose to lay down their weapons tomorrow and urge its population to
live peacefully alongside Israel, Gaza could become a thriving and successful state.
Not only will this biased resolution do nothing to promote peace or tolerance, it will only serve to further inflame the hate and
antisemitic atmosphere now on open display against our Jewish community. How can our locally elected officials be so complicit
in furthering and even promoting this hate, when you are all sworn to fight against any bias and stand up to all kinds of hate?
Maybe that just doesn't apply to us Jews...
I urge you to think hard about your moral and social compass, and consider whether you want to stand with promoters of lies
and extreme hate by approving this resolution.
Thank you,
Tali
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:41 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 8:07 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Natalie Goldfinger
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Orange County I was shocked horrified to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting.
This proposed resolution is completely one -side, using multiple false narratives to place all blame in the current war on the state
of Israel, as it struggles to repel Hamas terrorists who publicly strive to destroy it and commit genocide against all of its citizens,
as well as all Jews worldwide.
Yes — loss of life is tragic no matter where it occurs, but none of those lives would have been lost had Hamas not set upon
massacring, raping and kidnapping so many innocent civilians on October 7 who had done nothing but exist.
Nothing in this resolution will work towards promoting or ensuring a better life for the people in Gaza, who have been forcefully
ruled by Hamas for nearly 20 years, an organization that has used all of its resources to promote their destructive campaign
against Israel, at the expense of its own people. If Hamas chose to lay down their weapons tomorrow and urge its population to
live peacefully alongside Israel, Gaza could become a thriving and successful state.
Not only will this biased resolution do nothing to promote peace or tolerance, it will only serve to further inflame the hate and
antisemitic atmosphere now on open display against our Jewish community. How can our locally elected officials be so complicit
in furthering and even promoting this hate, when you are all sworn to fight against any bias and stand up to all kinds of hate?
Maybe that just doesn't apply to us Jews...
I urge you to think hard about your moral and social compass, and consider whether you want to stand with promoters of lies
and extreme hate by approving this resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:41 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 8:49 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Wendy Arenson
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92603
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my deep concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Wendy Arenson, JD, CSPG, CAP
Executive Director and President
Jewish Community Foundation Orange County
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:42 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 9:02 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Bonni Pomush
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
First, thank you for your service to our community. Raising your hand to say I'll help, getting elected, and now doing the work is a
huge feat and I am sincerely grateful for your efforts to strengthen and build community.
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding there.
At the same time, we must hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent lives in harm's way in pursuit of their
nefarious goals.
1
The proposed resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel
on October 7.
It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6 million Jews and
countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime.
While the resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" it is not achieving that intent. It is actually promoting and amplifying bigotry.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Bonni Pomush
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:42 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 9:19 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Noam Aviv
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92701
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
Comments or questions
As a Jewish member of the Orange County community, I am quite troubled by the proposed resolution concerning Israel that is
up for a vote at the next Santa Ana city council meeting.
This resolution seems to adopt a biased perspective, predominantly basing its arguments on misleading narratives that
predominantly hold Israel responsible for the ongoing conflict. It's important to acknowledge the sorrowful loss of life, but also
vital to understand Hamas's role in perpetuating violence against civilians. Such a resolution, unfortunately, does not seem to aid
in bettering the lives of the people in Gaza, who have suffered under nearly two decades of Hamas' governance, which is largely
aimed at attacking Israel. Passing this resolution might not only worsen existing tensions but also potentially foster an
environment of antisemitism. I strongly encourage you to consider the ethical and societal consequences of endorsing a
resolution that seems to be grounded in falsehoods and extreme animosity.
Sincerely
Noam
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:43 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 9:51 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Jane Brenner
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely, Jane Brenner
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:43 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:08 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Emily Aschbrenner
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
1
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Emily Aschbrenner
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:44 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:41 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
RC Stone
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92604-4619
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
Please educate yourselves about the mission of Hamas and the history of the area that is so complicated.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
RC STONE
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:11 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:55 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Bonnie Miller
Email
Address
Foster City, California 94404
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
1
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Bonnie Miller
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:11 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:00 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Emily Ball
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92603
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I am contacting you regarding the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
People around the globe are horrified by the deaths of innocent civilians in Gaza and the West Bank. The resolution makes clear
that it is not so concerned about past, present, or future deaths of innocent civilians in Israel.
The proposed ceasefire resolution refers to Israeli casualty figures as "estimates" but cites Palestinian casualties as exact
numbers, casting doubt only on Israeli deaths. This encourages conspiracy theories that deny the horrific atrocities committed by
Hamas on October 7th. Through this disparity, the resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and
amplifies it.
The resolution does not address what Israel should do to protect its multicultural, pluralistic society if it does not defend itself
from terrorist attacks, including the one that occurred in Jerusalem today (November 30th) killing at least 2 civilians and injuring
many more. The terms of the resolution, if pushed onto Israel, would leave the country's 9 million residents at risk of annihilation
if terrorist attacks are allowed to progress (and as Hamas has promised it will continue to carry out).
1
If you truly care about loss of innocent life, I urge you to reject this resolution.
Sincerely,
Emily Ball
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:11 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:05 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Diana Moss
Email
Address
Corona del Mar, California 92625
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
1
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Diana Moss
Araiza, Fatima
From: Asma Ahmad <
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 1:34 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Thank you
Thank you for supporting a ceasefire. We salute your commitment to the truth and justice.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:07 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:58 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Amit Inbar
Email
Address
Newport Beach, California 92663
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Newport Beach I was shocked horrified to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting.
This proposed resolution is completely one -side, using multiple false narratives to place all blame in the current war on the state
of Israel, as it struggles to repel Hamas terrorists who publicly strive to destroy it and commit genocide against all of its citizens,
as well as all Jews worldwide.
Yes — loss of life is tragic no matter where it occurs, but none of those lives would have been lost had Hamas not set upon
massacring, raping and kidnapping so many innocent civilians on October 7 who had done nothing but exist.
Nothing in this resolution will work towards promoting or ensuring a better life for the people in Gaza, who have been forcefully
ruled by Hamas for nearly 20 years, an organization that has used all of its resources to promote their destructive campaign
against Israel, at the expense of its own people. If Hamas chose to lay down their weapons tomorrow and urge its population to
live peacefully alongside Israel, Gaza could become a thriving and successful state.
Not only will this biased resolution do nothing to promote peace or tolerance, it will only serve to further inflame the hate and
antisemitic atmosphere now on open display against our Jewish community. How can our locally elected officials be so complicit
in furthering and even promoting this hate, when you are all sworn to fight against any bias and stand up to all kinds of hate?
Maybe that just doesn't apply to us Jews...
I urge you to think hard about your moral and social compass, and consider whether you want to stand with promoters of lies
and extreme hate by approving this resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:07 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 12:09 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Marla Nathan
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:07 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 12:26 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Howard Brostoff
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Howard Brostoff
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:14 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 1:19 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Jordan Muller
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Members of the Santa Ana City Council,
I am reaching out with an urgent appeal regarding the resolution on Israel set for vote in the upcoming council meeting. As a
resident deeply invested in the welfare and integrity of our community, I find it necessary to express my strong concerns about
this resolution.
The draft of the resolution, as it stands, seems to present a notably one-sided view of the Israeli -Palestinian conflict. This
approach not only oversimplifies a complex international issue but also risks propagating a narrative that could fuel divisiveness
and antisemitism in our community. It is imperative that any statement or resolution from our council reflects a balanced
understanding and does not unintentionally align with extreme and misleading viewpoints.
I urge the council to reconsider the implications of passing this resolution. It is essential that our community's actions and
statements promote peace, truth, and mutual understanding, rather than contributing to the spread of bias and conflict. As
decision -makers for our community, you bear the responsibility of ensuring that our actions and endorsements as a city are
grounded in fairness and informed perspective. I respectfully request that the council reevaluates this resolution to better reflect
these values.
Thank you for considering my perspective on this critical issue. I trust that the council will make a decision that truly represents
the best interests of all members of our community.
Sincerely,
Jordan Muller
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:18 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 1:20 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
jeanine raab
Email
Address
TUSTIN, California 92780-2402
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Jeanine Raab
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:18 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 1:25 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Karen M
Address
SANTA ANA, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
Comments or questions
As a resident of Santa Ana, it was deeply unsettling to come across the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at the
upcoming Santa Ana City Council meeting. This resolution, in its one-sided approach, relies on several false narratives, placing
the entire blame for the current conflict on Israel as it defends itself against Hamas terrorists. These terrorists openly aim to
destroy Israel and commit genocide against its citizens and Jews globally.
While the loss of life is tragic wherever it occurs, it's essential to recognize that none of those lives would have been lost if
Hamas hadn't initiated the massacre, rape, and kidnapping of innocent civilians on October 7, individuals who were simply going
about their lives. The resolution fails to acknowledge this reality.
Moreover, this resolution does nothing to contribute to the well-being of the people in Gaza, who have endured nearly two
decades of forceful rule by Hamas. The organization has diverted resources from its own people to pursue a destructive
campaign against Israel. If Hamas chose peace and encouraged its population to live harmoniously with Israel, Gaza could
potentially thrive.
Approving this biased resolution won't foster peace or tolerance; instead, it risks exacerbating the hate and antisemitism already
evident in our community. It's disheartening to witness locally elected officials contributing to this environment when they are
sworn to combat bias and all forms of hate.
his issue hits close to home for me, as I have family in Israel, and the constant fear for their safety weighs heavily on my mind.
The rise of antisemitism is not just a distant concern; it's a threat that directly affects our well-being here. By endorsing a
resolution that leans towards falsehoods and promotes extreme hate, we risk further exacerbating the already challenging
atmosphere we face.
I believe in the power of understanding, compassion, and genuine dialogue to bridge divides. Let's work towards a solution that
fosters peace and unity rather than contributing to the tensions that put our community at risk.
With great respect,
Keren
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:18 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:00 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Barbara Freeman
Email
Address
California San Mateo
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Barbara Freeman
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:19 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:04 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Ben Imberman
Email
Address
Orange, California 92865
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Ben Imberman
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:19 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:10 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Rachel Pearson
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Rachel Pearson
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:19 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:10 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Yael Adams
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92618
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Yael
Araiza, Fatima
From: muriel ullman <
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:04 PM
To: eComment
Subject: City Council Resolution in Support of Palestine
Re: Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be considered at
the December 5, 2023, meeting.
Dear City Council:
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false
equivalency between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent
crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing,
genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and
the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas
accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their
nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful
condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase
"Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6 million Jews and
countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that
the resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:05 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:23 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Jason Wenneberg
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
1
Sincerely,
Jason & Crystal Wenneberg
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:05 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:25 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Deena Brandes
Email
Address
Beverly hills
California 90212
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
1
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Deena brandes
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:05 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:28 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
John Pearson
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I have attached a letter urging you to reject the extremely one-sided and divisive Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian
People in Support of a Ceasefire .
Upload a file
• Dear-Santa-Ana-City-Council.docx
1
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian
People in Support of a Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency
between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not
hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which
are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the
worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for
deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of
Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and
references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6 million Jews and countless others who were
systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the resolution "vows to combat
antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
Additionally, there already is an ongoing ceasefire which has been negotiated in a hostage / prisoner
exchange between the two combatants. What is the purpose of a City resolution calling for a ceasefire if
there already is one?
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
John Pearson
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:06 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:34 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Elyse Feldberg
Email
Address
Orange, California 92869
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
How about reviewing the facts before passing this ridiculous resolution.
Palestinians have been given endless opportunities for peace and five different times to offer to two state solution, which was
rejected every single time.
How do you think the US would react if California was attacked?
Did you forget 911?
You don't have to be Jewish to support Israel, you just have to be human.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:07 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:36 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Julie Holdaway
Email
Address
California 92646
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I have never been so offended as when I was informed that your Council intends to pass a resolution in solidarity with the
Palestinian people using horrendous language demonizing Israel and all Jews. Further inflaming every one of my family
members who have fought and suffered, your council abuses the term "never again". I am appalled at the audacity to threaten
my family, my people, my culture. This is happening in my neighborhood? Where I shop? Where I work? Where I live? Where I
am bringing up my child?
And the biggest lie in the resolution, is hidden away, as you "vow" to combat antisemitism" while embracing and inflaming anti -
Jew trope
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious, genocidal goals.
I will continue to wish the best for my community, putting my words into action. I hope you can say the same.
Julie Holdaway
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:07 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:39 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Jason Weissberg
Email
Address
Tustin, California 92782
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I grew up in Santa Ana, went to Foothill High School, and I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in
Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Thank you,
Jason Weissberg
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:07 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:41 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
saar swartzon
Email
Address
Ste 630
santa ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I urge you to reconsider your misguided Resolution. Not only does it contain many false and misleading statements, but it
continues to perpetuate the antisemitic rhetoric that is currently raging out of control.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:08 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:42 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Laura Cervantes
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92701
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
FULL SUPPORT of Santa Ana City Councilors Vazquez and Hernandez Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire to Tuesday's Santa Ana City Council Meeting. What Israel is doing is genocide. Let's NOT stand by
voiceless and speak for those who cannot. That's what leaders do!
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:08 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:46 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Shelley Borovinsky
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
1
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Shelley Borovinsky
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:08 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:47 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Bruce Reitman
Email
Address
Anaheim, California 92808
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely
Bruce Reitman
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:08 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:48 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Carol Lehrer
Email
Address
FOUNTAIN VALLEY, California 92708-6340
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Please don't support the resolution to support the Palestinians. They voted Hamas as their leader and are paying the price.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:09 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 2:53 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Rebecca Roberts
Email
Address
ORANGE, California 92869-6025
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:10 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:00 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Sylvan Swartz
Email
Address
Villa Par, California 92861
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Re: Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire .
This resolution is the most antisemitic resolution I have ever seen. It is full of total PR from Hamas. The Gaza strip has been
totally under the control of Hamas since the last election there in 2007. They have chosen to build tunnels to attack Israel and
spend their money on weapons of war rather than to help the population. They could have a thriving economy but for their hate
of Jews (see their charter).
I doubt any of you have even been to Gaza or the West Bank to see for yourselves.
Please send me a copy of your indignation resolution against Russia for their atrocities' in Ukraine.
Why the Santa Ana city council feels they have a mandate to pass meaningless resolutions on an international scale is beyond
me. However, you do live in America and you are showing a strong antisemitic streak if you pass this resolution.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:10 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:08 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Todd Litman
Email
Address
Orange, California 92867
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council, I was born and raised in the City of Orange in 1960. 1 have spent a lot of time in Santa Ana having
gone to Santa Ana Junior College, played sports at the Santa Ana Bowl , and gone out to dinner at many of your fine
restaurants. I have a great respect for your City but the actions of Councilors Vazquez and Hernandez has brought shame to
your great city. Your job as City Council is here to govern the great City of Santa Ana and not to politicize actions taking place in
another country, especially when they do not understand the views and lives of all parties involved. I have read the Resolution
they are proposing and it is filled with inflammatory rhetoric that is devisive and one sided. This is a time to come together and
listen to both sides instead spewing Anti -Semitic comments as Councilor Vazquez and Hernandez are doing. Please be strong
and vote this down as responsible leaders of Santa Ana. Thank you for you time. Todd Litman
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:11 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:15 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Gal Sitty
Email
Address
California 92780
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Re: Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire
As a concerned stakeholder in the city of Santa Ana, I urge the council to reject this resolution outright. As I'm sure you are
receiving many messages about the inaccuracies and bias of the resolution itself, I will not address those points specifically and
individually as others have. Rather, I plead with you consider the wellbeing of all residents of Santa Ana, including the Jewish
community who are directly impacted by both Hamas terrorism and rapidly increasing antisemitism in America, including in our
own community. While I do not think it appropriate for any city council to wade so forcefully into foreign policy issues, if the
council does believe it should speak on the war, it should do in consideration of a true peace for all those involved - this requires
demanding an end to the Hamas terror organization rule of Gaza, a terror organization whose leader Yahya Sinwar just today
announced that the massive terrorist assault of October 7th, in which Hamas terrorists murdered, tortured, raped, and kidnapped
thousands of civilians, was just a "dress rehearsal." This terror organization has also cynically used the civilian population as
human shields by waging war from schools, hospitals, mosques, and even children's bedrooms, as has been extensively
documented. In short, should the council it has a place in addressing foreign policy issues that do not apply its jurisdiction,
please do so in consideration of the facts, especially the facts attributed and promulgated by our government through the State
Department, Defense Department, and intelligence agencies. Information readily available from these agencies are in negation
to many claims in the resolution including the claims that Gaza "is one of the most densely populated places on Earth (see CIA
factbook or Wikipedia), that Gaza is "occupied" (See CIA factbook), or that Israel is targeting civilians (see President Biden,
Secretary Blinkin remarks, and White House Spokesperson John Kirby's remarks on that issue).
In order to make sure Santa Ana remains an inclusive city whose government functions for all of its people, I once again urge to
not adopt any resolution that is so filled with falsehoods and greenlights more hateful acts against members of our community.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:12 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:30 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Marci Bruffey
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Using words like appartide promotes hate , fear and anger. Israel has been admonished since it's existence. Since the October
seventh attack anti senitism has increased drastically. Santa Ana's city council is feeding into this hatred.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:12 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:30 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
arielle ohls
Email
Address
Orange, California 92866-2446
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Arielle Ohls
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:12 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:34 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Mark Thompson
Email
Address
Seal Beach, California 90740
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
RE: Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire
I urge the Santa Ana City Council to reject this patently one-sided and unfair resolution
On October 7 Hamas burned alive human beings; beheaded, raped and kidnapped others; murdered children in front of their
parents; parents in front of their children. Young partygoers were hunted down and killed like beasts in the field. Israel's defense
forces, on the other hand, are attacking the enemy but not without first providing Gazan citizens warning to evacuate their
homes, mosques, hospitals, and schools where cowardly Hamas terrorists hide, using their own citizens as human shields.
Israel's is a military operation not remotely comparable to Hamas' premeditated atrocities. To draw a moral equivalency is
completely unwarranted and vile. There is a clear distinction between terrorists and a country's defending army.
Mark Thompson
Cantor Emeritus, Temple Beth Sholom, Santa Ana
1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:13 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:47 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Sean Ohls
Email
Address
Orange, California 92866
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Sean Ohls
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:13 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 3:56 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Daniel Weissberg
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 992705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Daniel L. Weissberg, M.D. FACR
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:22 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:18 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Matthew Lerner
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I wish to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire
to be considered at next Tuesday's meeting.
The resolution:
1. includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided
2. makes a false equivalency between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are
not hostages by any definition
3. uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the
Jewish people
4. distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel on October 7
1
5. weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6 million Jews including
my family and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime
6. "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it
I strongly urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Matthew Lerner
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 8:54 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:43 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Aviva Forster
Email
Address
Corona del Mar, California 92625
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
1
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Aviva Forster
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 8:54 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 4:56 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dennis Linson
Email
Address
ALISO VIEJO, California 92656
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council leaders and members,
I write to you to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023 council meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided:
-The text makes a false equivalency between babies abducted by terrorists as hostages and equates them to actual prisoners
convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition.
-The text uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry
towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold the terror entity of Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent
Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
1
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Rabbi Dennis Linson
Temple Judea
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 8:54 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 5:51 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Paul Groner
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92706
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council and Mayor and mayor Pro-Tem,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people. It
supports terrorists who raped, murdered, tortured, on one day October 7 over 1200 innicent civilians and took hostages of
people including babies, children, womenb, aged. it brings out waves of prejudice and hate against people just because of their
Jewish faith. this incxludes many citizens ofSanta Ana who have made many good contributions to our city. To many citizens of
many generations who have done generations of good for this city and do not deserve this horrid discriminatory act against
them, basically a city backed act of terrorism.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Paul Groner
Am Yisrael Chai,
Rabbi Sharon L. Sobel
Senior Rabbi
Mike Winston
President
Temple Beth Sholom
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent By ShulCloud
Unsubscribe I Manage Preferences
Delivered to
Can't see any pictures?
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 8:59 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 6:17 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Brenda Garcia
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92704
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Thank you do standing in solidarity with Palestine!!!
We will not stand for injustice being pushed by the oppressors.
Sincerely,
A concerned Santa Ana Resident
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 8:59 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 6:59 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Linda WEISSBERG
Email
Address
SANTA ANA, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Linda Weissberg
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:00 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 7:36 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Robin Saltzer
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I work in the City of Santa Ana and this resolution that is being proposed is deeply troubling on so many levels. I write today to
share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be
considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Robin Saltzer
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:00 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 7:39 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Rhea Dorn
Email
19191
California 92612
United States
Map It
Phone
(949)
is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Concerning your Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire. Hamas has held the Palestinian
people in Gaza hostage and have put them at extreme risk by attacking Israel in a viscous manner and took Israeli hostages on
October 7. The Palestinians in Gaza must not be held hostage to the vicious Hamas terrorists any longer. Hamas must be
eliminated from this region. The world has been sending money into this region to help the Palestinians living there. Hamas has
stolen these funds to build up their terrorist organization with arms and tunnels. Fuel and food have been diverted by Hamas for
their own benefit. Please help the Palestinians and free them from Hamas. Thank you for caring for the Palestinians.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:01 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 8:50 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Alexandria Margolis
Email
Address
Corona Del Mar, California 92625
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Orange County, and frankly as an American who respects our western democratic values, I was horrified
to read the proposed anti -Israel resolution slated for a vote at Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting. To see this so close to
home is unsettling.
The massacre that occurred on October 7th was a barbaric act of terrorism by Hamas - the undisputed terror group funded by
Iran. This atrocity is what our city council should be condemning, if anything. The reactive anti-semitism sweeping the globe by
those perversely celebrating such atrocities should be your concern. This 'canary in the coal mine' of escalating extremism at the
USA's front door is what I would expect my representatives to attend to.
Instead you pile on the anti -Israeli rhetoric of 'ceasefire'. What right do you have to bring this matter to the city of Santa Ana? Do
you often call the military strategy of other nations to a local vote? No, only for Israel. Yet they receive none of your compassion.
Have you condemned the mutilation, rape, and murder of the 1,400 Israelis, which included women and children? Have you
demanded the return of the hostages? Have you acknowledged that hostage return is in flight through Israel honoring a
ceasefire that Hamas broke immediately? Of course not - because you care nothing for the human beings who call themselves
Israeli or Palestinian. You've simply been sucked into the wave of Jew hate that treats them all as pawns to be able to question
the existence of Israel.
This is not new. Israel's right to exist has been challenged by its Arab neighbors relentlessly since it became a sovereign nation
in 1948. This is because Israel is the ONLY Jewish nation in the world. The existence of this democracy, which protects
minorities and diversity, is a threat to the maximalist aspirations of Islamic fundamentalist regimes. Iran has spent decades and
millions of dollars infiltrating universities and social media, even the UN - where it ironically now leads the Human Rights council
- to ensure it would have a position to de -legitimize the actions of the ONLY Jewish nation. In questioning the military strategy of
Israel to protect its citizens, you fall into the anti -Zionist trap.
Nothing in this resolution does anything to ensure a better life for Palestinians, Israelis, or frankly the Americans you actually
represent. Its only purpose is to align the city of Santa Ana with the rhetoric of a terror group. In proposing it at all, you inflame
the hate and anti-semitism on display against our Jewish community. To approve it will make you complicit.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:01 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:16 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Carolina Gurwitz
Email
Address
SANTA ANA, California 92707
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council Member,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
1
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Carolina Gurwitz
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:01 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:21 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Yael
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92604
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Irvine, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at Santa
Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame Israel in
the ongoing conflict. While acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating violence
against innocent civilians. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured
nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may
exacerbate tensions and contribute to an anti-Semitic atmosphere. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of
supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
Finally, and just out of curiosity, how often is the Santa Ana respectful council bothered with international conflicts around the
globe?
Sincerely,
Yael
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:02 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:23 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Raquel Unger
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:02 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 10:25 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Susan Nagel
Email
Address
SANTA ANA, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Susan Nagel
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:02 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:13 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dalia Arzanipour
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I write today to share my disgust at the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire
to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting. There was a ceasefire until October 7 when Hamas massacred Israelis and
its visitors. Hamas reportedly attacks Israel and when Israel responds to defend itself, a call for ceasefire is made. Israel
accepts, only to be attacked again and again. Enough is enough!
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses FALSE ana
inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often FALSELY used to justify bigotry towards
the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we must hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Dalia Arzanipour
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:03 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 30, 2023 11:23 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Irwin Rosenfeld
Email
Address
Dana Point, California 92629
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I am opposed to your new curriculum which supports the Palestinian people as opposed to support for Israel. Check the facts:
Israel tried to negotiate with Palestinian leadership on 5 occasions to offer land in exchange for peace, rejected each time
because the Palestinians would not negotiate with Israel, a country they do not recognize, and which they are committed to
destroying because they feel they are entitled to ALL the land in the Middle East. Israel is not anti -Palestinian. Millions of
Palestinians live in Israel in pece with their fellow Israelis, enjoying citizenship, voting power, representation in the Knesset, the
highest level of education of any Palestinian group, full healthcare, and economic security, without any obligation to serve in the
IDF, which other Israelis must do.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:06 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 7:24 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Michelle Simon
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92602
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
As a Santa Ana Unified School District special education teacher, I am deeply concerned about your upcoming resolution to
support Palestinians and Hamas.
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
1
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Michelle Simon
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:06 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 8:32 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
David Feldberg
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
David Feldberg
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 9:07 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 8:45 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
J. Sebag
Email
Address
HUNTINGTON BEACH, California 92647
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I am writing to communicate my great displeasure and profound concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution "Solidarity with the
Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire" to be considered at the December 5, 2023 meeting.
The resolution is divisive and one-sided, ignoring the concerns of other involved parties. It shockingly supports the heinous
actions of the Hamas terrorists on October 7, 2023. There is no equivalence between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to
prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not in any way hostages; they are prisoners jailed for crimes. The proposed
resolution falsely claims ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid. These are not realities and represent trumped up charges to
justify bigotry towards Jewish people.
Understandably, my hearts break at the loss of innocent lives in both Israel and Gaza, and it saddens me to witness the
worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza. However, the true culprits who are guilty for this are the Hamas terrorists, who are to be
held accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way.
The proposed resolution dose not accurately present the facts, nor does it include condemnation of Hamas and its terrorist
1
attack on innocent Israelis and other nationals perpetrated on October 7. The use of the phrase "Never Again" in the resolution is
insulting to the 6 million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazis. Most objectionable is that
the proposed resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject this resolution, which does not represent the beliefs and feelings of the majority of the electorate of our
community, people who you are sworn to serve.
Sincerely,
J. Sebag, MD, FACS, FRCOphth, FARVO
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 11:22 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 9:21 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Lisa Litman
Email
Address
Orange, California 92867
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Lisa Litman
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 11:23 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 11:15 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Danny Prosky
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92603
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Danny Prosky
Araiza, Fatima
From: Nadia Shah <
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 11:50 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Support Palestine resolution
Dear city council, please vote yes to support the Palestine solidarity resolution. You'd be the first city in OC to
side with humanity. Thank you
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 2:10 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 12:01 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Jean Poppa
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92706
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As one of the citizens that you are purportedly representing, I wanted to let you know that I am not supporting solidarity for
Palestine and giving you my 2cents worth requesting that you not vote in solidarity. There is no purpose in stating solidarity other
than to boast power --or to please a group of people --not all citizens of Santa Ana want solidarity with Palestine -it's really a
matter of dealing with a loud group and having the courage to say no. I know this message will be ignored, but my friends (of the
jewish faith) said that non-jewish friends are not sticking up for them, so I'm trying to do it now. The Hamas attack on Oct 7 that
started this was horrible and many lives gone. While the Hamas-Israel war needs to be over and peace reached, it does not help
if Cities in the US start a war among its own citizens over international causes. Look how much hate is going on now in the US
against people ofjewish faith -Is it worth it to you to add fuel to the fire? I hope not. Best regards,
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 2:10 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 12:12 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Coreen Mueller
Email
Address
Trabuco Cyn, California 92679
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Orange County, I am deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote
at Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting.
The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives that unfairly blame Israel in the ongoing conflict. While
acknowledging the tragic loss of life, it's essential to recognize the role of Hamas in initiating violence against innocent civilians
This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured nearly two decades of
Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may exacerbate tensions and
contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere.
I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of supporting a resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 2:11 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 12:24 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Joel Poremba
Email
Address
Laguna Niguel, California 92677
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 2:11 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 12:54 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Sheila Dalva-Hornback
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92603
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
1
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Sheila
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 2:11 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 12:56 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Shelly Aks
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 99703
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a Jewish resident of Santa Ana, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -Israel resolution set for a vote at
Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution appears one-sided, relying on false narratives and lies that unfairly
blame Israel in the ongoing conflict. The tragic loss of thousands people's life caused by Hamas monstrous actions and using
Palestinians civilians and Israeli hostages as human shields is despicable and it's essential you recognize the role of Hamas.
This resolution does not contribute to promoting a better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured nearly two decades of
Hamas rule focused on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may exacerbate tensions and
contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere and as a citizen of Santa Ana I am terrified for myself and my children's life both in my
home and in their school. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of supporting a resolution that aligns with lies
and extreme hate.
Upload a file
• SA-AS-Res.docx
1
Stoo Antisemitic Resolution Now!
Dear Mayor and council members,
12/1/2023
As a Jewish resident of Santa Ana, I was deeply concerned to learn about the proposed anti -
Israel resolution set for a vote at Santa Ana's upcoming city council meeting. The resolution
appears one-sided, relying on false narratives and lies that unfairly blame Israel in the ongoing
conflict. The tragic loss of thousands of people's life caused by Hamas monstrous actions and
Hamas using Palestinians civilians and Israeli hostages as human shields is despicable and it's
essential you recognize the role of Hamas. This resolution does not contribute to promoting a
better life for the people in Gaza, who have endured nearly two decades of Hamas rule focused
on a destructive campaign against Israel. Approving this biased resolution may exacerbate
tensions and contribute to an antisemitic atmosphere and I am terrified for myself and my
children's life. I urge you to reflect on the moral and social implications of supporting a
resolution that aligns with lies and extreme hate.
Thank you!
Shelly Aks
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 2:11 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 2:00 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Lynn Levy
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Lynn Levy
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Friday, December 01, 2023 3:46 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 3:32 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Katalin Szeker
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
The entire resolution is anti-Semitic and racist.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Katalin Szeker
Upload a file
• Letter -Santa-Ana-City-Council 11-30-23.docx
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity
with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be considered at the
December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It
makes a false equivalency between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to
prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It
uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are
all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both
Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At
the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent
Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a
forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel on October 7. It
weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way
that is insulting to the 6 million Jews and countless others who were
systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and
amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Katalin Szeker
Alcala, Abigail
From: R R <clingenet49@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 5:56 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support Palestine Resolution for permanent Ceasefire
Honorable Mayor and City Council Members,
With due respect we urge you to vote for "Support Palestine Resolution" and we are quite sure your City
Council does not want "loss of life to continue anymore" and call for a permanent ceasefire.
Thank you for your continued support of public demand to "STOP loss of life" anywhere in the world.
Muslim Community Service, Inc.
La Mirada Masjid, Board
La Mirada, CA 90638
Alcala, Abigail
From: cynthia thacker <
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 6:20 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19
This resolution is ridiculous for a city council and on top Hamas started the war. They captured Israel and
Americans, kills many and tortured and raped many more.
MOST IMPORTANT. this is not a city council duty. WHAT IS your duty as council is to help fix the city
problems and help your residents.
INNEVIErM
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Sir or Madam,
Sayem <
Friday, December 1, 2023 6:25 PM
eComment
Support Palestine Resolution.
Please consider passing this resolution in support of the genuine struggle of Palestinian people against the racist
occupation of the Zionist state.
Thank you,
y ,.Jl yl "oI "A J-.J "oI
Sayem
Alcala, Abigail
From: Katie Mayberry <
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 6:59 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19
Do not support the cease fire between Israel and Palestine. It's anti-Semit, evil, and outside the scope of our city
council. Don't create conflict in our city. Focus on our safety and basic daily functioning of Santa Ana city
infrastructure.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 1:50 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Resolution to Hamas and Cease Fire
Mayor and Council members,
This resolution should not even come before the City Council meeting and public. This is not part of the duties of a Mayor
or Council members. We have other problems that need full attention of our elected officials. This absurd resolution
should be on elected officials personal media page for expressing their opinions on current events.
Approving this resolution is not the job of a responsible city government.
Alberta Christy
Former City Councilwoman
Alcala, Abigail
From: thezilbermans <
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:00 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Liat Zilberman
Sent from my V rizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
1
Alcala, Abigail
From: liat.m.zilberman <
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:00 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Liat Zilberman
Semi from my Verizon, Samstmg Galaxy smartphone
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Pau <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:01 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Alcala, Abigail
From: Jordana Yechiel <
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:01 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Warm regards
Jordana Reuben Yechiel
Alcala, Abigail
From: liat_zilberman <
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:00 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Liat Zilberman
Semi from my Verizon, Samstmg Galaxy smartphone
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Michael Meerson <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:01 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Michael Meerson
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Natalie Waknine <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:04 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Natalie W.
P.S. The level of ignorance and lack of education on this matter is astounding and very sad. If people educated
themselves on the matter and had any level of intelligence, NO ONE would be against Israel let alone Pro
terrorism. Of course hate and jealousy would also have to be put aside for that. At least you can start with the
above situation. Maybe you'll have some hope.
Senn ftom my T..Mobile .5G Device
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sivan Siman-tov <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:04 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Ilyse Leland <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:09 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Ilyse Leland
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hannah Stern <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:13 PM
eComment
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages. They are not hostages, they are criminals. The United States would never
release violent prisoners in the population knowing that they still intend to commit violence against innocent
civilians and yet this is what Israel is doing in order to save its people. Do not confuse those who where
abducted by Hamas with those who were imprisoned for criminal acts.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
As history has shown, Israel has worked towards, and offered peace many times and the Palestinian leadership
has declined to make peace each time. It is the stated objective of Hamas to kill all Jews.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Hannah Stern
All the best,
Mrs. Stern
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Jordan Cusner <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:14 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David; Phan, Thai
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you!
Jordan Cusner
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
kirshenbaumi <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:17 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from my ( aaxy
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Adi Aharonov <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:18 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Also, there was a ceasefire and Hamas broke it both on October 6th and on November 30th. Asking for a new one is
pathetic at this point.
Thankyou
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Adi Aharonov <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:18 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Also, there was a ceasefire and Hamas broke it both on October 6th and on November 30th. Asking for a new one is
pathetic at this point.
Thankyou
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Debra Panitch <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:19 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Penaloza, David; Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Lopez, Jessie; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you, Debra Reiter
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Dan Kushnir <
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:21 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Dan Kushnir
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karen BarOr <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:25 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
tv iPhone-fin it' M
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Dawn and Kamran Kalaie <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:26 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G iAT Device
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Aylit Schultz <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:21 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Aylit Schultz, MD
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Nbillington95 <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:29 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Natalie Billington
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Raphael Elkayam <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:29 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rikki Mor <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:30 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Rikki Mor
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Pamela Keen <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:30 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you.
P. Keen
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Maybar Durst <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:30 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Best Regards,
Maybar
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:31 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Ita
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
ilana meirovitch <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:31 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Ilana
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Adva Alpert <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:31 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Adva
tv iPhone-fin it' M
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Einat Irelander <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Respectfully,
Einat Irelander
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
David Pitshone <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sandra Elkin Lester <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:33 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tsvia Goren <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:33 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Dassie Feingold <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:35 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Dassie Feingold
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lital Asher - Dotan <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:35 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Lital Asher-Dotan
Alcala, Abigail
From: Donna Griffit <
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:20 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Donna Griffit
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Traci Lerner <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:36 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Enviado desde mi iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sari Ariav <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:37 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Sari
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Howard Feldman <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:37 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Howard Feldman
President, Pioneer Security Services Inc.
Sent from my Whone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Kirsten Vangrofsky <
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:39 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone (please forgive any typos or errors caused by autocorrect).
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Ronen Schwartzman <
Sent:
Saturday, December 2, 2023 5:39 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Melinda Engel <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:39 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
0
Melinda Engel
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Eileen Botvinick <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:40 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Laura Fisher <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:43 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Laura Fisher
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
John Levy <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:45 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Flores, Dora
From: kkalaie <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:45 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Dawn Kalaie
Sent from my Galaxy
Flores, Dora
From:
David Schwartzman <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:45 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
1 am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Karen Tal <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:46 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote No
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Dgoren22 <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:48 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Council members Vazquez
and Hernandez.
I don't understand why the City of Santa Ana needs to pass a declarative resolution. This resolution will not have any
impact other than creating a divide among Sant Ana residents who might come on different side of the issues involved.
Please stick to governing our city. Please worry about safety, crime prevention and the education of our children — that
is what you were elected to do. You were not elected to be involved in affairs of the Middle East, the genocide in Congo,
the atrocities in the Sudan, the torture and ethnic cleaning of the Uyghurs, or the more than 15,000 civilians killed by the
Russians in Ukrainian.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
M B <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:50 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Michael Bitton
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tanya Alpert <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:51 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Tanya Alpert
10
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Kineret Rubin <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:54 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
11
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Dan <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:55 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Dan
12
Flores, Dora
From: Orly Levy <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:55 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire
Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th
Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the
Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of
antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their
atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life
and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The
resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been
internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists
abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and
bombing populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as
has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of
Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the
catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
13
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against
Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize
more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I
believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred
and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Mee
14
Flores, Dora
From:
Ori Snir <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:55 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thanks,
Ori
15
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
River Ben-Giat <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:56 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
River Ben-Giat
16
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
adi.c.eitan <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:58 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards,
Adi Cohen
17
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Shoshi Barkai <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:58 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Shoshi Barkai
18
Flores, Dora
From: Masha Minster <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:59 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
,Dear Council Members
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Masha Minster
Sent from my Whone
19
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tattoo MyRide <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:00 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
20
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hadas Gmail <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:01 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Hadas Dvir
Sent from myiPhone
21
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
The Dear Council Members,
Joanne Hanik <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:02 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
22
Flores, Dora
From: Tippi Denenberg <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:02 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution
submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez. Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath
of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us
have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th
and their aftermath. The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt
by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis
have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on
October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings
and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages. Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire
with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior
Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which
is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays
off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more
violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians. While this resolution may have been introduced
with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
23
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Shani Benjamin <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:05 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Shari Benjamin
24
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Amy Solomon <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:06 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Amy Solomon
25
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tali Klein <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:06 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best,
Talia Klein
26
Flores, Dora
From: Sandra Unterberger <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:13 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Justin M. Paperny
Sent from myiPhone
27
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Marina Chowaiki <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:15 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
28
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rabbi Avi Libman <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:15 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Rabbi Avi Libman
29
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hezy Shalev <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:18 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
30
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Elena Zubarevsky <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:18 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you!
Elena Zubarevsky
31
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
doritbm2000 <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:19 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
32
Flores, Dora
From:
Konya Vivanti <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:21 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
You should focus on the issues in your own city! Homelessness, crime, gangs, recall of council, etc!
I work In local government and am appalled you would expend your time And energy on this issue! Look in your own
community!
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from myiPhone
33
Flores, Dora
From: Merav Shenhar <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:25 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Merav Shenhar
34
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hudi Eshel <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:34 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Peace to the world
Hudi Eshel
35
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:37 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Craig
Sent from myiPhone
36
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:37 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
37
Flores, Dora
From: Elisheva Halevy <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:38 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Elisheva Halevy
Sent from myiPhone
38
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Leigh Choueke <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:45 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
39
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Yafit <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:46 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
40
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Yaffa Rosner <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:46 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Yaffa Rosner, LMFT
41
Flores, Dora
From:
lisa link <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:47 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
42
Flores, Dora
From: Melina Dworsky <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:51 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
43
Flores, Dora
From: Barank <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:51 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Iris Barank
Sent from myiPhone
44
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
tali brauman <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:59 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
45
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karina Kozinsky <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 7:03 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
46
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hila Gadot <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 7:03 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
47
Flores, Dora
From: Juliette Landesman <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 7:10 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa
Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Juliette Landesman
Sent from myiPhone
48
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Avi Gerassi <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 7:12 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Avi Gerassi
Sent from myiPhone
49
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Saturday, December 02, 2023 7:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Liz Carnes
50
Flores, Dora
From: Ilanit <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 7:33 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution
submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez. Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath
of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us
have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th
and their aftermath. The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt
by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis
have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on
October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings
and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages. Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire
with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior
Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which
is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays
off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more
violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians. While this resolution may have been introduced
with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
51
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
JACOB WAKSHLAG <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 8:02 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
-- Jack
52
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karen Kalina <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:06 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Karen Kalina
53
Flores, Dora
From: amanda horowitz <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 8:17 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Public comment - Support Palestine Resolution
Hello,
My name is Amanda Horowitz. Please vote to support Palestinian people as they are being subjected to a
genocide. Please call for a permanent ceasefire and unlimited aid being able to enter Gaza. Please oppose any
additional funding or weapons being sent to Israel for this genocide.
Thank you,
Amanda Horowitz
54
Flores, Dora
From:
Rita Fainaru <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:27 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
,Dear Council Members
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
55
Flores, Dora
From: Dorit Hermann <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 8:27 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
INSTEAD OF DEMANDING ISRAEL MAINTAIN A CEASEFIRE, (WHICH IT DID AND HAMAS PREDICTABLY VIOLATED IT
SEVERAL TIMES)— HOW ABOUT DEMANDING HAMAS FREE OUR HOSTAGES, WHO ARE BEING TORTURED RIGHT NOW.
Sent from myiPhone
56
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Miriam Hermann <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:29 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
M Hermann
57
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Deborah Gruen <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:41 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Deborah Gruen
58
Flores, Dora
From: Lynne Eisenstein <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:41 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone,
Voice 2 Text... S o rry4 E r ro rs.
59
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Elanit Abrams <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:54 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best,
Elanit Abrams
60
Flores, Dora
From:
T N <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:54 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Tammy Greenspan
61
Flores, Dora
From: Shlomi Barsheshet <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 8:54 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
62
Flores, Dora
From: stephanie macdonald <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:55 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Stephanie MacDonald
Sent from myiPhone
63
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hannah Bowers <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:56 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you!
91
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Ilana Umansky <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 5:56 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards,
Ilana U
65
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tina Nissim <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:00 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Orit Ravid <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:00 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Orit Ravid
67
Flores, Dora
From: DANIEL DAVIDOVICZ <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:01 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
m
Flores, Dora
From: limor lehavi <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:02 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Item Agenda #19
Attachments: Shameful Resolution.pdf
Comment regarding Item Agenda #19:
This resolution is a shameful example of overreach by an overzealous Santa Ana City Council, and reads more like a
poorly edited Arab/Palestinian propaganda piece published by Al Jazeera, than a measured response to an
injustice. The wording of the resolution itself, "Solidarity with the Palestinian People in support of a Ceasefire" is
problematic. Since this latest conflict between Israel and the Palestinians concerns only Palestinians from Gaza, it would
be far more accurate to say "Palestinian People of Gaza." Gaza, as opposed to the West Bank, has its own democratically
elected leadership - Hamas. Does the City of Santa Ana wish to align itself with the Palestinian people of Gaza who
through their active support of Hamas, openly endorse the ethnic cleansing of the Jewish people from all of Palestine?
Have the members of the Santa Ana City Council even read the Hamas charter? Does the City of Santa Ana really want to
go on record as having solidarity with an Islamist authoritarian regime that abhors all the values we cherish in the West?
The majority of Palestinian people in Gaza support the murder and/or imprisonment of anyone who identifies
themselves as part of the LGBTQ community. Does solidarity with the Palestinian people mean that the City of Santa Ana
supports this policy? The majority of the Palestinian people of Gaza are against freedom of expression and speech that
does not conform to Islamic law. Islamic law as constituted in Gaza, does not allow for the equality for women, the rule
of international law, or freedom of religion.
Besides mirroring anti-Western, and anti -Israeli Palestinian propaganda, this resolution keeps repeating the falsehood
that Gaza is still occupied by Israel. It talks about releasing all the hostages, Palestinian as well as Israeli, without
mentioning that Israel is trading Palestinian criminals, who actually have committed some sort of violent offense, for
Israeli hostages whose only crime was being on the Jewish side of the Gaza/Israel fence. It keeps referring to Gaza as
being "an open air prison" as if this was not a choice made by the Palestinian residents of Gaza. It also falsely refers to
Israel as an "apartheid" State, as if the 2.2 million Arab Israeli citizens who are free to vote, hold elective office, and can
become members of the Israeli Supreme Court, somehow do not matter. Does the fact that Israeli Arabs have more
rights within the State of Israel than in any Arab majority nation suggest an alternative to this false Palestinian narrative?
Israel completely withdrew from Gaza in August of 2005. The Palestinians who moved into this territory immediately
after, inherited one of the fastest growing real estate markets in the entire middle east (a basic Google search of
Newspapers from June 2005 all the way until early 2006 will support this fact). In 2006, the Palestinian people in vast
numbers rejected this economic windfall by democratically electing a terrorist organization with a platform that
promised to eliminate all the Jews in Palestine — "from the river to the sea." It was only after the elected representatives
of the Palestinian people of Gaza turned their newly acquired territory into a military base of operations in order to
terrorize their Jewish neighbor, that Israel was forced to target the missile launchers and Hamas command centers
deliberately embedded in civilian populations, schools, and hospitals.
With this resolution, the City of Santa Ana has taken an explicitly anti -Israel position that not only is completely one-
sided, but goes so far as to misrepresent or completely ignore the factual record. It makes claims that appear to be
deliberately false. Furthermore, by declaring "solidarity" with the "Palestinian People" of Gaza, the City of Santa Ana had
given tacit support to the elimination of the Jewish State. Just in the past year, anti-Semitism has increased by 400
percent. Both of our Jewish children attend OCSA in Santa Ana, and already have had to endure the anxiety that
accompanied the recent desecration of school property with painted swastikas. Those Palestinians who attacked
Southern Israel from Gaza on the 71h of October were barbarians. Full stop. When these barbarians returned to Gaza
with 247 hostages, the Palestinian people of Gaza celebrated them as heroes with cries of jubilation all down the Gaza
01
strip, taunting and physically assaulting these innocent Israelis as they made their way through this mass of inhumanity.
There is no moral equivalency between the cult of death that is Hamas and the IDF, which warns civilians where and
when they are going to launch an attack. There is no moral equivalency between the Palestinian people of Gaza who
celebrate the murder, rape and torture of women and children, with the citizens of Israel, who are horrified by the death
of Palestinian children that died because their parents voted for a cult of Death to rule over them. Israel cannot be free
until Hamas control over Gaza is completely nullified. If Hamas is not willing to release the remaining hostages, there can
be no ceasefire. The Palestinian people cannot be free until they are ready to choose life over death. As to this
resolution being proposed by the Santa Ana City Council, it will have zero impact on events in the middle east, or for that
matter, in Washington DC. Our real concern is that by giving Palestinian propaganda a platform from which to launch
even more anti-Jewish hatred, this resolution could have a potentially dangerous impact locally— not just for Jews, but
for increasing hatred within the community at large.
Limor Lehavi and Stephen Sprague
70
Flores, Dora
From: Limor Danai <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:02 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Limor
Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Get Outlook for Android
71
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Danna Regev <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 6:53 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
- Donna Regev
72
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
ileana slavin <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:15 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best,
Ileana Slavin
Sent from myiPhone
73
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
DB Yahoo <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:16 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
74
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
denisita13 <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:17 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
75
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Debbie Massry <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:17 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Gracias
Debbie
Sent from myiPhone
76
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Josh S. <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:22 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best Regards
Sigal Sherman
77
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Reina Shteremberg <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:25 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely
Reina Shteremberg
76
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Darren Youngleson <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:25 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
79
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hanna Barniv <
December 02, 2023 9:30 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thanks,
Hanna Tagger
Sent from myiPhone
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
David C Michan <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely
David Michan
Sent from myiPhone
81
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Uri Shapen <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
82
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
DEENA SWIDLER <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Deena Swidler
Sent from myiPhone
83
Flores, Dora
From: Eduardo Sneider <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:32 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Eduardo
84
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Liza Tacher <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:39 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Liza Tacher
#BringThemAllHomeNow
#IsisHamas
#StopAntisemitism
#StopJewishHate
Sent from myiPhone
85
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Youval Dar <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:40 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
86
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Mike Spilky <
December 02, 2023 9:41 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Mike Spilky I President
Location Matters Inc.
dl858-
locationmafters.com
Sent from my iPhone
87
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sivan Hecht <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:42 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sivan Hecht
99
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Ken Solnit <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:43 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Yours truly,
Kenneth Solnit
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Elisheva <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:46 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from Elisheva's (Phone
m
Flores, Dora
From: Susana Corrigan<
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:47 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Susana Corrigan
91
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Bernard Wosk <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:55 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Dr. Bernard Wosk
Sent from myiPhone
92
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Irene Nosrati <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 9:59 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
93
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Daniel G <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 10:10 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Daniel Vann
91
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Saturday, December 02, 2023 10:20 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez. I would also like to remind you that there was a cease-fire on October 6 that Hamas broke. they also
broke the latest cease-fire last week.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Shelley Saban
Sent from myiPhone
95
Flores, Dora
From: Noga Villalon <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 10:34 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
,Dear Council Members
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Noga Villalon
Sent from my Whone
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Jacky Schon <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 10:49 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
97
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Keren seker gafni <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 10:54 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Keren Seker Gafni
Sent from myiPhone
99
Flores, Dora
From:
Jackie Bisch <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 11:03 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Jackie Bisch
Sent from myiPhone
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Henry Michan <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 11:10 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
100
Flores, Dora
From:
Debbie <
Sent:
Saturday, December 02, 2023 11:15 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Deborah Bank
Sent from myiPhone
101
Flores, Dora
From: Dror Levy <
Sent: Saturday, December 02, 2023 11:43 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
This is a personal appeal - Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
102
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rebeca Adato <
Saturday, December 02, 2023 11:55 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
103
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Moni Stern <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 12:00 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Get Outlook for Android
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sunday, December 03, 2023 12:32 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Iris Gold
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Galina Bukh <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 1:25 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Get Outlook for Android
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Yael Turok <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 3:52 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Natalie Blank <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 4:18 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Farida Kassin <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 5:10 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Farida kassin
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tal Lachmann <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 5:14 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath, including the violent rape of
women and beheading of children.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you for seeing the light.
Tal
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
BatSheva Allen <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 5:23 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
People around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the
single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of
antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of
antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have explicitly indicated their
intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the world and Israel of Jews, they want global genocide. Hamas
is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is
possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Patricia Beer <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 5:37 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Mina Rasis <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 5:48 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thanks
Mina
10
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Janine <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 6:01 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
11
Flores, Dora
From:
David Fuchs <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 6:12 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
You Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
lol
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
12
Flores, Dora
From:
YANA KATZAP-NACKMAN <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 6:28 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Respectfully,
Yana Katzap-Nackman
13
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nora silberstein <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 6:39 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Nora Silberstein
14
Flores, Dora
From:
Tal Shuster <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 6:44 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Tal Shuster
Sent from myiPhone
15
Flores, Dora
From:
Tal Shuster <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 6:47 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Tal Shuster
Sent from myiPhone
16
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karen Jaffe <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:05 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
17
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karen Jaffe <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:05 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Karen Jaffe
18
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Ofer Krichman <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:08 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
,Regards
Ofer Krichman
19
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nora Vinograd <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:25 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
20
Flores, Dora
From:
Jena Tell <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:36 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution
submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez. Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath
of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us
have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th
and their aftermath. The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt
by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis
have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on
October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings
and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages. Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire
with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior
Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which
is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays
off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more
violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians. While this resolution may have been introduced
with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Jena Tell
21
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Avital Levy <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:38 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you for your attention and help in this matter!
Sincerely,
Avital Levy
22
Flores, Dora
From:
Lilly Flores <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:38 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath. Again, adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn
Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their
aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
23
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
liana Gold <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:43 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Ilana Gold
24
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Fred Keivanfar <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:47 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
25
Flores, Dora
From:
Barbara Schwartz <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:52 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best, Barbara Schwartz
Sent from myiPhone
26
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Julie <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:51 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
julie
Sent from myiPhone
27
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:50 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
28
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rakefet Abergel <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:54 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Rakefet Abergel
29
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sarah Marsh <
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sarah Marsh
Sent from myiPhone
30
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hayley Frankel <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:17 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
31
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sarit Mochtar <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 2:15 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Sarit Gandin
32
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Aza Squarer <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:25 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Aza Squarer
33
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
gabriela dondisch <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:28 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
34
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
genyagamburg <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:37 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
35
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Dana <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:51 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Dana Ben-Artzi
Sent from myiPhone
36
Flores, Dora
From: Pepper <
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:52 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Your policy on Israel is absurd!
City Council members of Santa Ana - it has just come to my attention that the city council will be voting on whether to
adopt a policy against Israel that would condemn the state of Israel for the ethnic cleansing of Palestinian people. This is
the most ridiculous, and in my opinion, evil thing that a city council could do. You are in effect supporting a terrorist
regime that is opposed to democracy, human rights, and supporting the Hamas regime which represents and terrorizes
its own people- the Palestinians — Hamas align itself with the worst human rights violator in the world — Russia. In fact,
Hamas aligned themselves with Russia recently when they announced they were releasing two Russian Israeli civilians
that they held hostage. Upon their release they stated that they were releasing the Russians because Russia has been
in support of their terrorism.
Hamas documented their own war crimes this year beginning October 7 when they broke a ceasefire in order to
butcher, rape, burn, murder and kidnap 1400 women, children, the elderly and babies! Of the 1400 - over 200 were
taken hostage and many are being held now and used as human shields along with their own civilian population.
You are cowardly and corrupt people on the council if you think that supporting terrorists over Israel (the only
democratic country in the Middle East), is the way to help the people of Gaza. You are sending a powerful promotional
message to Hamas - these violators of human rights who continue to violate them and to promote policies and activities
that will ensure the subjugation of women and the murder of LGBTQAI + people within their borders. It is not too late
to reverse course to educate yourselves on the issues at hand, and the history, which sadly has caused the death of
many innocent people - and this situation could be reversed if the people of Gaza want to live peacefully within a
multicultural pluralistic democratic country - they must stop taking foreign aid and instruction from an international
terrorist Association affiliated with the Muslim brotherhood including the country of Iran.
I am the mother of a 19-year-old who was killed in an act of hate by a white supremacist - and I am absolutely horrified
to see what you were doing. I will not support the campaign of any of the people on your council who seek higher office,
and will do everything in my power to make sure that you are all exposed for the evil that you are perpetrating here.
Jeanne Pepper
Sent from my iPhone
37
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:00 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
38
Flores, Dora
From:
Wendy Zuckerberg <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:06 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Wendy Z
39
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Guri Weinberg <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:14 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
G Weinberg
Sent from myiPhone
40
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sofia Minevich <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:15 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sofia Minevich
Sent from myiPhone
41
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lillian <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:22 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Lillian M
Sent from myiPhone
42
Flores, Dora
From:
Lillian Miselewicz <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:22 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Lillian M
Sent from myiPhone
43
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Israel Furmansky <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:22 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
44
Flores, Dora
From:
Alona Korol <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:49 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
,Dear Council Members
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
45
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Jill Cutler <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 10:01 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Jill Cutler
46
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Igor Polevoy <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 10:13 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
47
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Mira Shiloach <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 10:17 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Mira Shiloach
Skokie, IL
48
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Joan Marks <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 10:44 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
joan
49
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Robin Katz <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 11:28 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Robin Katz
53
Flores, Dora
From: Ahron <
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 11:32 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from myiPhone
54
Flores, Dora
From: David Schwartz <
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 11:43 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
—David Schwartz
Sent from myiPhone
55
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
alicia chiriti <
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alicia Chiriti
56
Flores, Dora
From: Romi Neustadt <
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 12:49 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Romi Neustadt
57
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Dalit Lewis <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 12:52 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their
atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards,
Dalit Lewis
58
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lena Yasterzon <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 1:38 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
59
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Susan Segal <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 1:47 PM
eComment
Resolution for a cease fire in Gaza
I respectfully urge you to vote no on this resolution, which does so much more than just call for a ceasefire, but rather
echoes Hamas—an internally recognized terrorist organization —talking points. Nowhere in this resolution is the
acknowledgment that Hamas started this war on October 7 by invading Israel and visiting atrocities on its citizens, killing
over 1200 of them —the equivalent of 50,000 Americans —and taking hundreds hostage, where they have endured
torture and starvation.
The war could end tomorrow, and innocent Palestinian lives could be saved if Hamas surrendered and returned the
remaining hostages.
People are entitled to their political opinions. They are entitled to be willfully blind to the facts, to espouse a cause they
clearly know little about, etc. etc. However, it is not appropriate for city council representing a city on the other side of
the world from the Middle East, a city whose citizens have little stake in what is happening (or if, as this resolution
argues, they DO have a stake, have very little insight or knowledge as to the true state of affairs there) to declare
unequivocal support for a terrorist organization over a sovereign nation.
A no vote is the only ethical option.
Sincerely,
Susan Segal
m
Flores, Dora
From: Brian Mandel, Esq. <brian@brianmandellaw.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 2:10 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Anti -Israel resolution
How dare the Santa Ana city council even consider a vile, hateful, divisive resolution that supports the Hamas terrorist
organization!
First, what business is it of the Santa Ana city council? Every citizen in Santa Ana can petition his or her US
representative or Senator to express views on what is going in in Israel; the resolution before the Santa Ana city council
is little more that an effort to mobilize anti Semitic elements in the community. International events are clearly not a
legitimate the domain of a small, local city council.
Second, the resolution charges Israel with "ethnic cleansing" and war crimes. Both are ludicrous positions, which
demonstrate either the outright ignorance or willful hatred of Israel by their proponents. There are many times as many
inhabitants of Gaza now than when Israel initially took control; Israel must be the worst ethnic cleanser in
history. Unfortunately, Arab states such as Iran, Iraq, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Sudan, Yemen, Morocco, etc. have been
quite good at ethnic cleansing of Jews, since there are hardly any significant Jewish populations in those countries as
they were all forcibly expelled in 1948.
Nor is it a war crime for a country to defend itself from murderous, viscous attacks by hateful barbarians. On October 7,
2023 it was Hamas that committed not only war crimes but crimes against humanity! Israel takes great pains to
minimize civilian casualties, unlike Hames that targets Israeli civilians and then uses its own citizens as human
shields. And lets not forget that Hamas kidnaps infants, children, and old ladies to use as hostages, also a war crime.
The Santa Ana city council did not introduce a resolution condemning Syria during their ongoing civil war, which has
killed over 500,000 civilians. Nor have they accused Russia of "ethnic cleansing" for bombing civilian targets in
Ukraine. The list of worthy transgressors is long, but it seems that Santa Ana is only concerned with how the only Jewish
state, tiny Israel, defends itself. What a bunch of hypocrites!
The resolution must fail.
Sincerely,
Brian S. Mandel
Certified Specialist in Estate Planning„ Trust, and Probate Law*
The Law Offices of Brian S. Mandel, Inc.
NEW OFFICE LOCATION:
24031 El Toro Road, Suite 210
Laguna Hills, CA 92653
Telephone (949) 660-0007
Facsimile (949) 660-0009
Email: Brian@Brianmandellaw.com
Web: www.Briamnandefaw.com
* The California State Bar Board of Legal Specialization
61
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: THIS MESSAGE IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE USE OF THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS
ADDRESSED, AND MAY CONTAIN INFORMATION THAT IS PRIVILEGED, CONFIDENTIAL, AND EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE
UNDER APPLICABLE LAW. IF THE READER OF THIS MESSAGE IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, OR THE EMPLOYEE OR
AGENT RESPONSIBLE FOR DELIVERING THIS MESSAGE TO THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT
DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION, OR COPYING OF THIS COMMUNICATION IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED
THIS COMMUNICATION IN ERROR, PLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY BY EMAIL AND DELETE THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE.
IRS Circular 230 Disclosure:
To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the U.S. Department of the Treasury and Internal Revenue Service, we inform you that any tax
advice contained in this e-mail (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and may not be used, for the purpose of (a) avoiding
penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (b) promoting, marketing, or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed
herein.
62
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Jodi Rothman <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 2:12 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
PLEASE vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Jodi Rothman
Leah Rothman
Samuel Rothman
Lindsay Rothman
63
Flores, Dora
From:
Elysa Todd <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 2:44 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Elysa Todd
#endjewhate
Sent from myiPhone
91
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hilary Bowers <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 2:52 PM
eComment
URGENT - Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Warmly,
Hilary Bowers
65
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Allison Binder <allison@ggssc.com>
Sunday, December 03, 2023 3:43 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
All the best,
Allison
ALLISON IL BINDER
Goodman Genow Schenkman
Smelkinson + Christopher, LLP
9665 Wilshire Blvd Fifth Floor
Beverly Hills I CA 90212
Ph: 310.385.9300 ext.665
66
Mobile: 323.377.4949
Email: allisongggssc.com
This communication, including any documents, files or previous e-mail messages attached to it, may include
information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient,
please note that any dissemination, distribution, copying or use of this communication, or any of the
information contained in or attached to it, is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you are not the intended
recipient, please notify the sender by immediately replying to this message or notifying the sender by telephone
and then delete this communication and its attachments from your system without reading or saving in any
manner
ReFrame, a collaborative project of @womeninfilm and @sundanceorg,
has launched ReFrame ReSource: an online hub of culture change tools
for screen industry professionals. Visit htips://www.reframeproject.org/ to
explore. #ReFrameReSource
67
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Cary Rubenfeld <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 4:25 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
66
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Debra Feiler <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 4:34 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
69
Flores, Dora
From:
missidvisious <
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 5:45 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Kindly,
Rachael Morua
LySent from my iPhone +@
70
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Oded Berson <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:50 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
71
Flores, Dora
From: John Dade <
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 7:52 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19
Hello Santa Ana City Council,
What!? How about you take care of your city and its
residents and their needs first instead of trying to take a stance
on a global issue that is truly out of your control and outside
of your area of concern.
Stop virtue signaling.
Sincerely,
John Dade
OC Resident
72
Flores, Dora
From: iris goldman <
Sent: Sunday, December 03, 2023 8:19 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Opposition to Agenda item #19 Ceasefire Resolution by city of Santa Ana
Attn: Council member Benjamin Vazquez and Johnathan Hernandez,
Opposition to agenda item #19 by the City of Santa Ana City Council
This resolution is a shameful example of overreach by an overzealous Santa Ana City Council, and reads more like
a poorly edited Arab/Palestinian propaganda piece published by Al Jazeera, than a measured response to an
injustice. The wording of the resolution itself, "Solidarity with the Palestinian People in support of a Ceasefire" is
problematic. Since this latest conflict between Israel and the Palestinians concerns only Palestinians from Gaza, it
would be far more accurate to say "Palestinian People of Gaza." Gaza, as opposed to the West Bank, has its own
democratically elected leadership - Hamas. Does the City of Santa Ana wish to align itself with the Palestinian
people of Gaza who through their active support of Hamas, openly endorse the ethnic cleansing of the Jewish
people from all of Palestine? Have the members of the Santa Ana City Council even read the Hamas Charter? Does
the City of Santa Ana really want to go on record as having solidarity with an Islamist authoritarian regime that
abhors all the values we cherish in the West? The majority of Palestinian people in Gaza support the murder and/or
imprisonment of anyone who identifies themselves as part of the LGBTQ community. Does solidarity with the
Palestinian people mean that the City of Santa Ana supports this policy? The majority of the Palestinian people of
Gaza are against freedom of expression and speech that does not conform to Islamic law. Islamic law as constituted
in Gaza, does not allow for the equality for women, the rule of international law, or freedom of religion.
Besides mirroring anti-Western, and anti -Israeli Palestinian propaganda, this resolution keeps repeating the
falsehood that Gaza is still occupied by Israel. It talks about releasing all the hostages, Palestinian as well as Israeli,
without mentioning that Israel is trading Palestinian criminals, who actually have committed some sort of violent
offense, for Israeli hostages who's only crime was being on the Jewish side of the Gaza/Israel fence. It keeps
referring to Gaza as being "an open air prison" as if this was not a choice made by the Palestinian residents of
Gaza. It also falsely refers to Israel as an "apartheid" State, as if the 2.2 million Arab Israeli citizens who are free to
vote, hold elective office, and can become members of the Israeli Supreme Court, somehow do not matter. Does the
fact that Israeli Arabs have more rights within the State of Israel than in any Arab majority nation suggest an
alternative to this false Palestinian narrative? Israel completely withdrew from Gaza in August of 2005. The
Palestinians who moved into this territory immediately after, inherited one of the fastest growing real estate markets
in the entire middle east (a basic Google search of Newspapers from June 2005 all the way until early 2006 will
support this fact). In 2006, the Palestinian people in vast numbers rejected this economic windfall by democratically
electing a terrorist organization with a platform that promised to eliminate all the Jews in Palestine — "from the river
to the sea." It was only after the elected representatives of the Palestinian people of Gaza turned their newly
acquired territory into a military base of operations in order to terrorize their Jewish neighbor, that Israel was forced
to target the missile launchers and Hamas command centers deliberately embedded in civilian populations, schools,
and hospitals.
With this resolution, the City of Santa Ana has taken an explicitly anti -Israel position that not only is completely one-
sided, but goes so far as to misrepresent or completely ignore the factual record. It makes claims that appear to be
deliberately false. Furthermore, by declaring "solidarity" with the "Palestinian People" of Gaza, the City of Santa Ana
had given tacit support to the elimination of the Jewish State. Just in the past year, anti-Semitism has increased by
400 percent. Those Palestinians who attacked Southern Israel from Gaza on the 7th of October were barbarians.
Full stop. When these barbarians returned to Gaza with 247 hostages, the Palestinian people of Gaza celebrated
them as heroes with cries of jubilation all down the Gaza strip, taunting and physically assaulting these innocent
Israelis as they made their way through this mass of inhumanity. There is no moral equivalency between the cult of
death that is Hamas and the IDF, which warns civilians where and when they are going to launch an attack. There is
no moral equivalency between the Palestinian people of Gaza who celebrate the murder, rape and torture of women
73
and children, with the citizens of Israel, who are horrified by the death of Palestinian children that died because their
parents voted for a cult of Death to rule over them. Israel cannot be free until Hamas control over Gaza is
completely nullified. If Hamas is not willing to release the remaining hostages, there can be no ceasefire. The
Palestinian people cannot be free until they are ready to choose life over death. As to this resolution being proposed
by the Santa Ana City Council, it will have zero impact on events in the middle east, or for that matter, in
Washington DC. My real concern is that by giving Palestinian propaganda a platform from which to launch even
more anti-Jewish hatred, this resolution could have a potentially dangerous impact locally — not just for Jews, but for
increasing hatred within the community at large.
We would love to have open conversation with all the council members for a quick dive into the region history and a
general discussion of the situation because we know you can do better than the "draft only" template resolution
copy.
Thank you for taking the time to read our letter.
Iris Goldman
74
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:41 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
75
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lara Kaplan <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:51 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
76
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
J O <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 9:52 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Life is an exercise in constrained optimization.... Carpe diem!
If this message contains any typos, please note it was sent from my Whone.
77
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
david shteremberg <
Sunday, December 03, 2023 10:13 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
David Shteremberg
76
Flores, Dora
From: liat_zilberman <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 4:19 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Agenda Item 19
Dear Santa Ana City Council Members,
Please vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution. For the reasons I'm about to explain, as it is drafted, this proposed
resolution is a reprehensible idea guaranteed to (1) harm the local Jewish population and (2) have absolutely no
impact on events in the Middle East. There is no ethical or moral justification for approving such a deleterious
measure ... unless the council's goal is to physically and mentally harm Jews, a minority group already
suffering from marked bigotry and discrimination.
Please note: (i) I am not able to find a copy of the proposed resolution online. I am therefore relying on a
summary provided by another resolution opponent. His summary might or might not be accurate or complete.
The unavailability of the text leads me to wonder whether the council has complied with due process and all
other legal requirements for promulgating resolutions. (ii) Why does the council think this is an appropriate
resolution subject for the City of Santa Ana? This city has lots of problems to address, but there are no bombs
falling in or near the city limits. Does the council have constituents who are Hamas members? Has the council
also weighed in on conflicts involving the Rohingya people in Myanmar, the Uyghurs in China, Sudan,
Venezuela, Colombia, Syria, Iraq, and Ethiopia?
ERRONEOUSTEXT
Assuming I have been adequately informed about the resolution content, the resolution contains several glaring
misstatements. Does this council really want to go on record as making erroneous statements of fact and law?
Error #1: I understand the resolution faults Israel for a war that was started by Hamas. Speaking as an attorney
specializing in international law, I can tell you that's an embarrassingly nonsensical, indefensible position.
Error #2: I understand the resolution uses the term "hostages" to describe inmates in Israeli prisons. These
inmates are (1) individuals convicted of crimes, e.g., bombings, attempted bombings, and stabbings of Israeli
citizens (21% of whom are Arab Israelis, and who, collectively, consist of a wide variety of races and
ethnicities) or
(2) administrative detainees (like U.S. terror suspects held at Guantanamo Bay). Under international law, these
inmates are not hostages. I don't know where you are getting your information about these matters, but you need
to vet your sources better.
Error #3: I understand the resolution uses the term "ethnic cleansing." While someone could righteously take
issue with the alleged number of civilian casualties in this conflict (a complicated topic), Israel is not doing
anything that qualifies as "ethnic cleansing." Here is a graphic that provides a simplistic but accurate illustration
of what is and is not ethnic cleansing.
[a chart]
Apartheid and Genocide: I do not know whether the proposed resolution uses these terms. If it does, then please
be advised that Israel is not doing either of these things. I can provide detailed legal explanations if anyone is
interested.
79
ONE-SIDED, HYPOCRITICAL RESOLUTION
I understand the proposed resolution (1) fails to condemn Hamas for its October 7th atrocities; (2) refuses to
recognize that a civilized, moral society cannot ever permit intentional and gruesome crimes committed against
innocent civilians, e.g., murder, torture, rape, mayhem, and public desecration of victims' bodies; (3) neglects to
demand the immediate return of Israeli hostages; (4) does not insist upon an immediate surrender by Hamas
wrongdoers; and (5) declines to plead for peace negotiations. In other words, the resolution expresses concern
about innocent Gazan civilians (which is fine) but [i] refuses express corresponding concern about innocent
Israeli citizens (which is an appalling double -standard) and [ii] indicates no desire to see a viable long-term
resolution to the ongoing conflict. So, the council's proposed resolution is the quintessence of hypocrisy. A
moral, ethical person would express concern about all the innocent victims and would seek a solution. Such
one-sidedness reflects prejudice and discrimination by this council. Is this council really that depraved and
immoral? Does this council truly reject fundamental notions of DEI? By adopting this resolution, this council
will be telling the world that Santa Ana is an ugly place that approves of bigotry and unfairness.
The proposed resolution is sadly consistent with the local school district's misstep in illegally adopting a
discriminatory ethnic studies curriculum geared to indoctrinate the next generation of Jew -haters. I cannot speak
for the school district's legal counsel, but if I were that attorney, I would be begging the council to drop the
resolution. It just makes Santa Ana look like a hotbed of Jew -hate and would give the plaintiffs' attorneys more
evidence.
CONTEXT & HARM
Jews worldwide are still reeling from the October 7th Hamas atrocities - the single deadliest day for Jews since
the Holocaust. It's personal for us: every Jew knows someone who was massacred or kidnapped. If that weren't
enough, many of us have experienced and/or witnessed recent acts of antisemitism, and we live in fear of
increasingly violent and unlawful protest activity. Indeed, Nazi Germany has been reincarnated here in 21 st
Century Southern California. Resolutions like yours encourage Jew -haters to do more to harass and harm local
Jews ... and why? We American Jews have no control over events that in Israel. None, whatsoever. So, your
efforts would increase Jew -hate and Jew harm but with no corresponding benefit (as if there ever could be a
benefit from bigotry).
CONTEXT & INEFFECTUALITY
Ceasefire resolutions might be a trendy far -left public gesture, but they affect nothing in the Middle East.
Backstory and context: on a nearly -nonstop basis since 2007, Hamas has been lobbing rockets toward civilian
areas in Israel. On October 7th, Hamas took its civilian death campaign to a diabolical new level. It was the
proverbial straw that broke the camel's back.
Like any nation, Israel has a fiduciary and ethical obligation to protect its diverse citizenship. Given the heinous
new heights of the most recent Hamas offensive, Israel has understandably determined that Hamas must be
wiped out. Accordingly, Israel has important military objectives: (1) destroy Hamas' war machine; (2)
neutralize Hamas personnel; (3) rescue hostages; (4) minimize civilian casualties (notwithstanding Hamas'
dedicated human shield tactics). In the context of Israel's important obligations to its own people, what makes
this council think Israel cares about the Santa Ana city council's desire for a ceasefire? Especially when this
council's resolution demonstrates one-sided, hypocritical bigotry and an utter lack of concern about innocent
Israelis? Pro tip: Israel could not care less about the desires of the Santa Ana city council, especially if the
council is sending a bigoted, one-sided, unhelpful message.
[CONTINUED] ........................................
HISTORY & PERSPECTIVE
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. Unfortunately, the historical record demonstrates that a ceasefire
m
ultimately will (1) prolong the war and (2) escalate bilateral casualties.
Senior Humus leaders have clearly said they intend to attack Israel again and again until they eradicate Israel
and all the Jews therein. See, e.g., https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/hamas-official-
vows-to-repeat-oct-7-attack-repeatedly-to-teach-israel-a-lesson/articleshow/ 104903949.cros
Humus is the sole cause of all Palestinian and Israeli casualties. See, e.g.,
https://www.fdd.org/podcasts/2023/12/01/what-hamas-believes/
The people of Gaza deserve a better future; this will be possible only when Humus is gone.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, it would do only bad things: (1) harm
local Jews, (2) add more fuel to an already -raging inferno of hatred and conflict, and (3) publicly demonstrate
that Santa Ana is a city of bigotry and unfairness. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you for your kind attention to this important matter.
Very truly yours,
Liat Zilberman
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
81
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Jaimme <
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:09 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you.
Jaimme Shandler
Sent from myiPhone
82
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sherri Chapman <
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:39 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sherri Chapman, Fullerton
Sent from myiPhone
83
Flores, Dora
From:
Margot Eiran <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:01 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Margot Eiran
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Zehava Dahan <
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:01 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Maybar Durst <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:56 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Maybar Durst
Flores, Dora
From:
Nikki P <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:52 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Kinneret Pahima
Flores, Dora
From:
Yehudit Feinstein Mentesh <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:51 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Yehudit Feinstein
Flores, Dora
From:
Maybar Durst <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:48 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
,Dear Council Members
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Maybar Durst
Sent from my Whone
Best Regards,
Maybar
10
Flores, Dora
From: liat.m.zilberman <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:49 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Liat Zilberman
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Flores, Dora
From: Shevet Hamifratz <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:50 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Tal
Flores, Dora
From: liat_zilberman <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:49 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Liat Zilberman
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Becky Hershkowitz <
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:49 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Zehava Dahan <
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:01 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Margot Eiran <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:01 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Margot Eiran
Flores, Dora
From:
Shani Stolero <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:04 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sham Stolero
Flores, Dora
From:
Shani Stolero <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:04 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Sham Stolero
Flores, Dora
From:
71D'119 ilia <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:07 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Gala Phursov
Flores, Dora
From:
NOAAGIV <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:09 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution
submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez. Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath
of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us
have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th
and their aftermath. The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt
by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis
have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on
October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings
and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages. Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire
with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior
Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which
is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays
off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more
violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians. While this resolution may have been introduced
with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution. Thank you
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 9:16 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews
since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to
explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their
aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The
resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and
Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed
crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the
spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of
Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only
once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that
crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not
inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel
more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Moshe Malkin
Palo Alto CA
Flores, Dora
From:
avi zechory <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:17 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Avi Zechory, DVM
Paying Santa Ana taxes - your salaries!
11
Flores, Dora
From:
Kobi Meir <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:18 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Kobi Meir
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Reut Gurion <
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:21 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Reut Zeft
Flores, Dora
From:
Allana Miller <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:22 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Allana Miller
10
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Pierre Kopec <
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:53 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Pierre Kopec
12
Flores, Dora
From:
Tali Dolev <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:19 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
13
Flores, Dora
From:
Yael Herooty <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:19 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Penaloza, David; Lopez, Jessie; Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution
submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez. Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath
of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us
have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th
and their aftermath. The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt
by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis
have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on
October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings
and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages. Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire
with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior
Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which
is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays
off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more
violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians. While this resolution may have been introduced
with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution. Thank you
14
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
ili bar-sade <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:31 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Ili Bar-Sade
15
Flores, Dora
From:
Jeffrey Katz <jeffrey.katz@kesherlawgroup.com>
Sent:
Sunday, December 03, 2023 10:32 AM
To:
Lopez, Jessie
Cc:
Hatch, Tom; Amezcua, Valerie; Penaloza, David; Hernandez, Johnathan; Bacerra, Phil;
Vazquez, Benjamin; Phan, Thai; eComment, Peter Christoffersen; Julie Humphreys;
Mark Rothenberg; Stephanie Miles; Katie Mayberry FPNA Co Membership Director,
Kevin Shuler; Angel Barnes; Sandy Deangelis; Trace Weatherford; Allyson Thompson
Subject:
Letter to MPT J. Lopez re Agenda Item #19
Attachments:
12-23-03 - Letter to Lopez re Israel resolution.pdf
Hon. Lopez,
Please see the attached letter sent on behalf of the Floral Park Neighborhood Association board of directors.
Kesher Law Group
Jeffrey A. Katz I Attorney at Law
1919 N. Heliotrope Dr.
Santa Ana, CA 92706
Direct Dial: (714) 296-8309
Email: jeffrey.katz@kesherlawgroup.com
Y,A Lfill
N 814 VB 01N OPD�ASS OSIA"fON � � !
December 3, 2023
Re: Agenda Item #19 on the December 5, 2023 Agenda
Dear Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez:
As the proud representatives of the Floral Park Neighborhood Association, we write to you with
great concern regarding the upcoming resolution addressing the War in Gaza, scheduled for the
December 5 Santa Ana City Council meeting.
Our community is deeply committed to fostering a spirit of unity, understanding, and
constructive dialogue. While we respect the right to discuss global issues, we believe it is crucial
to consider the potential ramifications of such discussions on our local community. The board
of the Floral Park Neighborhood Association has authorized this letter, expressing our
apprehensions and respectfully requesting your reconsideration of the proposed resolution.
Our concerns can be summarized as follows:
Beyond City Jurisdiction:
We firmly believe that matters beyond the immediate jurisdiction of the City may divert
resources and attention away from addressing pressing local issues. While we acknowledge the
global significance of the War in Gaza, we urge you to prioritize matters directly impacting our
community.
Potential for Hateful Rhetoric:
Unfortunately, discussions surrounding international conflicts can sometimes escalate into
divisive and emotionally charged rhetoric. We fear that such an atmosphere may not only harm
the unity of our community but could also compromise the effectiveness of City Council
meetings. We encourage a focus on fostering a respectful and inclusive environment for all
Santa Ana residents.
Divisiveness of the Resolution:
Our primary concern lies in the one-sided nature of the proposed resolution, which we believe
may contribute to division rather than unity. We advocate for resolutions that encourage open
dialogue, understanding, and cooperation, ultimately strengthening the fabric of our diverse
community.
In light of these concerns, we kindly request that you consider advocating to your fellow
councilmembers, Ben Vazquez and Johnathan R. Hernandez, for the withdrawal of this item
from the agenda of the December 5 meeting. We believe that redirecting the Council's
attention away from matters over which it exercises absolutely no authority to pressing local
issues will better serve the needs and interests of our community.
You are at one of those pivotal moments in your tenure, providing an opportunity to represent
the diverse voices within your community —all of your community. We believe that resolutions
addressing conflicts outside the jurisdiction of the City, especially those with a potential for
divisive discourse, will not serve the best interests of our local community.
It's crucial to consider the recent Oakland City Council meeting as a cautionary tale, where
discussions surrounding a similar resolution deteriorated into members of the public praising
Hamas and claiming that the massacre of Jews is a "fabricated narrative" and that "many of
those killed on October 7, including children, were killed by the IDF. We fear that the proposed
resolution will, likewise, lead to inflammatory rhetoric and a divisive atmosphere.
We appreciate your dedication to serving the residents of Santa Ana and trust that you will
carefully consider our perspective in this matter. We remain hopeful that, together, we car
continue to make Santa Ana a harmonious and vibrant community.
Should you wish to discuss this letter's plea or should you have any questions, we remain
available to you. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Jf IeK:a
FPNA President
cc: Mayor of Santa Ana
City Councilmembers
City Manager
FPNA Board of Directors
Floral Park Neighbors
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Alona Korol <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:36 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Alina Korol
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
HE ED <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:48 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Hilit shifman
Typed with thumbs on glass ...
Please forgive typos
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Dan <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Dan
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rachel Plafker-Esrig <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Helene Schneider <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Ayala Helft <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Ayala Helft
Flores, Dora
From: Michelle Palmer <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Michelle Palmer
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Audrey adler <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Audrey Adler
Certified fitness professional
Owner
www.homebodiesworkoutfitness.com
14
Flores, Dora
From: Michael Cohen <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Michael Cohen
Sent from myiPhone
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:49 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sara Weisblum <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:50 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sara Weisblum /
10
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Leslie Hickey <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:50 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Leslie Hickey
11
Flores, Dora
From: Mary Dwek Radnor <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:50 AM
To: eComment
Subject: I'm writing to ask you to Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards
Mary
Sent from myiPhone
12
Flores, Dora
From: Moshe Rudin < on behalf of Moshe Rudin
<
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:50 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Mark Rudin
Sent from myiPhone
13
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
CB Neugroschl <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:50 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
CB Neugroschl
15
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sherrie Altaras <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:50 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sherrie Potash
Sent from myiPhone
16
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:51 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Tamara Fiche
17
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Judith Gellerstein <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:51 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Get Outlook for Android
is
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
LDear Council Members,
Leah Glicksman <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:51 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Leah Glicksman
Sent from myiPhone
19
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sharon Volk <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:52 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sharon Volk
Sent from myiPhone
20
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
oshratyechzkia <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:52 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
21
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:52 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust.
Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians.
The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis.
250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah.
Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th.
This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood.
Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is
possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution.
The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and
Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
22
PLEASE.
Liz Carnes
23
Flores, Dora
From:
Risa Davis <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:53 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Risa Davis
Sent from myiPhone
24
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sharon Schaier <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:53 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Sharon Schaier
25
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Luckcheese3 <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:53 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you for your consideration,
-Rikki S.
26
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
irenebigio <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:55 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Enviado do meu Galaxy
27
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Bettina <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:55 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Bettina Kramer
28
Flores, Dora
From: Sharon Weisman <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:55 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best,
Sharon Ann Weisman
CEO PowerStation Studios LLC
® +
29
Flores, Dora
From: Amy Kestenbaum <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:55 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
30
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
adi.c.eitan <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:56 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards,
Adi Cohen
31
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:57 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 4:39 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Daniel Rothblum
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705-6303
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
32
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Daniel Rothblum
33
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karen Robinovitz <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:57 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Karen Robinovitz
34
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:57 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 4:57 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Arnold Shugarman
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Please see attachment regarding proposed resolution on Israel and Hamas.
Upload a file
• Response -to -SA -City -Council -Resolution 120123.docx
35
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:57 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Friday, December 1, 2023 5:28 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
simon bonnie
Email
Address
California 92663
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
36
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Bonnie Simon
37
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rabbi Avi Libman <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:58 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
38
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:58 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 7:14 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Randie Noel[
Email
Address
Yorba Linda, California 92886
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
39
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I desperately urge you to reject the resolution consider the false information you are using.
Sincerely,
Randie Noell
40
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:58 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 9:53 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Michele Shugarman
Email
Address
California Santa Ana
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
My heart breaks at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At
the same time, we should hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their
goals.
Your resolution includes rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. Babies were taken by terrorists as hostages. Palestinian
prisoners in Israel were convicted of violent crimes. They are not hostages of Israel. You use inaccurate terms like ethnic
cleansing, genocide, and apartheid. Thee terms are too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
41
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Michele Shugarman
42
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Helari <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:58 AM
eComment
Please, vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Apart from the reasons below, if Israel does not defeat Hamas, these extreme terrorists will be coming after the United
States next. Please do some due diligence and look at this from a historical context- Hamas has always broken cease
fires- is an arm of the Iranian government. Hamas is an Isis organization.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Helen Flechner
Sent from myiPhone
43
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:59 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Saturday, December 2, 2023 10:40 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Allen Bernstein
Email
Address
1107 W Memory Lane
Santa Ana, California 92706
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I am no longer proud to be a citizen of Santa Ana. The city has disgraced itself by even considering a resolution that condemns
Israel. What about condemning the worst atrocities ever committed against other humans by Hamas? Why not call for a
resolution for Hamas to release all hostages and surrender so all of this can end? I'm sure the council members who are for this
resolution are actually hoping for more deaths so they have an excuse to spew their anti-semitism. At least the anti-semitic
members of the council who are in favor of this disgusting resolution have called themselves out for all to see. I will no longer be
part of the silent majority and will work to oppose all who support this resolution now and in the future.
44
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Stu <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:59 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Notwithstanding the upside down rhetoric that abounds, Hamas's actions
that day demonstrate in real life its plan to exterminate all 7 million Jews in Israel. Many of us have experienced and/or
witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath, and enabling attempted genocide.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have repeatedly indicated their intentions to continue in
their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The
people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Stuart Krause
Sent from myiPhone
45
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:59 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 10:37 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dror Landau
Email
Address
Irvine, California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
Comments or questions
Dear Council -member Thai Viet Phan,
I read the ceasefire resolution submitted by Council -members Vazquez and Hernandez. I'm urging you to vote no on this
resolution.
I was in Israel visiting my family when Hamas declared a war on Israel on 10/7/2023 by committing atrocious attacks on innocent
Israeli civilians.
In the following days we were in fear that other terror organizations and countries around Israel would start a regional war.
Gladly so far, they "only" attack Israeli towns close to border with Lebanon. One of the main reasons for that is the strong
message of support by President Joe Biden.
Approving this resolution would send the wrong message to Hamas, ISIS like, terrorists and their supporters. It will not shorten
the war, just the opposite.
Moreover, the resolution blames Israel for the deaths of Palestinians that occurred because Hamas initiated a war. Israel is no
more morally responsible for those deaths than the Allies were for German casualties during World War II or for Syrian
casualties during the fight against ISIS.
No nation would agree to neighbor a quasi -state controlled by a terrorist organization committed to genocide, one that has
demonstrated its capabilities and reiterated its intent countless times, including after Israel and the Palestinians Authority signed
the Oslo Agreement in the WH. By making a demand for a ceasefire, people are effectively asking Israelis to suicidal consent to
mass murder.
The war could stop in five minutes: if Hamas, a fundamentalist organization that took control of Gaza in a coup d'etat, would lay
down its weapons, its leaders would receive safe passage, the PA would take over the Gaza Strip with international assurances,
and all hostages would be freed. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and
terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
46
Warm wishes,
Dror Landau (Irvine, CA)
47
Flores, Dora
From: Ilanit Zakowski <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:59 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Ilanit Zakowski
48
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:00 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 10:39 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dror Landau
Email
Address
Irvine, California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
Comments or questions
Dear Mayor Valerie Amezcua,
I read the ceasefire resolution submitted by Council -members Vazquez and Hernandez. I'm urging you to vote no on this
resolution.
I was in Israel visiting my family when Hamas declared a war on Israel on 10/7/2023 by committing atrocious attacks on innocent
Israeli civilians.
In the following days we were in fear that other terror organizations and countries around Israel would start a regional war.
Gladly so far, they "only" attack Israeli towns close to border with Lebanon. One of the main reasons for that is the strong
message of support by President Joe Biden.
Approving this resolution would send the wrong message to Hamas, ISIS like, terrorists and their supporters. It will not shorten
the war, just the opposite.
Moreover, the resolution blames Israel for the deaths of Palestinians that occurred because Hamas initiated a war. Israel is no
more morally responsible for those deaths than the Allies were for German casualties during World War II or for Syrian
casualties during the fight against ISIS.
No nation would agree to neighbor a quasi -state controlled by a terrorist organization committed to genocide, one that has
demonstrated its capabilities and reiterated its intent countless times, including after Israel and the Palestinians Authority signed
the Oslo Agreement in the WH. By making a demand for a ceasefire, people are effectively asking Israelis to suicidal consent to
mass murder.
The war could stop in five minutes: if Hamas, a fundamentalist organization that took control of Gaza in a coup d'etat, would lay
down its weapons, its leaders would receive safe passage, the PA would take over the Gaza Strip with international assurances,
and all hostages would be freed. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and
terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
49
Warm wishes,
Dror Landau (Irvine, CA)
50
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:59 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 10:44 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dror Landau
Email
Address
Irvine, California
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Councilmember David Penaloza
Comments or questions
Dear Councilmember David Penaloza,
After reading the ceasefire resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez and I'm urging you to vote no on
this resolution.
I was in Israel visiting my family when Hamas declared a war on Israel on 10/7/2023 by committing atrocious attacks on innocent
Israeli civilians.
In the following days we were in fear that other terror organizations and countries around Israel would start a regional war.
Gladly so far, they `only" attack Israeli towns close to border with Lebanon. One of the main reasons for that is the strong
message of support by President Joe Biden.
Approving this resolution would send the wrong message to Hamas, ISIS like, terrorists and their supporters. It will not shorten
the war, just the opposite.
Moreover, the resolution blames Israel for the deaths of Palestinians that occurred because Hamas initiated a war. Israel is no
more morally responsible for those deaths than the Allies were for German casualties during World War II or for Syrian
casualties during the fight against ISIS.
No nation would agree to neighbor a quasi -state controlled by a terrorist organization committed to genocide, one that has
demonstrated its capabilities and reiterated its intent countless times, including after Israel and the Palestinians Authority signed
the Oslo Agreement in the WH. By making a demand for a ceasefire, people are effectively asking Israelis to suicidal consent to
mass murder.
51
The war could stop in five minutes: if Hamas, a fundamentalist organization that took control of Gaza in a coup d'etat, would lay
down its weapons, its leaders would receive safe passage, the PA would take over the Gaza Strip with international assurances,
and all hostages would be freed. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and
terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Warm wishes,
Dror Landau (Irvine, CA)
52
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:00 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 1:33 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Adam Lang
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting. It is in disbelief that this resolution is being written in order to
divide sides, no matter the short "clean up" at the end referencing the Holocaust and peace among everyone.
The resolution's reference to an Amnesty International article states how whole Palestinian families were wiped out. The article
does not talk about whole families being wiped out by Hamas. The article talks in generalities about Hamas' rocket fire into
Israel, which is much more detailed about the destruction in the Gaza Strip (which is terrible). From October 7 to November 10,
2023 over 9,500 missiles have been fire INTO Israel (ref: https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-easVhamas-fires-rockets-deep-
into-israel-setting-off-sirens4el-aviv-2023-11-10/).
The resolution speaks nothing about the missile fire into Israel, nor the displacement of Israelis including those near the war
zone and those who have no more family to take care of them. How do I know this? It is because I have a personal friend who
just came back from Israel after helping to teach kids who were displaced due to the fighting.
53
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution `vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Adam Lang
Santa Ana
54
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:00 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 2:20 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Jessica McMillin
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• CouncilmemberJohnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I'm writing regarding the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be
considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
I grew up in Irvine and have frequented, and continue to frequent, establishments in Santa Ana over the last 35 years. Santa
Ana, like Irvine, has always "felt like home" to me. But in reading this resolution that the city is planning to pass, I, as a Jewish
woman, feel like an "outsider' and no longer embraced by a place I used to consider home.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
At this critical time, ALL reasonable voices, especially those who want to promote Western values of religious freedom,
economic opportunity, womens' rights, and technological innovation, should be clearly condemning Hamas. We should all be the
"adults in the room" and holding Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of
their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
55
I urge you to reject the resolution
I feel discouraged and, quite frankly, disgusted by Santa Ana's willingness to consider this resolution. The vast majority of YOUR
OWN COMMUNITY is Latino and follows the Christian faith. I do not see how this resolution serves the interests of your own
constituents, most of whom have an indirect yet special connection to Israel because of their Christian faith. Christians, like Jews
and Muslims, should be equally protective of ensuring Israel is a safe and secure place, where people of all religions can visit
important historical sites. To disparage Israel for trying to keep its citizens (including its Arab Muslim and Christian citizens) safe
is unacceptable.
As a reminder, the Palestinian population in Gaza VOTED FOR HAMAS IN THEIR ELECTIONS to represent them after Israel
left the territory in 2005. The brainwashing done by Hamas over the last 20 years has created a population that wishes death
upon all Jews. Even young children are raised to find value in martyrdom - killing themselves and non -Muslims (Jews first, then
Christians and other Westerns) in the name of Allah. I've seen interviews of 5 year olds in Gaza celebrating the brutal murder of
Jews.
After what transpired on October 7th, this resolution is completely inappropriate.
56
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:00 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 3:26 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Kenneth Pivo
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
I follow below with a comment I am sure you have seen multiple times by now. But in addition to those well -reasoned comments,
I must add my absolute outrage that you would interject yourselves in this very divisive issue (which is well outside the purview
of your Counsel obligations) and dare to suggest you speak for the members of this diverse City. I urge you to reject this
resolution and move on to business for which you were elected. Should you want to express these beliefs in a forum, outside
your position as a representative of others, then you certainly have that right. But do not hold out the Board's position to the
world as somehow reflective of the beliefs of so many others that strongly disagree with your misinformed and uneducated
conclusions.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
57
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution `vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
56
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:01 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 7:38 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Orna Lang
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
59
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Orna Lang
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:01 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 3, 2023 11:04 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Dr Iris Rosenfeld
Email
Address
Laguna Hills, California 92653
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
61
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Dr Iris Rosenfeld
62
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Noam Landor <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:01 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
63
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:01 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 8:03 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Bob Klein
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
Good morning.
I appreciate your hard work
Today, I write to share my deep concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of
a Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes incredibly inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between
babies taken by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses
inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish
people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
64
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Respectfully,
65
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:01 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 8:58 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Bonnie Jeannette
Email
Address
Newport Beach, California 92663
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting. This resolution is inciteful and fails to address the fact that ALL
WAR IS TERRIBLE! Israel is a tiny country surrounded by terrorists. They have no choice but to rout out terrorists that daily
threaten Israel's existence and have one mission - to kill Jews and eliminate Israel completely.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its continual
terrorist attack on Israel and most especially on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the
66
Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6 million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi
regime. And most insulting is that the resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Bonnie Jeannette
A Jewish American in Orange County
67
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:01 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 10:06 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Irma Mejia
Email
Address
Anaheim, California 92805
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
66
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Irma Mejia
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
David Awerbuch <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:02 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
70
Flores, Dora
From:
Flores, Gaston
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:02 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 10:24 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Elizabeth Flanigan
Email
Address
santa ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana council,
I an a Christian member of your district who stands in support of the response of the Israeli government and people to respond
to the horrific massacre that was inflicted upon the Israeli men, women and children on October7th. While it is very sad to watch
the results of the war between the two governments of Palestine and Israel there is no option for the Isreali people but to
completely take out the Hamas infested Palestine till Hamas is no longer able destroy the security and peace that Israel is
wanting and indeed is needed for any country. All countries must be able to keep their people free and protected. Hamas by their
own admission wants to complete a genocide that they along with Iran and the Hezbollah and the Houthi's work towards every
single day.
The good people of Palestine must stand up on their own now as they are released from some of the tyranny of these afore
mentioned mongers of war and genocide, the Iranian government and all of their puppet players.
Until the underground tunnels are destroyed, the Hamas people are wiped out the good Palestinian people will continue to live in
a world of deprivation and military rule by Hamas. It is always hard for us to watch the innocents die in war. BUT that is and has
always been the ravages of being at war. To retreat now to satisfy the part of the world that lacks or appreciates the costs of
freedom to that lead to eventual destruction of a way of life for its own people, the good Palestinians and the Israeli people need
us to continue to just that . Freedom. For both. The Hamas members are horrific people as shown by their acts of savagery. And
71
they must be annihilated to bring peace and security to the rest of the members of a humanity that is good.
I am very very distressed to have learned and read of the Santa Ana councils decision to support the good people of the world.
Shame on you.
Sincerely,
Elizabeth Flanigan
72
Flores, Dora
From: Joanne Asher <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:02 AM
To: eComment
Subject: NO
Dear Council Members,
Vazquez and Hernandez are telling all Jews to voluntarily die. Please don't join with these vicious anti-Semites.
If you want to get involved,then tell Hamas to stop hiding behind civilians . Come out and fight like a man or
surrender.
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Joanne Asher
73
Flores, Dora
From:
Dov <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:03 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
74
Flores, Dora
From:
Shai Aizin <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:03 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
,Dear Council Members
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
,' v Whone-nn ri7m
75
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Harry schlachter <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:03 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Harry Schlachter
Sent from myiPhone
76
Flores, Dora
From: Sherrie Soleymani <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:08 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Sherrie S.
Sent from myiPhone
77
Flores, Dora
From: Howard Blank <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:11 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Howard Blank
76
Flores, Dora
From:
Miti Nafte <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:12 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Miti Nafte
79
Flores, Dora
From: Michal Guelfand <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:12 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Michal Guelfand
An American citizen
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hayley Prochazka <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:12 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Hayley Prochazka
Sent from myiPhone
81
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nazanin Yacobi <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:14 AM
eComment
Re: The Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards
Naz Yacobi, PhD
82
Flores, Dora
From: Deborah Schwartz <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:14 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from myiPhone
83
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Aliza Cinamon <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:15 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Aliza Cinamon
84
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
abby flamholz <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:15 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Abby flamholz
85
Flores, Dora
From: Lisa Kohorn <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:16 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Please vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Lisa Kohorn, MD
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Shelly Aks <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:17 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best
Shelly Aks
87
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Morris Missry <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:18 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
> Morris Missry, Esq.
>
U.S. Treasury Circular 230 Notice: Any U.S. federal tax advice included in this communication was not intended or
written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of avoiding U.S. federal tax penalties.
This message is sent by a law firm and may contain information that is privileged or confidential. If you received this
transmission in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachments.
m
Flores, Dora
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Deborah Reich <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:20 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Hamas continually breaks seas fires as recently as last week, so this does not make any sense. Israel must defend itself
from the constant terror it has faced.
Deborah Reich MD
Sent from my iPhone
m
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Jennifer Shalom <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:21 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Steven Ancona <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:22 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Aylit Schultz <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 9:38 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
It's very simple. There was a ceasefire on October 6th and look what Hamas did!
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Aylit Schultz, MD
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hila Abada <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:27 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 11:27 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 11:27 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Martin Nakell
Email
Address
Orange, California 92866
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Please see attached
Upload a file
• santa-ana.1.docx
1
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I am not surprised — but I am very disturbed to see — just how far the proposed Resolution "In Solidarity with
the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire" repeats hackncvcd canards, displays a lack of historical
knowledge, distorts facts in the sernrice of blind and blinding anti -Zionism. Its very title (which does not read
in support of the Palestinian and Israeli people") attests to its prejudice, its intentions, its agenda.
I urge you to defeat this proposed Resolution. Following the order of the proposed Resolution, I will address
its claims.
The proposed Resolution references "a relentless and ongoing campaign of airstrikes on the people of Gaza."
Israel is not bombing "the people of Gaza." Israel is bombing Hamas. Hamas, using the people of Gaza as
human shields, is responsible for each and cvcry death, cvcry dismemberment, cvcry injury.
The Israeli Defense Force warns the people of Gaza of upcoming bombings. Extraordinary! Hamas prcvcnts
the people of Gaza from cvacuating a Hamas-created combat zone. Hamas holds the whole civilian Gazan
population hostage. At the risk of its own soldiers, the IDF proNrides protection for fleeing refugees —
protection from Hamas!
Israel does not occupy Gaza. Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005. Israel has no citizens, no police, no armor, no
court, no judge in Gaza. The proposed Resolution need be at least historically, geo-politically accurate.
As to the blockade, should Israel stand idly by while Hamas ships into Gaza tons of weapons, including missiles
to fire at Israel? The proposed Resolution is naive in the extreme.
The proposed Resolution uses hideously inflammatory, propagandistic language to distort reality. Israel is
simpler not an apartheid state. (see mar article in The Algemeiner of January 12 2021, "Whose Human Rights?
BIDS Is Antisemitic and Harms Palestinians"). The proposed Resolution, in assuming such unsubstantiated
claims of apartheid, falls prcv to slanderous tropes. It perpetuates them.
The proposed Resolution cites "UN reports" claiming that Israel's bombing has displaced 1.6 million
Palestinians. It says nothing about the estimated 250,000 Israelis displaced by the Oct. 711, terrorist attack and
by the continuing onslaught of missile attacks from Gaza and from Hezbollah. This kind of selective
information constitutes a sin of omission. Not surprisingly, it speaks of one suffering; it ignores the other. This
rhetorical manipulation belies a hidden agenda.
If, in the sloganeering language of the proposed Resolution, Gaza is the world's "largest open-air prison," who
made it so? Israel did not create the necessity of the "enclosure of Gaza's borders." Hamas's relentless
aggression against Israel built those concrete walls, those barbed wire fcnccs.
The proposed Resolution points to Gazans' dependence on humanitarian aid, citing alarming percentages of
shortfalls. Placed as these statistics are amidst an accusatory list of Israel's culpabilities for Gaza's suffering, one
can only conclude the Proposal blames Israel for all of Gaza's suffering. It does not mention the number of
trucks normally entering Gaza daily, carrying supplies such as concrete and fuel — stolen from the Gazans by
Hamas. It does not mention the innovative Israeli water projects given to Gaza. It omits everything but blame
placed on Israel.
The Proposal goes on, in the next two paragraphs, to accuse Israel of the war crime of collective punishment.
I suggest that international war crime attorneys and scholars be given the opportunity to advise you. It certainly
cynically brutally and without remorse kill, rape, murder while raping, burn is a war crime to purposefully,
alive, and abduct civilian men, women and children. It is a war crime to then to run and hide behind civilian
human shields. It is a war crime to use a place of healing, a hospital, or a place of worship, a mosque, or a
place of education, a school to hide. It is nearly unbearably painful to see such destruction, to witness so many
suffer as the Gazan people are suffering. But dare not call it an Israeli war crime! Call it as it is: a Hamas war
crime.
The International Criminal Court JCC) prosecutor, Karim Khan, after a recent visit to Israel and to the
Palestinian Authority, said that "the attacks against innocent Israeli civilians on October 7 represent some of
the most serious international crimes that shock the conscience of humanity.... There can be no justification
for the holding of any hostages, and in particular the egregious breach of fundamental principles of humanity
through the taking and continued holding of children. Hostages cannot be treated as human shields or
bargaining chips."
Mr. Khan went on to say, "Conflict in densely populated areas where fighters are alleged to be unlawfully
embedded in the civilian population is inherently complex, but international humanitarian law must still apply
and the Israeli military knows the law that must be applied .... Israel has trained lawyers who advise commanders
and a robust system intended to ensure compliance with international humanitarian law."
Is it a war crime — as Israel did — to provide incubators with which to evacuate premature babies from Shifa
hospital? Is it a war crime to urge civilians to evacuate an upcoming battle zone — even at the risk of one's own
troops? Is it a war crime that Israel provided fuel to Shifa hospital?
The proposed Resolution speaks of "ethnic cleansing." To support that accusation the proposed Resolution
claims that Israeli leaders use such language as "human animals." The proposed Resolution doesn't clarify that
that language is directed — not at Gazans or Palestinians — but at the October 7 terrorists. Is it an inappropriate
appellation for those who engage in murder, rape, burning of babies alive? Do not speak of an Israeli policy of
"ethnic cleansing" without irrefutable evidence. To claim the Israeli government plans to ethnically cleanse
Gaza of Palestinians, the proposed Resolution must provide a cited reference or be seen as dangerously
inflammatory but empty rhetoric.
However, Article 7 of the Hamas Charter of 1988 does call on Moslems to "fight Jews and kill them."
Similarly, do not use the word "genocide" lightly and loosely, without evidence. It is a hideous — unfounded —
accusation.
The proposed Resolution raises the issue of increased violence in the West Bank. Again, it abrogates
responsibility in not mentioning Palestinian �Tiolence and the killing of Israelis in Israel. Nor does it mention
how many Palestinian deaths resulted from Palestinian -initiated firefights during legal arrests of suspected
terrorists. Nor does it place any responsibility on Hamas, only on Israel.
The proposed Resolution begins a turn toward a truly humanitarian vision when it affirms that "we mourn the
loss of all civilian lives...." However, it returns to unfounded one-sided blame: "throughout the decades of
displacement, occupation, oppression and blockade endured in Gaza and the West Bank." I have discussed the
blockade above. The rest of this assumes a bias which ignores history and international law in dismissing
decades of Israeli suffering from Palestinian aggression. At the very least, Gaza is not "occupied" (arguably,
neither is the West Bank).
Were this proposed Resolution aimed at peace, it would have my wholehearted support. Its rhetoric now
enflames the passions of hatred, and, in particular, of antisemitism. It will serve our communities — in need of
calm — with an influence to violence. Antisemitic incidents have been rising at alarming rates. The Santa Ana
City Council does not want to exacerbate this by contributing a public document voicing inaccuracies, using
extremely inflammatory rhetoric, creating misperceptions. The safety of myself and my family and my
community depend on your action. Yes, civil violence has increased in the West Bank and in Israel, 7500 miles
from Santa Ana. Let's make sure we don't contribute to that here. Let's contribute to peace.
Sincerely,
Martin Nakell
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Irina <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:29 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sugar <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:30 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Gaby Wolff <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:30 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely
Gaby
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:33 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Ronit Rosenblum
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Naomi Korb Weiss <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:34 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rita Rak <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:19 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Rita Rak
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rachel Silvera <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:37 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hattie Dubroff <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:37 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Hattie Dubroff
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Lee Garrun <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:35 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Lee Garrun
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Oded Cohen <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:38 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Oded Cohen
Small opportunities are
often the beginning of
great enterprise.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Jayne Rosengarten <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 11:40 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Jayne
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Cecille <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:52 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Elena Zubarevsky <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:53 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Elena Zubarevsky
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Naomi Korb Weiss <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:55 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Roman Gelman <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 11:56 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Howard Frantz <
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:08 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Roz Moskovitz <
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:13 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Roz Moskowitz Bielski
Alcala, Abigail
From: Mark Rothenberg <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 12:15 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Lopez, Jessie; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: City Council Agenda 12/5 Item 19/Demand For Withdrawal of Cease Fire Resolution
(Opposition to Resolution)
Attachments: Santa Ana Resolution Objc 12042023.pdf
Madamme Clerk:
Please find attached a letter from Santa Ana residents -Mark and Lauren Rothenberg of North Ross Street. Kindly
distribute to Council in advance of the meeting tomorrow.
I am also ccing Mayor Amezcua who has shown inspired leadership on this issue and ask that our Councilwoman, Ms.
Lopez (also cc'd) do the same.
Many Thanks
Mark A. Rothenberg, Esq.
Lauren Tarkow, Esq.
Mark Rothenberg, Esq.
Lauren Tarkow, Esq.
Santa Ana, California
Re: Opposition to Resolution in Favor of a Ceasefire Between Israel
and Hamas (12/5 City Council Agenda Item 19)
Dear Mayor Amezcua and honorable members of the City Council:
As a threshold matter, our home address is not provided on this letter. It
is telling that we now feel the need to keep our home address in Santa
Ana private given the divisive and terrifying Resolution that has been
placed before you regarding the conflict in Gaza. Please note (and
Councilwoman Lopez —please pay particularly close attention as this
impacts your ward): Santa Ana is home to one of Orange County's oldest
Jewish communities which includes one of its oldest synagogues and
newest Jewish Day Schools. Your Jewish community now lives in fear.
Although I trust this is not the motivation behind the Resolution, it does
seem to fit an age-old pattern for those who seek attention: when failure
abounds —blame the Jews.
As residents of Santa Ana, we are writing to demand that you withdraw
from consideration the intellectually dishonest and morally bankrupt
resolution advocating for a ceasefire between the Israeli Defense Forces
(IDF) and Hamas Terrorists operating in the Gaza Strip. Temporarily
putting aside the well -known --voluminous logical, fair-minded, honest
arguments against any such resolution and the horrifying factual
inaccuracies evident in its text, the proposed resolution is a divisive
distraction from the myriad of actual municipal issues we elected you to
resolve.
The City of Santa Ana (our home of over 15 years) has numerous
problems. Crime, homelessness, housing affordability, air quality,
infrastructure, a giant mound of dirt festering in the middle of
downtown, the lack of libraries, potholes, a demoralized police
department, lack of a permanent city manager, budget problems, recall
elections, absentee landlords allowing their properties to crumble... are
all issues that this council needs to address. Instead, a small group of
"misguided" Councilmembers have decided to waste public resources to
opine on a foreign matter with no practical consequence other than
dividing our community.
In substance, the resolution is blatantly one-sided, inaccurate, and
entirely at odds with positions taken by the United States government,
the State of California, and our elected officials in Congress who are
actually responsible for foreign policy (most of whom are Democrats).
The Resolution fails to condemn Hamas which livestreamed its barbarism
for the world to see. That barbarism included the massacre of men,
women, and children, rape, and kidnap. Putting those issues aside (if you
can), that terror group butchers its own citizens for being gay, summarily
executes its citizens without any form of due process, and steals money
from the international community to build terror tunnels and military
installations under and within hospitals, mosques, and schools. The
barbarism includes firing thousands of rockets at its sovereign neighbor
and turning a blind eye to rocket misfires which kill untold numbers of
Palestinians.
Any civilian casualties are a tragedy. However, that does not make them
a genocide. A genocide is the deliberate killing of a large group of a
particular people with the aim of destroying those people. That is exactly
what Hamas has set out to do to Jews in Israel. The Hamas Charter calls
for the destruction of the State of Israel and the annihilation of the Jewish
people across the world. The mastermind of 10/7 (who was released in
an exchange of 1027 prisoners for one soldier) has vowed to commit 10/7
again and again and again. Civilian death as a result of collateral war
damage is not the same as intending to wipe out a group of people. To
callously throw around words like genocide, ethnic cleansing and "never
again" is disparaging and offensive to all those who were killed in the
Holocaust.
The IDF is a moral army and is fighting with considerable restraint. No
such restraint is evident anywhere in the world —let alone this troubled
area of the world. What other army makes phone calls, drops leaflets and
knocks on the rooftops to tell civilians in harm's way to evacuate areas
due to terrorist activity, thereby losing the element of surprise to save
civilians? Further, the IDF creates safe zones and evacuation routes with
maps for civilians in order to try to protect them. This Resolution
admonishes Israel as it attempts to defend itself from a war that it did
not start and from an enemy that uses its own population as human
shields while it hides in its network of terror tunnels.
The bias in the resolution is blatant. The Israeli men, women and
children that were kidnapped and dragged to Gaza against their will are
HOSTAGES. The men women and children convicted of crimes, awaiting
trial, or caught committing acts of violence or terrorism in Israel are
PRISONERS. To call prisoners "hostages" is disingenuous. Further, to
equate civilian casualties of war with intentional murder of civilians is
immoral.
There are numerous other inaccuracies and distortions in the Resolution.
The Resolution refer to Gaza as "occupied". The only occupier is Hamas.
Hamas has controlled all of Gaza since 2007. Arab Israelis that live in
Israel have full rights and serve in all aspects of the government. What
would happen if Jews attempted to live in Gaza?
The tragic deaths and humanitarian crisis in Gaza are the result of the
terrorist organization--Hamas hiding behind its citizens and stealing its
resources. The failure of the Resolution to even mention these
fundamental facts underscores the bias and distortion in the Resolution.
Further, the Resolution's advocacy in support of Hamas when it has
been silent on so many other international crises is telling.
Where are the City of Santa Ana Council Resolutions condemning the
internment and forced sterilization of the Uyghurs in China, the hundreds
of thousands killed by the Assad regime in Syria, the destruction of towns
and displacement of millions of people in Sudan, the executions of
women in Iran, the in discriminant killing and massacre of thousands
Palestinians by Jordan, the callous act of throwing gays off of buildings in
Gaza, and the refusal of Egypt to open its border and allow the
Palestinians free travel throughout the greater Arab world?
Please withdraw the Resolution immediately. Let your constituents know
that you do not support terrorism. Please do not send the message that
Santa Ana stands with Hamas. Please do not further fan the flames of
antisemitism and vote no on this Resolution and address the issues that
you were elected to deal with.
Sincerely,
E/S
Lauren Tarkow, Esq.
Mark A. Rothenberg, Esq.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Leah Fischler <
Monday, December 4, 2023 10:54 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Leah Fischler
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Annie Duran <
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:07 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Annie Duran
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Doris <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:21 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Doris Hartman
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ayelet Nachman <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 12:22 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Ayelet Nachman
Orange county CA
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Sara Richards <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 12:39 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sara Richards
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Norm Cantor <
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:40 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not incentivize more violence even inadvertently,
at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Think about it this way; what if Hamas comes for you and your children and peomises to repeatedly beat, rob,
rape and decapitate them? Would you stand by while they held hostage you and those you love, and not fight
back even though you know they hide behind their own citizens, hospitals, schools and mosques?
It's finally time to admit that there is no logic in believing Israel should pursue any others course but destroying
those who say that they will accept no less than the goal to annihilate the Jewish People, a nation that precedes
Islam by a thousand years.
Open your mind to possibilities that might actually work and not cling to violence and slogans that espouse a
desire to destroy.
Thank you
Sincerely,
Norman Cantor
Alcala, Abigail
From: Eva-Michaele Wasser <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 12:55 PM
To: eComment
Subject: City Council resolution
Dear Council members,
I am writing to you ahead of the council meeting to express my concern that the upcoming meeting does not turn into a
farce as happened in Oakland recently. Outsiders will come and attempt to hijack the meeting proclaiming falsehoods
and propaganda as it relates to the current situation in the Middle East. I implore you to educate yourselves on the facts
prior to commencing. Israel, the only Democratic nation currently In the Middle East, was viciously, and barbarically
attacked on October 7th, by Terrorists of Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and regular citizens of Gaza. Their sovereign borders
were breached and 1400 men, women, children and infants, were butchered . There is video evidence which has been
viewed by members of the world wide media and Diplomats from Countries around the globe. I implore you to not allow
agitators and deniers of these atrocities to grand stand and disrupt your meeting solely for their own agenda and
continued dissemination of lies. We must as Americans stand with our allies as we fight this ever growing threat to our
democracy, freedoms, and values.
Sincerely,
Eva-Michaele Wasser
Sent on the run
from my iPhone,
please excuse dictation and autocorrect errors.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Yaeli Gila <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:56 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nicky Colley < >
Monday, December 4, 2023 12:57 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Naomi Rotter <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:54 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Adi Kaplan <
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:04 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thanks
Adi
Get Outlook for Android
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Maya Fawcett <
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:12 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you for your time and consideration,
Maya Fawcett
Alcala, Abigail
From:
cathie rankin <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:12 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Cathie Rankin
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Debbie Cohen <
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:21 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
A proud Jew,
Deborah Cohen
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sharon Senderowicz <
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:24 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sharon Senderowicz
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sam <
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:39 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best Regards,
Sam Dushey
Jenel Management
New York NY 10016
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 1:41 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 12:49 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Linda Kaplan -Schwab
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92618
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Linda Kaplan -Schwab
Alcala, Abigail
From: Cara <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 1:42 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote No on Ceasefire
Hamas invaded Israel after years of launching thousands of rockets at Israeli civilians. October 7 was the largest
attack against the Jewish people since the holocaust. Its barbarity and cruelty is beyond what can be imagined:
people burned alive, cutting body parts off before killing people, gang rapes of women and children that caused
broken pelvises, and 240 people being kidnapped.
Israel vowed to destroy this terror organization, like the United States did to AI-Qaeda. It is beyond me as to
why you want to reward them with a cease-fire. Why not demand the return of the hostages? Hamas has used
cease-fires many times in the past to rearm. There was a cease-fire in place on October 6, but they broke it with
devastating results. They have vowed to repeat the depraved attack of October 7 "again and again and again."
Hamas puts Palestinians directly in the line of fire. They kill political opponents. Their attacks cause Palestinian
deaths. To stop Israel is to cause more death on both sides.
Find your backbone. Do not be swayed by the loud voices that want the Jews dead.
Cara Altman
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Robyn Bowers <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:51 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Robyn Bowers
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 1:52 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 1:51 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Brad & Bonnie Wenneberg
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
We are members at a faith -based organization in Santa Ana, as well as shop, dine, and seek entertainment within Santa Ana so
we care about this city.
See attached / uploaded file - Letter to the SA City Council
Upload a file
• letter-to-SA-City-Council.pdf
1
December 4, 2023
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
We write today to share our concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in
Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire to be considered
at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It
makes a false equivalency between babies taken by terrorists as hostages to
prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It
uses inaccurate terms like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all
too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel
and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same
time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent
Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a
forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack on Israel on October 7. It
weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that
is insulting to the 6 million Jews — including members of our family!! - and
countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And
most insulting is that the resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it
actually promotes and amplifies it.
We strongly urge you to reject the resolution !!!
Sincerely.
Bonnie & Brad Wenneberg
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
shegamega2 <
Monday, December 4, 2023 1:52 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Michelle Kahan
Alcala, Abigail
From: C Rudman <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 2:16 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support for Israel
I am urging you not to pass any ordinances similar to the ones in Oakland. Instead of promoting peace, you are
considering making Jewish people the other, similar to during the Holocaust. The resolution passed in Oakland
and the language used in the teachings they are planning are outright propaganda and a false narrative.
People should be against the terrorist group Hamas but seem to be lost in their antisemitism and I urge you not
to perpetuate it further. The Palestinian people will be able to thrive once Hamas is no longer oppressing them
and using them as human shields. The atrocities that took place on October 7th are to be condemned and not
celebrated.
Thank you for reading my plea.
Cindy Rudman
Cindy Rudman
Founder, NoteworthyNotes
www.NoteworthvNotes.com
W,
' 10 "1"1 11I S
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Vardit Ozeri <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 2:12 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Vardit
1
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 2:17 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 2:16 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Shawn Boatright
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Shawn
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Taya Friedman <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 2:22 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Taya
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Dorene Richman <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 2:20 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you.
Ron and Dorene Richman
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Jody Comins <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 2:35 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thanks,
Jody
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
mjacobsonmalek <
Monday, December 4, 2023 2:41 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Michelle Malek
Michelle Malek:
gent frorn my Veri/on, Ssrnsune Galaxy srnurtphone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
ruth levy <
Monday, December 4, 2023 11:48 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Zionlevy
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rahel Tennenbaum <
Monday, December 4, 2023 2:57 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war.
A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli
blood.
Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of
Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future
which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Eugene Kilberg <
Monday, December 4, 2023 3:06 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Eugene Kilberg
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
big mama <
Monday, December 4, 2023 3:42 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Emile Holdings <
Monday, December 4, 2023 3:42 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both sides, but as
stated ceasefire was broken by Hamas on October 7th and once more last week
Zeev Goldreich
Alcala, Abigail
From: Yesenia Martinez <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 3:52 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Yesenia Martinez
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Heidi Sokol <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 3:54 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Heidi Sokol
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Prose Cute Tricks < >
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 1:55 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Santa Ana City Council Agenda Item 19: NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Santa Ana City Council Members,
Please vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution. For the reasons I'm about to explain, as it is drafted,
this proposed resolution is a reprehensible idea guaranteed to (1) harm the local Jewish population
and (2) have absolutely no impact on events in the Middle East. There is no ethical or moral
justification for approving such a deleterious measure ... unless the council's goal is to physically and
mentally harm Jews, a minority group already suffering from marked bigotry and discrimination.
Please note: (i) I am not able to find a copy of the proposed resolution online. I am therefore relying
on a summary provided by another resolution opponent. His summary might or might not be accurate
or complete. The unavailability of the text leads me to wonder whether the council has complied with
due process and all other legal requirements for promulgating resolutions. (ii) Why does the council
think this is an appropriate resolution subject for the City of Santa Ana? This city has lots of problems
to address, but there are no bombs falling in or near the city limits. Does the council have constituents
who are Hamas members? Has the council also weighed in on conflicts involving the Rohingya
people in Myanmar, the Uyghurs in China, Sudan, Venezuela, Colombia, Syria, Iraq, and Ethiopia?
ERRONEOUS TEXT
Assuming I have been adequately informed about the resolution content, the resolution contains
several glaring misstatements. Does this council really want to go on record as making erroneous
statements of fact and law?
Error #1: I understand the resolution faults Israel for a war that was started by Hamas. Speaking as
an attorney specializing in international law, I can tell you that's an embarrassingly nonsensical,
indefensible position.
Error #2: 1 understand the resolution uses the term "hostages" to describe inmates in Israeli prisons.
These inmates are (1) individuals convicted of crimes, e.g., bombings, attempted bombings, and
stabbings of Israeli citizens (21 % of whom are Arab Israelis, and who, collectively, consist of a wide
variety of races and ethnicities) or
(2) administrative detainees (like U.S. terror suspects held at Guantanamo Bay). Under international
law, these inmates are not hostages. I don't know where you are getting your information about these
matters, but you need to vet your sources better.
Error #3: 1 understand the resolution uses the term "ethnic cleansing." While someone could
righteously take issue with the alleged number of civilian casualties in this conflict (a complicated
topic), Israel is not doing anything that qualifies as "ethnic cleansing." Here is a graphic that provides
a simplistic but accurate illustration of what is and is not ethnic cleansing.
IS,
ETHNIC
r �/��yriC
� %/% /% �j�
'1�/% /� /// a �,,, „ „ i ,,,,, ��, ��<
'G...YPT nw�uww�w���;www�������www..�.atiwMwuirwwu�o
���-rrwr�wwr�rwiwr�r�rr�rrw�w�a�rrwr�wrr�w�rrrwrw�rrnr�wr�w!�rwwr�ww�rw�wrrrri��:wr!r�..��?rrr�!w
IRAN
/ r
IRAQ ---------
i;
� errs rr+ rr� ..rn r,.w r� �wrw a� � rw �r.,u riw � rrwr rw r.n •wiw wrce � !ww� � ur yi.. �
RC
r
— ——
YEMEN
. �
�
�IA,
ri ,Z
,
LYErru � rr � wrw� rr oar rrr !wYYf rr rYw wrr rr rvr d�r,:irY rr rr MWW� rr` rw Y�YR r� uWrw rra'+�W9 r +� grw -;
TUNISIA
T, H IS I,
r /
�� /iirrrrr �f
Apartheid and Genocide: I do not know whether the proposed resolution uses these terms. If it does,
then please be advised that Israel is not doing either of these things. I can provide detailed legal
explanations if anyone is interested.
ONE-SIDED, HYPOCRITICAL RESOLUTION
I understand the proposed resolution (1) fails to condemn Hamas for its October 7th atrocities; (2)
refuses to recognize that a civilized, moral society cannot ever permit intentional and gruesome
crimes committed against innocent civilians, e.g., murder, torture, rape, mayhem, and public
desecration of victims' bodies; (3) neglects to demand the immediate return of Israeli hostages; (4)
does not insist upon an immediate surrender by Hamas wrongdoers; and (5) declines to plead for
peace negotiations. In other words, the resolution expresses concern about innocent Gazan civilians
(which is fine) but [i] refuses express corresponding concern about innocent Israeli citizens (which is
an appalling double -standard) and [ii] indicates no desire to see a viable long-term resolution to the
ongoing conflict. So, the council's proposed resolution is the quintessence of hypocrisy. A moral,
ethical person would express concern about all the innocent victims and would seek a solution. Such
one-sidedness reflects prejudice and discrimination by this council. Is this council really that depraved
and immoral? Does this council truly reject fundamental notions of DEI? By adopting this resolution,
this council will be telling the world that Santa Ana is an ugly place that approves of bigotry and
unfairness.
The proposed resolution is sadly consistent with the local school district's misstep in illegally adopting
a discriminatory ethnic studies curriculum geared to indoctrinate the next generation of Jew -haters. I
cannot speak for the school district's legal counsel, but if I were that attorney, I would be begging the
council to drop the resolution. It just makes Santa Ana look like a hotbed of Jew -hate and would give
the plaintiffs' attorneys more evidence.
CONTEXT & HARM
Jews worldwide are still reeling from the October 7th Hamas atrocities - the single deadliest day for
Jews since the Holocaust. It's personal for us: every Jew knows someone who was massacred or
kidnapped. If that weren't enough, many of us have experienced and/or witnessed recent acts of
antisemitism, and we live in fear of increasingly violent and unlawful protest activity. Indeed, Nazi
Germany has been reincarnated here in 21st Century Southern California. Resolutions like yours
encourage Jew -haters to do more to harass and harm local Jews ... and why? We American Jews
have no control over events that in Israel. None, whatsoever. So, your efforts would increase Jew -
hate and Jew harm but with no corresponding benefit (as if there ever could be a benefit from
bigotry).
CONTEXT & INEFFECTUALITY
Ceasefire resolutions might be a trendy far -left public gesture, but they affect nothing in the Middle
East.
Backstory and context: on a nearly -nonstop basis since 2007, Hamas has been lobbing rockets
toward civilian areas in Israel. On October 7th, Hamas took its civilian death campaign to a diabolical
new level. It was the proverbial straw that broke the camel's back.
Like any nation, Israel has a fiduciary and ethical obligation to protect its diverse citizenship. Given
the heinous new heights of the most recent Hamas offensive, Israel has understandably determined
that Hamas must be wiped out. Accordingly, Israel has important military objectives: (1) destroy
Hamas' war machine; (2) neutralize Hamas personnel; (3) rescue hostages; (4) minimize civilian
casualties (notwithstanding Hamas' dedicated human shield tactics). In the context of Israel's
important obligations to its own people, what makes this council think Israel cares about the Santa
Ana city council's desire for a ceasefire? Especially when this council's resolution demonstrates one-
sided, hypocritical bigotry and an utter lack of concern about innocent Israelis? Pro tip: Israel could
not care less about the desires of the Santa Ana city council, especially if the council is sending a
bigoted, one-sided, unhelpful message.
HISTORY & PERSPECTIVE
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. Unfortunately, the historical record demonstrates that
a ceasefire ultimately will (1) prolong the war and (2) escalate bilateral casualties.
Senior Hamas leaders have clearly said they intend to attack Israel again and again until they
eradicate Israel and all the Jews therein. See,
e.g., https:Heconomictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/hamas-official-vows-to-repeat-oct-7-
attack-repeatedly-to-teach-israel-a-lesson/articleshow/104903949.cros
Hamas is the sole cause of all Palestinian and Israeli casualties. See,
e.g., https://www.fdd.org/podcasts/2023/12/01/what-hamas-believes/
The people of Gaza deserve a better future; this will be possible only when Hamas is gone.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, it would do only bad things: (1)
harm local Jews, (2) add more fuel to an already -raging inferno of hatred and conflict, and (3) publicly
demonstrate that Santa Ana is a city of bigotry and unfairness. Please vote no on the Ceasefire
Resolution.
Thank you for your kind attention to this important matter.
Very truly yours,
Name withheld due to concerns about retribution
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:08 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Council -members,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Heena Hameed
Alcala, Abigail
From: Melvin Steiner <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 4:06 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19
To ALL of the Santa Ana City Council Members.
Any plan for the City Council to make such a resolution is utterly abhorrent.
It is completely out of the scope of what I believe the council has authority to do.
How much time have you taken to discuss with all of your constituents? I would venture to guess, very
few. And very few people are aware of your plan.
This is not an item for our city to even explore. Leave it to the Federal Government, Executive Branch and
Department of Defense.
You can better represent our city by working on the issues that affect the city and the residents
I have been here for nearly 31 years in the same home and saddened by the decline of the entire city.
STOP and think what you are doing. Your personal agendas are not what we are looking for on City
leadership.
In
REALTOR® I Lic# 01497016
(
* in 0 a 1=
C
INTERNATIONAL REAL ESTATE
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
pfpollack <
Monday, December 4, 2023 4:07 PM
eComment
Please Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Paul F. Pollack
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Soshea Leibler <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 4:31 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
re Israel
Dear City Council,
Please let me share my strong support for the state of Israel and their right to defend themselves against vicious
Hamas terrorists. if at this moment in history you don't stand on the side of Israel- you are standing in support of
terrorists who rape, kidnap, behead and behave exactly like ISIS. that's not how you want to go down in history.
Israel has every right to protect itself against missile attacks, and violent, murderous attacks on its civilians.
Please show your support.
Thank you,
Soshea 11..,eibier
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Rozanne Treger <
Monday, December 4, 2023 4:37 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Rozanne Treger
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Brian Byrd <
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 4:44 PM
To: eComment
Subject: December 5th council Mtg
To whom it may concern:
I write to express deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in Gaza,
particularly its one-sided nature and potential consequences. As residents, we urge you to
consider the broader impact on our community and focus on issues that directly affect Santa Ana,
such as the homeless crisis, affordable housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street safety.
I fear that a resolution on an international conflict over which the City Council has no authority
may divert attention from pressing local matters and invite divisive rhetoric, as witnessed in other
cities. We respectfully request that the City Council prioritize the needs of our constituents by
withdrawing the proposed resolution and redirecting attention to pressing issues within the
jurisdiction of the City.
Rgds,
Brian Byrd
Santa Ana, Ca
92706
Sent from my iPhone
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Cynthia Kestenbaum <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 4:45 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Cynthia kestenbaum
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nathalie Vilinsky <
Monday, December 4, 2023 4:01 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely
Nathalie vilinsky
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
philip fischer <
Monday, December 4, 2023 4:51 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Pinny
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Karen Robinovitz <
Monday, December 4, 2023 5:01 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Karen Robinovitz
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sarah Sever <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 8:57 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:05 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 5:02 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
elizabeth agredano
Email
Address
Placentia, California 92870
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
Comments or questions
Dear Mayor Amezcua,
I write in support of the Santa Ana (SA) Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire. As an
Orange County (Placentia) resident who was born in SA and has many SA residents in my immediate family and friend's circle, I
will always feel especially connected to SA. That SA is proposing this resolution is nothing short of visionary. I am proud of the
City Council for taking the brave and difficult step of proposing this resolution and I hope that it passes. I have always been
proud of being from SA and if this passes, I will have another reason to feel immense pride in my hometown, as it will prove that
SA is a city of groundbreaking vision in support of human rights, justice, and sovereignty for all people, which is not easy, given
the United States political incentives to support Israel despite its decades long history of displacement and recent war crimes.
In writing to support the resolution I also write to support you through the backlash you might get, which follow common Zionist
talking points or manipulate Jewish trauma in order to support Zionism. First, this resolution is not antisemitic, as it is not
antisemitic to acknowledge human rights violations, war crimes, and blatant imperialism that are documented and upheld by
non -partisan international organizations such as Human Rights Watch and the United Nations. Passing this resolution would
show that SA is politically sophisticated, and does not obfuscate Israel with Judaism. Israel is a nation state, a political body, with
its roots in a nationalist political movement, not in Judaism. Judaism calls for each person to take upon themselves the
responsibility to better the world towards justice and an ideal state of affairs where we can all experience wholeness, a sense of
peace, and work cooperatively towards a messianic age. It does not follow that indiscriminate bombing resulting in the killing of
15,500 Palestinians (over 6,000 of them children) is in line with Jewish values in any sense of the word. This resolution is not
antisemitic because Israel's actions are not Jewish. Their actions are political; decisions of a president who is currently
undergoing a corruption trail. Anti-antisemitism, the hatred of Jewish people, has risen since the war began, and we must be
clear-eyed enough to focus on calling out true antisemitism and preventing hate crimes rather than be distracted by suggestions
that calling for peace, human development, and protection of citizens, as this resolution does, is antisemitic. The City of SA will
have to ensure that its citizens understand the difference between antisemitism and calling for an end to Israel's war in order to
protect its Jewish citizens, especially considering that Orange County's oldest synagogue is located in Santa Ana.
I hope that SA will not engage with Zionist justifications for Israel's onslaught following Hama's reprehensible October 7th attack.
SA should blatantly disavow Hamas while maintaining that Israel's actions are not one of self-defense or a focused dismantling
of the militant group, but rather on carpet bombing an entire region. Israel and its supporters will use phrases such as "freeing
Palestinians from Hamas" or blaming Hamas for using Palestinian as "human shields" to justify their actions while dropping more
than 25,000 tons of explosives on the Gaza. It is clear who is to blame for the killing of innocent Palestinian people. Both the
actions of Hamas on 10/7 and Israel's subsequent actions are war crimes.
SA should be careful with the appropriation of the memory of the Holocaust in supporting a ceasefire and the Palestinian people,
as it imperils the city to accusations of antisemitism or using Jewish trauma to support Palestine. Although Israel is perpetrating
three of five acts the UN Genocide Convention lists as defining genocide: 1. Killing members of the group. 2. Causing serious
bodily or mental harm to members of the group. 3. Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about
its physical destruction in whole or in part", i believe it is important to be careful with ones wording when passing a resolution as
brave as this. It may be inappropriate to invoke the phrase "Never Again", especially considering how Holocaust memory is
being used by Israel itself to justify unimaginable levels of death and destruction, and may be more reasoned to focus on the
UN's definition of genocide as enough to call for a ceasefire.
Gaza is currently the most dangerous places to be a child, according to UNICEF, and Israel's actions are only possible through
the US financial support. This resolution is a tremendous step in making the world a safer place for children by demonstrating
that SA is a progressive justice -focused city in the US that opposes what is likely to go down in history as a humanitarian
disaster perpetrated by the US by proxy.
Thank you for all you do.
My Best,
EA
Araiza, Fatima
From: R Lidsky < >
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:04 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support for Israel
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered
without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to
minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no
other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise
attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-
defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this
they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Best,
Rose Raskas
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Daniel Block <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:10 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Daniel Block
Araiza, Fatima
From: Ruth Seigle <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:11 PIV
To: eComment
Subject: City Council Meeting
I oppose the city council considering any resolution on the Gaza war. Our city council should focus on Santa
Ana and local issues.
Ruth Seigle
Flower Street
Araiza, Fatima
From: Zara M <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:20 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Santa Ana Council
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Trang Do
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Onir Spiegel <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:20 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Get Outlook for Android
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tehillah Harris <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:21 PM
To: eComment
Subject: I stand with Israel
Dear City Council -
I was very distressed to hear the vitriolic, blatant Anti Semitic statements made during the public comments section at
your November 7th meeting.
I also have deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in Gaza - Can you please explain why your
local city council is involving itself in foreign policy?
It can't be that you possibly believe you can impact or effect the political issues in another country... This seems to be a
thinly veiled opportunity for hate mongering against Jews at a time when we are seeing a surge of anti semitic crimes in
our country.
You are creating a potential for violence and hate - with a negligible possibly payoff.
Please consider withdrawing the proposed resolution.
Tehillah Harris
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Beata Lyashevska <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:21 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Beata
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Ruth Ifrah <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:25 PM
To: eComment
Subject: STAND WITH ISRAEL
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered
without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to
minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no
other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise
attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-
defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this
they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Thank you.
Ruth
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Ester Lebovich <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:25 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Esther Lebovich
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Carmit Solomon <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:26 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Carmit Solomom
Araiza, Fatima
From: Brenda Goldstein <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:31 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Brenda Goldstein
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:40 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Stand with Israel , good over evil
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again
Tamar Ornstein
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Maya Dayan <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:41 PIV
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thanks, Maya
Araiza, Fatima
From: Kyler <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:46 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Noha Abdou <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:49 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Noha Abdou
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from Noha's iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Liat Solomon <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:48 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Please read
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Affnan Zubi <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:49 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Affnan Zubi
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Eleina Addes <
Monday, December 04, 2023 5:51 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Eleina Addes
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Shayna Franks <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 5:53 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Stand For Israel
Hamas does not want peace! Peace lovers m don't gouge peoples eyes out, burn babies and families alive, capture
women and children, dismember and rape civilians — all while LAUGHING, MOCKING and BRAGGING of their feats.
Hamas tortures its own people. They MUST be DESTROYED. Israel us the ONLY country in the world that tries to protects
innocent civilians- an almost impossible task when the enemy disguises as and hides in the very midst of the civilian
population.
Think critically. See past the smoke and mirrors. Israel deserves to defend itself.
HAMAS doesn't let its people seek shelter. HAMAS wants the citizens of Gaza dead so they can garner world sympathy.
DEMAND HAMAS PROTECT THE GAZAN CIVILIANS!
Be smarter. Put the blame where it's due and support Israel - don't fool yourselves to think that your children are
protected from the same tragedies suffered in Israel .
Never Again is Now
S. Franks
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sarhe Mandel <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:05 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Israel
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered
without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to
minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no
other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise
attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-
defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this
they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:08 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Israel has a right and duty to depend itself
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Yermi Ornstein
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Share Mandel <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:09 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Israel
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered
without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to
minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no
other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise
attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-
defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this
they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.I
Araiza, Fatima
From: Lenore Rabin -Koster <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:09 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Lenore Koster
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Basya Pinter <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:25 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Stand with Israel
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered
without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to
minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no
other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise
attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-
defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this
they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lara Goldberg <
Monday, December 04, 2023 6:29 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: devorah moshiach <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:37 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Stand with the good and good will stand with you!
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Araiza, Fatima
From: weatherwoman365 (null) <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:43 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Lori Maslow
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Khadeeja Abdullah <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:44 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Khadeeja Abdullah
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: efrem joelson <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:50 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
The State Department revealed Monday the reason why Hamas continues to hold hostages underground is the
Gaza Strip. More specifically, why they are refusing to release female hostages.
According to State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller, the Iranian backed terrorist organization isn't
releasing additional female hostages, who were violently taken from their homes and a music festival in Israel
on October 7, because they know and have experienced too much while in captivity. In other words, they don't
want them speaking out about what has been done to them.
There are American hostages!
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you.
Efrem Joelson
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Cheryl Singer <
Monday, December 04, 2023 6:53 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Cheryl Singer
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Hannah Wolinsky <
Monday, December 04, 2023 6:54 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo,
allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and
Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently
incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Respectfully,
Hannah Wolinsky, Esq.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Geraldine t'Felt <
Monday, December 04, 2023 6:56 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Geraldine't Felt - Rutenberg
Mobile:
Sent from my iPhone with apologies for any typos or word substitutions.
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Elif Bashir <
Sent:
Monday, December 4, 2023 7:02 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
CEASEFIRE IN PALESTINE NOW
ISRAEL IS AN APARTHEID REGIME AND FOR DECADES IT HAS DONE NOTHING BUT GENOCIDE
AND MURDER. NOW THAT USA IS A HUGE SUPPORTER OF ISRAEL AND USA IS ALLOWING
ISRAEL TO USE BANNED AND ILLEGAL WEAPONS ON CIVILIANS SUCH AS BUNKER BOMBS,
WHITE PHOSPHORUS, TO NAME A COUPLE. THIS VIOLATES INTERNATIONAL LAW AND IS A
VIOLATION OF HUMANITY. ISRAEL NEEDS TO END ITS OCCUPATION AND OPPRESSION. IT
NEEDS TO END GAZA GENOCIDE, AND KILLINGS AND DETAINING IN WEST BANK. ISRAEL
NEEDS TO LEAVE PALESTINE ALONE. PALESTINIANS ARE THE SEMITES. THEY BELONG TO
PALESTINE. ISRAEL NEEDS TO GO BACK TO EUROPE, THE REGION OF THEIR DESCENDENTS.
END GENOCIDE. STOP COMPLYING WITH ISRAEL. END THIS MADNESS RIGHT NOW. CEASEFIRE
RIGHT NOW!!!!!!!!
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mustafa Elfarra <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 9:48 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I am writing to support the resolution calling for a ceasefire now in Gaza. Please vote yes in support of the resolution.
Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 7:07 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution
submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez. Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath
of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us
have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly
condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th
and their aftermath. The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt
by both the Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis
have been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on
October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings
and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages. Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire
with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior
Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews.
Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which
is possible only once Hamas is gone. A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue
to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays
off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more
violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians. While this resolution may have been introduced
with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict.
Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Rochel Rabinowitz <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 7:11 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Rochel Rabinowitz.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sondos Kholaki <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 7:17 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sondos Kholaki
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Deborah Y <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 7:19 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support Israel
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Thank you,
Deborah
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
BURT LIEBROSS <
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:33 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Debbie Beran <
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:38 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Deborah Beran
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Michele Weiss <
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:40 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank You
Michele Weiss
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Michal Babay <
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:42 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Monday, December 04, 2023 7:42 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 7:50 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Resolution in solidarity with the Palestinian people.
Santa Ana has been a leader in OC on so many issues. We need our Council to ince again lead the
way and take a stance against Israel's genocide and ethnic cleansing campaign against the people of
Palestine.
Please vote in solidarity with the Palestinian people.
CPO Virus®free.www;aVrasf orrin,
Araiza, Fatima
From: Kimberly M <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 7:57 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support Palestine Resolution
I urge you to vote in support of the solidarity for Palestine and ceasefire resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Eileen Harbater <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:04 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Humanitarian Efforts of Israel
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered without
warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to minimize civillian
casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no other army that would put
their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise attacks, which would certainly be
more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week,
Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again
and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was
a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any
ceasefires moving forward. Asking for a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been
the case for their grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Sincerely,
Dr Eileen Harbater
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sam <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:07 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Please support a cease fire
Daily children are be slaughtered
You must please support a ceasefire
Thankyou
Dr Sam Borno
Araiza, Fatima
From: Chana Berkowitz <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 6:47 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Anti -Israel sentiments
Good evening,
Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians murdered
without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts to
minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is no
other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform surprise
attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting in self-
defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to this
they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
CZB1
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:11 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Cease fire in Gaza
With the death toll among civilians including helpless children We need an immediate ceasefire in Gaza
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Julia Gandelsman <
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:15 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Julia Gandelsman
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Jaco van Broekhuizen <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:28 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Hearing tomorrow 12/5
I write to express deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in Gaza, particularly its
one-sided nature and potential consequences. As residents, we urge you to consider the broader impact on
our community and focus on issues that directly affect Santa Ana, such as the homeless crisis, affordable
housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street safety.
I fear that a resolution on an international conflict over which the City Council has no authority may divert
attention from pressing local matters and invite divisive rhetoric, as witnessed in other cities. We respectfully
request that the City Council prioritize the needs of our constituents by withdrawing the proposed resolution
and redirecting attention to pressing issues within the jurisdiction of the City.
Jaco
Araiza, Fatima
From: Marlene Mordowitz <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 8:29 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Marlene Mordowitz
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Shoshi Barkai <
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:29 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you!
Shoshi Barkai
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Samantha Maya <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:31 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Ending Antisemitism, support of Israel is pro- Palestinian
To Whom it May Concern:
Any pro -Palestinian rally or support for Palestine is in fact antisemitic because these rallys support the destruction of
Israel and the genocide of the Jews.
When we attend any pro -Israel rally we are in fact pro -Palestinian. The moment the world eradicates terrorism in the
region is the moment the Palestinians will see peace. Hamas has ruined the lives of Palestinians, robbed them, murdered
them and used them as human shields. Eradicating terrorism is what Israel intends to do; so supporting Israel is
supporting Palestinians.
In partnership,
Samantha Maya
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Ariel Kopelioff <
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:46 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lisa Sturm <
Monday, December 04, 2023 8:54 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Lisa Sturm
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sarah Hashemi <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 9:01 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Voting (Yes) CEASFIRE for GAZA
Greetings Dear Santa Ana Council Members and the Mayors office,
Please consider our vote " YES" to call for a Ceasefire for Gaza and de-escalation for a permanent peace
process allowing humanitarian AID to enter and rebuilding efforts but primary Medical Aid for all the injured
victims to prevent any further atrocities of civilians. Orange County has always been a beacon of hope as a
largely diverse community we are grateful for your support/advocacy and leadership. God bless thank you
Sara Hashemi MBA
CEO/President
-0fl S WOSB
, J.
Woitte(hreretl5mall Buanets
This e-mail, including attachments, is intended for the exclusive use of the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain
confidential or privileged information. If the reader of this e-mail is not the intended recipient or his or her authorized agent, the
reader is hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you think that you have
received this e-mail in error, please advise the sender by reply e-mail of the error and then delete this e-mail immediately
Araiza, Fatima
From: Amgad Ellaboudy <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 9:08 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Dear Members of the Santa Ana City Council,
I am writing to you with a sense of urgency and a deep concern for the escalating conflict in Gaza. It is crucial
for our community, as a symbol of peace and solidarity, to support a ceasefire resolution immediately.
The ongoing violence in Gaza has resulted in devastating loss of life, injury, and destruction, impacting
countless innocent civilians. By advocating for a ceasefire, we can contribute to halting this tragic loss and
suffering. A ceasefire will provide much -needed relief and create a window for humanitarian aid, which is
desperately required in the region.
Furthermore, supporting a ceasefire aligns with our city's values of promoting peace, human rights, and
international cooperation. It is an opportunity for Santa Ana to be a leader in advocating for global peace and
stability.
Time is of the essence. Every moment we delay, more lives are at risk. I urge you to take immediate action and
support a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. Let us stand together for peace and humanity.
Sincerely,
Amgad Ellaboudy
Orange County Resident
-Amgad Ellaboudy
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Stephanie Gayshon <
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:32 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mustafa Elfarra <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 9:48 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I am writing to support the resolution calling for a ceasefire now in Gaza. Please vote yes in support of the resolution.
Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
gabrielle hazan <
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:50 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Laura Ben-Shimon <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 9:51 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Laura Simon
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
nanette cutler <
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:01 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Nanette Cutler
Sent from my iPad
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Kim Riley <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 10:07 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David
Subject:
eComment for Item #19 on 12/5/2023 Santa Ana City Council Meeting
Dear Mayor and Council Members,
I am writing in FULL SUPPORT of the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire (item 419 on the 12/5/2023 Santa Ana City Council meeting agenda).
I want to thank Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez for bringing this resolution to council.
The Israeli occupation forces have murdered over 15,000 Palestinians since October 7, and have displaced the
vast majority of the Gazan population. Images and videos coming from Gaza do not lie - the destruction of
homes, businesses, and whole blocks are horrific. Humanitarian aid is urgently needed, and must be supported
by our local Congress members.
The City of Santa Ana has an opportunity to stand against injustice and be a leader in our Orange County
community!
I urge you to APPROVE the resolution.
In solidarity,
Kim Riley
Anaheim, CA 92805
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:08 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Council -members,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Heena Hameed
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mohammed Asifuddin <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 10:18 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Mohammed Asifuddin
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tanaz Yeroushalmi <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:02 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Debby Gabbai <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:03 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Debby@debbysrealty.com
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
ronit yeroushalmi <
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:04 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
rachellfried <
Sent:
Monday, December 04, 2023 11:19 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Rachell Fried
Sent from my V rizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Lourdes Sandoval <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:30 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Ceasefire Resolution Item 19
Ladies and gentlemen of the city council,
Thank you for your time, I'm a resident in Ward 5.
As a teacher, I am privileged to witness the boundless potential within the hearts and minds of our
youth. It is with this perspective that I come before you today, not just as a concerned citizen but as
someone deeply connected to the future we are shaping for our children.
Children should be immersed in the joy of learning, discovering the wonders of the world around them,
and envisioning the limitless possibilities that lie ahead.
Yet, as we convene in the comfort of this chamber, there are children in Gaza who should be reveling
in the joys of childhood playing, learning, and growing.
Children should be learning in a classroom not sheltering in one along with 25 people and bombed
while they sleep like they did at the Kuwait School in Gaza on Nov. 20th.
Children should be playing during recess not witnessing the same images of blood and destruction that
as adults we have a hard time seeing.
Children should be writing their names on their homework not on their arms in case their bodies are
found like they did in northern Gaza.
Children should know when their parents are coming back not left in this world without them as many
medical professionals and organizations(including Doctors Without Borders) in hospitals have to
identify with the common acronym in Gaza "WCNSF." "Wounded Child No Surviving Family"
I ask today that you support a ceasefire resolution so that our state representatives can see that citizens
of Santa Ana care about all people. That what is happening to the people of Palestine is unacceptable
and will not be tolerated. The world is watching, but most importantly our children are watching.
I urge you, as representatives of our community, to consider the stark contrast between the aspirations
of the children I teach and those in occupied Palestine who are picking through the remnants of their
homes. Our collective responsibility extends beyond our city limits; it reaches across oceans to
embrace the shared humanity that binds us all.
Let our plea for a cease-fire be a testament to our commitment to the well-being of all children,
regardless of borders. Let us be advocates for the right of every child to experience the joys of
childhood.
I implore each one of you to stand with me, not just as representatives but as stewards of a future where
the children and people of Palestine can flourish in the embrace of peace and opportunity.
Thank you.
Lourdes
Araiza, Fatima
From: M&C Ingber <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:34 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support GOOD I S R A E L from evil -
We strongly condem evil & would hope to believe that you would too!
Israel was attacked & is continued to be attacked by evil Hamas & Hezbolla!
We need to feel & see that good is backed by this city council!
Thank you in advance
Sara White
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sara Hussain <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:23 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sara Ahmed
Araiza, Fatima
From: Liz A < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:04 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Liz A < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:04 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Gonny Katzir <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:38 AM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sharon <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 2:08 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sharon Zughaft
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sandra <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 2:10 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Council members,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
I have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sandra S
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Lori Rof6
Dear Council Members,
Lori Rofe <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:07 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: lylybeth nino <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:27 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Lylybeth Nino
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Cynthia Kestenbaum <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:29 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Cynthia kestenbaum
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Shirley Bassiri Rahmani <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:40 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Shirley Bassiri
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nancybassiri <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:57 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Nancy Bassiri
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:07 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Tia Faisal
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Viviana Gomez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:28 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Viviana
Araiza, Fatima
From: Karim Hakim <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:40 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:48 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nazeef kazi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: GULNAZ RAHMAN <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:57 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Gulnaz
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: hena <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:58 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Usman Ghani <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:58 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Usman Ghani
Araiza, Fatima
From: Yesenia Chavez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:01 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Amr Riched <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:06 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Eva <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:07 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Daniel G <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:19 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely
Daniel Vann
Araiza, Fatima
From: Christine Assaf <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:22 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Lizah Samat <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:22 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Liza
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: musbahn <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:23 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nahlah Musbah
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G iAT Device
Araiza, Fatima
From: Stephen Arnsler <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:28 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Proposed Resolution
Dear City Council, I write to express my deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in
Gaza, particularly its one-sided nature and potential consequences. As a resident of Santa Ana for 37 years, I
urge you to consider the broader impact on our community and focus on issues that directly affect Santa Ana,
such as the homeless crisis, affordable housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street safety.
The resolution on an international conflict over which the City Council has no authority will divert attention
from pressing local matters and invite divisive rhetoric'
as witnessed in other cities. I respectfully request that
the City Council prioritize the needs of our constituents by withdrawing the proposed resolution and
redirecting attention to pressing issues within the jurisdiction of the City.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
george Eshaghian <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:38 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
George Eshaghian
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Javid Moreh <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:41 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: tazeen k <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:41 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Tazeen
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Joseph Amin <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:42 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Best Regards
Joseph
Araiza, Fatima
From: Joe alamad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:49 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Lilian Kashfian <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:50 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Lili Kash
Araiza, Fatima
From: Behzad Kianmand <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:54 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mark Haloossim <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:54 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Mark Haloossim
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Henry Talei <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:04 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Alina Kaufman <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:13 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alina Kaufman
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Ida Aris <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:18 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Ida Mat Aris
Santa Ana, CA 92705
ONTARIO, CA 91761
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:20 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 6:50 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Nancy McMillin
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I am appalled that the city council would even take a side against Jews, a people who have been persecuted throughout human
history. Shame!
"... first they came for socialists, and I did not speak out, because I am not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade....
Then they came for the Jews....
Then they came for me. And there was no one left to speak
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:21 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Monday, December 4, 2023 10:10 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Sara N
Email
Address
California
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I am writing tonight because I am concerned about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support
of a Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting. I was sad to hear that this resolution was bringing brought for
discussion the way it is written.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
I am a teacher, and I always teach my students that we can't let our subjective views get in the way of being fair and unbiased.
Both perspectives are not truly being included in this resolution, and I am sad that not all voices are being heard. Two things can
be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in
Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit
of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
Please reject the resolution as it is written, thank you.
Sincerely,
Sara Naudin
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:21 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 6:51 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Barry Kahn
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92707
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Santa Ana needs to reject the profoundly Jew Hating and Anti-Semetic "Solidarity with the Palestinian People Resolution" as it is
written.
There is a simple definition of Anti-Semitism: Holding Jews to a different or higher standard than other groups or holding Israel to
a different or higher standard than other countries.
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:21 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 7:54 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
shana segall
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92612
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Shana Segall
Araiza, Fatima
From: Cassandra Perez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:22 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Cassandra Perez
Lomita, CA 90717
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Einat Ronen <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:22 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Einat Ronen
Araiza, Fatima
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:22 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 8:22 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Eddie Segall
Email
Address
Irvine, California Ca
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Araiza, Fatima
From: Rick Amborski <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:24 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19
City Council- I am opposed to the City Council in the upcoming vote to support the solidarity for Palestine
and the Cease Fire. You are doing this when Hamas plans to rape women, behead, and continue to burn
babies? Your moral compass is broken if you go ahead with such a disturbing vote! The nation of Israel is
defending their country in an unprovoked attack. The Palestinian people are being used as pawns by Hamas.
Your upcoming vote is outside your scope of work. And, you do not represent my values.
There can be hope for a two state solution only after Hamas is eradicated.
Rick Amborski Resident of Santa Ana
Araiza, Fatima
From: eman ismaiel <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:26 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Eman Ismaiel
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Brandon Gallegos <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:30 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Brandon Gallegos
Santa Ana, CA 92707
Araiza, Fatima
From: Halima Sat <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:31 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Halima Sat
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Faye Saied <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:32 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Comment on Agenda Item 19: "Discuss and Consider Directing the Interim City
Manager to Prepare a Resolution for City Council's Consideration to Call in Support of
a Ceasefire in Gaza"
I am commenting in support of the resolution to call for a ceasefire in Gaza. A majority of the population
supports a ceasefire and, as citizens who are implicated in Israel's actions through the support our government
gives from our taxes to the Israeli military, we must speak up in every way, including this resolution, to call for
the violence to end. This resolution should have already been passed a month and 10,000 needless deaths ago.
How many more innocent lives destroyed will it take if this is not enough for you?
Araiza, Fatima
From: shahida umar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:32 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Karen Arnsler <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:33 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Proposed resolution
Dear City Council, I want to express my deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in
Gaza, particularly its one-sided nature and potential consequences. As a resident of Santa Ana for 37 years, I
urge you to consider the broader impact on our community and focus on issues that directly affect Santa Ana,
such as the homeless crisis, affordable housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street safety.
I fear that a resolution on an international conflict over which the City Council has no authority, may divert
attention from pressing local matters and invite divisive rhetoric, as witnessed in other cities. I respectfully
request that the City Council prioritize the needs of our constituents by withdrawing the proposed resolution
and redirecting attention to pressing issues within the jurisdiction of the City.
Thank you,
Karen Annsler
Araiza, Fatima
From: Jennifer Carbajal <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:32 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Jennifer Carbajal
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Hulya Peker <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:34 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Hulya Peker
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:35 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Annalisa Bejarano
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Christina Ruiz <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:51 AM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Christina Ruiz
Santa Ana, CA 92704
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:00 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Sarah Miller
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ameena Qazi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:09 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Ameena Mirza Qazi, Esq.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Alejandra Gonzalez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:11 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Alejandra Killekar
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Alexis Serrato <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:11 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Alexis Serrato
Santa Ana, CA 92703
Alcala, Abigail
From: Halima Shabandri <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:14 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:17 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Safia Mullick <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:20 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Marya Bangee <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:20 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Marya Bangee
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Mazna Ahmad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:21 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Dr. Mazna Ahmad
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Nushin Alloo <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:26 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nushin Alloo
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Holly Sen < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:28 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Ghazaly Salim
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Syed Abdullah <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:31 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Syed Abdullah
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Santa Ana council members,
Mahmoud <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 8:26 AM
eComment
Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Please consider supporting the Ceasefire in Gaza and allow humanitarian assistance to the Palestinian refugees in Gaza.
Thanks,
Mahmoud
Grandchild of 1948 Palestinian refugee
Father from Anaheim
Alcala, Abigail
From: Rana Kassab <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:38 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Rana>
Alcala, Abigail
From: Mudassir <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:40 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Syed Ahmed
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Sarah Dakak <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:41 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Please support resolution for a Ceasefire in Palestine
Hello Mayor and Councilmembers,
My name is Sarah, and I am a healthcare executive from Santa Ana, and I am distraught by the atrocities happening in
Palestine and our governments role in enabling it. I implore you to lend your powerful and impactful voices to the call
for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sarah
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sarah Dakak
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Shai Nafte <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:42 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sincerely,
Shai Nafte
Alcala, Abigail
From: R Gabriel <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:43 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Rae Chelle V
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:45 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:31 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Leane Kahrs
Email
Address
Tustin, California 92780
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:45 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:32 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Henry Kahrs
Email
Address
Tustin, California 92780
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Alcala, Abigail
From: Natalie Gonzalez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:48 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Natalie Gonzalez
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Maria Estela Valencia <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:50 AM
To: eComment; Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; Bacerra, Phil
Subject: Support - Resolution for a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Council Members,
My name is Maria Estela Valencia, and I reside in Ward 6. I have lived in Santa Ana most of my life. I have
come to see and understand the importance of living in dignity and peace, so I urge you to vote yes in
supporting a resolution for a Ceasefire. These past 59 days, I have seen the destruction and despair that the
Palestinian people in Gaza have faced. Growing up, I learned of what happened in the holocaust, and I always
asked myself what I would have done if I was a witness to something like that. Well, it's 2023, and I am
witnessing the ethnic cleansing, and I can either say it is a complicated issue or stand in solidarity with the
people of Palestine.
I am choosing not to stay silent and stand in solidarity with the Palestinian people and asking all of you also not
to remain silent and to stand in solidarity. The occupation and the massive destruction of Palestinian
neighborhoods in Gaza are something that we cannot pretend is not happening. They, too, deserve the right to
live in dignity and peace. So, I urge you to vote yes in supporting a resolution for a Ceasefire. The more that we
come together in calling out the Occupiers, the harder it is for them to commit these atrocities.
Thank you for taking the time to read my comment.
Blessings,
Maria E. Valencia
PS: Our liberation as a community is tied to the Palestinian Liberation.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Cecilia Avila <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:51 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Cecilia
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Saeid Fard <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:54 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Samantha Molina <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:56 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Samantha Abumallouh
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Mitzi Hernandez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 9:58 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Mitzi Hernandez
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Maya Haddad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:08 AM
To: eComment
Subject: "Agenda Item #19" Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
To Our Representatives,
We, the People, are in solidarity with the People of Palestine.
We want a permanent ceasefire and end to this horrible violence and genocide in Gaza. We, the American
people, and local citizens of Santa Ana, are forever changed and broken from what we've seen: over 21,000
Palestinians killed (over half of whom are children) plus countless injured and orphaned, entire families wiped
off the face of the earth.
We do not support this genocide. We don't approve of another dollar going towards Israel. Let's keep that
money here for the people who need it, and work IMMEDIATELY, to achieve peace, safety and human rights
for the Palestinian people.
CEASEFIRE NOW. No more money towards Israel. Free Palestine.
Sincerely,
Maya
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ahmad Cory Jubran <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:12 AM
To: eComment
Subject: "Agenda Item #19" Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
To Our Representatives,
• We want a PERMANENT CEASEFIRE NOW.
• We want human rights, freedom and dignity for the Palestinians.
• We don't want to send another dollar to Israel. (No more funding from the American taxpayer.)
• We want this genocide to end.
• We want the occupation to end.
Free Palestine. Please do the right thing.
Sincerely,
Cory
Alcala, Abigail
From: ZeyroXlll <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:18 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely, Edgar Lita
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tanaz Yeroushalmi <
Sent: Monday, December 04, 2023 11:02 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: 86inka Hip Hop <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:20 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Maria Ceja <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:22 AM
To: eComment
Subject: In Support of Council Member Requested Item #19
Greeting City Council,
I am writing in support of the council member requested item 419 to direct the Interim City Manager to prepare
a resolution to call for an immediate Ceasefire in Gaza. The Insitute for Middle East Understanding (IMEU) has
reported that Israel has murdered over 21,000 Palestinians since October 7th, more than half being children and
women. IMEU also reports that 80 percent (1.9 million people) of Gaza's population has been displaced as a
result of the constant bombardment that they have faced these past 2 months that is funded by OUR TAX
DOLLARS! This is 6 times the current estimated Santa Ana population! Even when Israeli forces designate an
area as a "safe zone" they still bomb and attack Palestinians in these areas, a strategy aiming to harm and
constantly displace people from their homes, cities, and neighborhoods. Since the temporary pause ended, Israel
has escalated their attacks on Gaza, targeting homes, schools, and hospitals. I ask the City Council and staff to
empathize with the Palestinian people in Gaza and the West Bank, as well as the Palestinian people who call
Santa Ana and Orange County their current home and who have loved ones who still reside in occupied
Palestine. I ask that you put yourself and their shoes and imagine that you, your family, and the generations
before you were living through this terror for the past 75 years and 2 months. Let's follow the steps that cities,
such as Oakland, CA, Atlanta, Georgia, Akron, Ohio, Wilmington, Delaware, Providence, Rhode Island, and
multiple cities in Michigan, across the United States, have already taken, calling for an immediate and
permanent Ceasefire in Gaza.
Thank you,
Maria Ceja
(Santanera)
Alcala, Abigail
From: maryam ahmad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:23 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Greg Camphire <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:31 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19: Resolution to Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello Councilmembers,
I'd like to draw your attention to a place just blocks away from where you sit on the dais at City Hall, down the
street at the Santa Ana Public Library. On the front lawn along Civic Center Drive, there is a single statue
dedicated to a man named Alex Odeh. Mr. Odeh was a Palestinian -American poet, writer, and human rights
activist who fled his homeland as a refugee and made a new home in Orange County. He earned a master's
degree, raised a family, and led the West Coast office of the American -Arab Anti -Discrimination Committee
(ADC), which continues to fight against racism while advocating for fair Arab -American representation.
Alex Odeh was brutally murdered at his ADC office in Santa Ana on October 11, 1985. The FBI named three
suspects in connection with this horrible assassination who were linked to a far -right Zionist terrorist
organization and who fled to Israeli -occupied territories in Palestine. Nonetheless, Odeh's murder remains
unsolved and justice remains unserved.
On the day he died, Odeh was scheduled to speak at a local synagogue as part of his work uniting Jewish and
Arab communities in their shared struggle for civil rights. Rabbi Arnold Rachlis said that "Alex Odeh was an
advocate for justice for his people. He championed Palestinian rights, not because he wished to deny those of
others, but because he wanted his people's voice to be heard." On a related note, I highly recommend seeking
out Odeh's master's degree thesis from CSU Fullerton, "United States Policy Toward the Palestinian's in the
Overall Context of the Arab-Israeli Conflict."
It is extremely significant that the Santa Ana City Council unanimously approved Odeh's statue and its location
at the library, a communal meeting place of knowledge and understanding. More than 500 people attended the
statue's dedication ceremony in 1994, and at that time, it was the only known full-length outdoor statue in the
U.S. dedicated to an Arab -American.
Santa Ana, a city of immigrants and refugees, has chosen Odeh as our hero. It's especially significant that we
continue to honor Odeh at this time, as his people's voice is once again crying out in pain due to genocide and
ethnic cleansing. These horrors are being inflicted on Palestinians by a cruel autocratic government that
represents neither democracy nor the global Jewish diaspora. Many in our local communities are acutely feeling
the pain of the events in Gaza —not only Palestinian- and Jewish -Americans, but all residents who care about
human rights, justice, and peace. The city has an obligation to support these communities in a time of crisis, and
that time is now.
So I am writing now to strongly urge you to direct the Interim City Manager to prepare a resolution for
the City Council's consideration to call in support of a ceasefire in Gaza. It's in the best interest of our city
government to make a statement that will be remembered on the right side of history, echoing the statement
made with the dedication of Alex Odeh's statue. The inscription at the statue's base reminds us that "he was a
visionary, a builder of bridges which many may now safely cross." As a city, we must join the growing chorus
of calls for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza; the safe return of Israeli hostages to their families; and the return of
land to the Palestinian people. It's the least we can do and it's the right thing to do.
Thank you,
Greg Camphire
Ward 2
Alcala, Abigail
From: cynthea ocampo <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:37 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Cynthea Fernandez
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: karim salem <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:45 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Karim Salem
Alcala, Abigail
From: Miriam O. Nunez Valdovinos < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 10:55 AM
To: eComment
Subject: City of Santa Ana: Support Solidarity For Palestine & Ceasefire Resolution
Good morning,
I am sharing my public comment as it pertains to supporting the efforts of
the Latino Muslim Community and Islamic Shura Council of Southern
California. It is my understanding that you will hear preliminary public
comments this week and will vote next week. I urge you to support any of
our non-violent efforts to denounce the heinous actions demoralizing the
Palestinian survivors of genocide.
I would like to thank you in advance for taking the time to read my
opposition to the Palestinian -Israel conflict and hope that we can count on
your council to represent and support our muslim community that exists
within your region as well as across the globe. May your solidarity serve as an
example of the humane politicians our society needs.
Sincerely,
Miriam
Miriam O. Nun"ez Valdovinos
Pronouns: She, Her, Hers, Ella
mmezv. miriam(a�mail. com
Confidentiality Statement
This e-mail message, including attachments, is for official use only and by the intended recipient and may
contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is
prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies
of the original message.
1
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:03 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:01 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Bob Klein
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92614
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
The Israel -Palestine conflict is far beyond the City of Santa Ana's oversight.
Do not reward Hamas terrorists for their hateful and cruel actions.
They are similar to the cartels who strike fear in the hearts and actions of well meaning individuals. They rob the ordinary people
and live abroad with billions. They are haters.
Let the interested parties and our national elected officials weigh in. Do not bring hatred to Santa Ana
If not you should stop being silent on the rape as a weapon of war being practiced by Hamas. That could be an universal
resolution by the Council.
1
Alcala, Abigail
From:
perazzok <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:04 AM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Kathleen Perazzo
Sent from my V rizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Susan Muzila <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:05 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Pro Palestinian Resolution
I am writing to express my concerns regarding the recent discussions and actions taken by some of our City
Council members concerning matters that extend beyond the purview of local governance - specifically,
engagement in foreign policy issues.
As a resident of this city, I greatly appreciate the dedication and efforts of the Council in addressing local
matters that directly impact our community's well-being. However, recent discussions and resolutions
involving foreign policy matters are clearly diverting attention and resources away from the primary
responsibilities of local governance.
While acknowledging the importance of international affairs, I believe that the City Council's role should
primarily focus on addressing local concerns, such as infrastructure, education, PUBLIC SAFETY, and
community development. Engaging in foreign policy matters do not align with the core responsibilities
entrusted to the Council by the citizens of our city.
A strong stance to a specific "side" of these international issues will only perpetuate a divisive community and
threaten the public safety of those that live within your city limits.
Susan C. Muzila
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:03 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:09 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
City council members,
DX Huitzil <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:12 AM
eComment
City Council Meeting 12/05
I'm writing this message to urge you to vote YES on the resolution in support of the ceasefire. The
tremendous suffering and atrocities that are happening should not be overlooked.
I urge you to put humanity over politics and other interests, and support the resolution.
Respectfully,
Daniel Ximenez
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Maha Shariff <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:14 AM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Please Pass the Ceasefire Now Resolution
Dear Santa Ana City Council;
Millions of us are outraged at the systemic discrimination against groups standing in solidarity with Palestine and
Palestinians everywhere. It's high time for every city, state, leader and institution to say NO to the constant erasure and
silencing of Arab and Palestinian voices. Enough is enough. Drop the baseless and racist charges against Palestinians who
are being slaughtered and remember the protections afforded to us by our US Constitution along with the
responsibilities of it. Every city should follow your lead and be protecting all, not some, of its citizens from racism and
tactics like silencing and doxxing—instead of perpetuating these illegal and unconstitutional tactics which have
culminated into a horrific environment where we are watching a genocide unfold against Palestinians in real time and
our global leaders are too afraid or soldout to call it exactly what it is. This is a Palestinian Holocaust that has gone on for
nearly a century - please pass this symbolic resolution today!
Thank you,
Maha Said-Shariff
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Marcelle Navid <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:14 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
City council members,
Daniela Martinez <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:16 AM
eComment
Dec 5 City Council Meeting
I'm writing this message to urge you to vote YES on the resolution in support of the ceasefire. The
tremendous suffering and atrocities that are happening should not be overlooked.
I urge you to put humanity over politics and other interests, and support the resolution.
Respectfully,
Daniela Martinez
Alcala, Abigail
From: Jessica Leah <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:18 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Request to participate in 12/5 city council meeting
Hello,
I plan to attend tonight's meeting and would like the opportunity to provide comments on the agenda item relating to
the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
Thank you,
Jessica
Alcala, Abigail
From: Siti Fatima Ahmad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:20 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
To Whom it May Concern,
Uyen Hoang <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:26 AM
eComment
Agenda Item #19: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
My name is Uyen Hoang and I am the Executive Director of Viet Rainbow of Orange County (VROC). VROC
was created in 2013 when 5 LGBTQ+ Vietnamese Americans were rejected from participating in
cultural celebrations on the belief that "LGBT is not part of Vietnamese culture." In response, we fought for
inclusion of our humanity as being both Vietnamese and queer. Today, VROC uplifts the different multiple
intersectional identities that queer, trans Vietnamese Americans have, as well as the issues that they may face
because of them.
In our work towards advancing justice here in Orange County, we also must remember that injustice anywhere
is a threat to justice everywhere. The genocide that is happening in Palestine is an issue that affects us all and
has particular resonance with the AAPI community here in the US, especially for our Vietnamese
community.What is happening in Palestine is an all too familiar story for Southeast Asian refugees and
descendants of refugees. We condemn these atrocities and the genocide of Palestinians.
We urge the Santa Ana City Council to pass a resolution in solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire. Thank you.
Warmly,
Uyen Hoang, MA, MPH (she/they)
Executive Director
ROC
Website I Facebook I Instagram I Linktree
Schedule a meeting with me I Hear my name pronunciation
Alcala, Abigail
From: TRACEY STEIN <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:28 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Resolution Addressing War in Gaza
I write to express deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in Gaza,
particularly its one-sided nature and potential consequences. As a resident, I urge you to
consider the broader impact on our community and focus on issues that directly affect Santa
Ana, such as the homeless crisis, affordable housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street
safety.
I fear that a resolution on an international conflict, over which the City Council has no authority,
may divert attention from pressing local matters and invite divisive rhetoric, as witnessed in
other cities. I respectfully request that the City Council prioritize the needs of our constituents
by withdrawing the proposed resolution and redirecting attention to pressing issues within the
jurisdiction of the City.
Tracey Stein
(
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:30 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:11 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Daniel Ximenez
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92701-2621
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
I'm writing this message to urge you to vote YES on the resolution in support of the ceasefire. The tremendous suffering and
atrocities that are happening should not be overlooked.
I urge you to put humanity over politics and support the resolution.
Respectfully,
Daniel Ximenez
1
Alcala, Abigail
From: timrush@bhhscaprops.com
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:33 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Proposed Resolution at tonights City Council meeting regarding the War in Gaza
Dear Honorable Mayor and Council ;
While there is much to say about this terrible situation and its causes ............ none of it involves any level of authority or
purview of the City of Santa Ana. We have no business getting involved in this international crises....... especially when
we are having great difficulty managing the affairs of our own city.
With all due respect to each of your opinions on this conflict it is inappropriate for this body to become embroiled in this
matter and provide yet another reason for people to be divided in our city. Please take no action on this matter this
evening.
Tim Rush
Chief People Connector
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties
The Maple Building, Corporate Offices
16911 South Bellflower Boulevard
Bellflower, CA 90706-5903
(714) 299-4455
17 Branch Sales Offices, Serving 6 Southern California Counties
Cod;fr,lrni.'t pl°aperlies
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:41 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:31 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Joy Bonner
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92604
United States
Map It
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
1
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely,
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sina Niku <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:45 AM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Respectfully,
Sina
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Nour Hamida <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:47 AM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nora H.
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: keren mkmagnets.com <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:49 AM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Keren
Sent from my iPhone
1
Alcala, Abigail
From: Lian Ulan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:52 AM
To: Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by
Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel -
the single deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed
acts of antisemitism directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the
wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their
aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the
Israelis and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have
been internally displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages
on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes
including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated
repeatedly over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their
intentions to continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the
Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only
once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza.
Do not set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this
Ceasefire Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the
expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa
Ana community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Lian
Alcala, Abigail
From: Erika Gutierrez Preciado Taft <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:27 AM
To: eComment
Subject: December meeting, concerned constituent
I find the interpretation this community has of the Jewish people deeply troubling. There is a massive blindspot
for Jews in progressive spaces in particular, as there is a failure to recognize Jews as an ethnic group and only as
a religious one. This oversight further alienates a vulnerable segment of our community, especially in times of
conflict, like now. To have the school district's curriculim exclude Jews as an ethnic group based on the
misguided ideas previously listed is problematic at best. This action would erase the lived experience of
othering, discrimination, and racism that Jews face in this country every day. Antisemitism is racism.
As a Mexican non -Jew in a multifaith marriage, it terrifies me to think about how my children will be affected if
curriculums and other public measures continue to be pushed to outcast and discriminate against Jews. I love
Santa Ana. I love that this city has such a pride in family values and hanging on to our Latino culture, but I
know that if this blatant disregard towards growing antisemitism continues, my children won't get to experience
the Santa Ana I grew up in and love, because they won't be safe here.
I'm well aware of the working draft of the council's statement against Israel in regards to the war with the
terrorist group, Hamas. This council needs to understand that Zionism is integral to the survival of the Jewish
people, since without a nation they would be once again vulnerable to be subjegated to systemic targeting.
Zionist Jews are not their prime minister (which majority of them want him out). Just like Palestinians are not
Hamas. I urge this council to educate itself objectively on terminology I've seen grossly misused and to
advocate for peace instead of more discrimination and alienation.
Lastly, to have any sort of mention of the holocaust in regards to Isreal and palestine is incredibly tone deaf,
insensitive, and cruel. Many of your Jewish constituents have had majority of their families wiped out by Hitler
and his regime via systemic encarceration and mass execution like lambs to the slaughter. To have their elected
officials even hint that because they believe Jews have a right to a Jewish nation, they are doing the same thing
that was done to them is disgusting.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Eric Stein < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:56 AM
To: eComment
Subject: Re: Dec 5 City Council Mtg. — resolution addressing the war in Gaza.
I understand you are considering a resolution addressing the war in Gaza.
I write to express my concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in Gaza --particularly its one-sided nature and
potential consequences. As residents, we urge you to consider the broader impact on our community and focus on issues that directly
affect Santa Ana, such as the homeless crisis, affordable housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street safety.
I fear that a resolution on an international conflict over which the City Council has no authority may divert attention from pressing
local matters and invite divisive rhetoric, as witnessed in other cities. We respectfully request that the City Council prioritize the needs
of our constituents by withdrawing the proposed resolution and redirecting attention to pressing issues within the jurisdiction of the
City.
While it is a very important and significant issue on a global stage, and one with no simple answer, the bottom line, this is not an issue
for city politics.
Sincerely,
Eric Stein
Santa Ana, CA 92706
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:57 AM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 11:56 AM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
gary winkler
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92704
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
As a business owner and property owner in Santa Ana, and as a very significant Taxpayer, I strongly object to this stupid
resolution. Who gives you the moral authority to both pass judgement and make any demands on the Israeli people? Where do
you come off telling Irael what to do? Are missiles flying over Santa Ana every day? Has the population equivalent of 40K
Americans been brutally murdered?
Why don't you worry about your true responsibilities? Homeless, theft and violence in our community. My building was
vandalized a couple months back causing over $50K in damage.
Worry about our community! That was why you were elected!
You haven't a clue of the nuances in the Middle East!
As an example: you called Israel an Apartheid state. You haven't a clue of what you are talking about! How about Arabs and
Muslims in the Knesset? How could that happen if Israel was an Apartheid state?
I strongly object to what you are doing! Do what you were elected to do and do it well! Stay the hell out of international politics!
Gary Winkler
Alcala, Abigail
From: Tatiana Zavala <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 12:04 PM
To: eComment
Subject: City Council 12/5 Topic: Ceasefire Resolution. COUNCILMEMBER-REQUESTED ITEM
TITLE #19: Discuss and Consider Directing the Interim City Manager to Prepare a
Resolution for City Council's Consideration to Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
My name is Tatiana Zavala. I am emailing to urge the city council to support an immediate and permanent
ceasefire in Gaza, and the safe passage of substantial humanitarian aid to the people of Palestine.
Since October 7th, over 13,000 Palestinians have been murdered. Over 5,500 of those murders have been
children. I urge the Santa Ana city council to proclaim their support for Palestine, to denounce the horrific acts
being committed by the state of Israel by opposing all existing and any future military aid to Israel, and to call
in support of a permanent ceasefire in Gaza.
To be clear, it is crucial to distinguish between criticizing the actions/policies of the state of Israel, and
harboring any kind of anti-Semitic sentiment. My disagreement with Israel's specific governmental decisions
should not be misconstrued as an attack on the Jewish people as a whole. I strongly urge the city of Santa Ana
to continue advocating for the dignity and safety of residents in every community, regardless of what crimes its
leadership may commit. Peaceful diplomacy is the only way to achieve this safety and dignity.
As stated in the proposed resolution, "the historical memory of the Holocaust requires us to speak out when we
see atrocities being committed against innocent people, no matter their identity." I urge the council members in
Santa Ana to heed this call.
Thank you for your review and consideration.
Best,
Tatiana Zavala
Alcala, Abigail
From: Saine Carrasco <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 12:05 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Please do not turn a blind eye on this. We are all counting on you.
Sincerely,
Saine Carrasco
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Kenny Howell <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 12:08 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Kenny Howell
Santa Ana, CA 92704
Araiza, Fatima
From: Buharie Faisal <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:12 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:15 PM
To: eComment
Subject: A Call for Peace
Please vote for a ceasefire in Gaza.
Thank You,
Ed Stepanian
Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS
Araiza, Fatima
From: Elizabeth Meza <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:19 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Elizabeth Meza
Santa Ana, CA 92707
Araiza, Fatima
From: Muhammad Shafiq <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:39 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Yvonne Lopez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:42 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Resolution in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Council Members,
Thank you Council Members Benjamin Vazquez and Johnathan Hernandez for bringing this
Ceasefire resolution before Council. I am in full support and implore the Santa Ana City Council to
pass this resolution and be on the right side of history. The world is witnessing a genOcide and we
cannot be complicit. It is not complicated. Supporting a ceasefire does not equal anti-s3metism.
Thank you. I look forward to the Santa Ana City Council passing this humanitarian resolution.
Yvonne Lopez
La Habra, CA
Alcala, Abigail
From: Thouraya Awad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 12:38 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19 - Call in Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I have worked and lived in Orange County for five years. This is my home and as a diverse and compassionate
city, standing in solidarity with Palestinians promotes peace, justice, and human rights. Supporting a cease-fire
now resolution reflects our commitment to a peaceful coexistence, fostering understanding, and advocating for a
just resolution to stop the genocide of innocent civilians. We must act now and I hope my city listens to its
Palestinian community members during this dire time. Thank you.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Justin <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:51 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Omar Habbak <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:52 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Omar Habbak
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Leah Hassouneh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:52 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Ceasefire in Gaza
Dear Members of the Santa Ana City Council,
I am writing to you with a sense of urgency and a deep concern for the escalating conflict in Gaza. It is crucial
for our community, as a symbol of peace and solidarity, to support a ceasefire resolution immediately.
The ongoing violence in Gaza has resulted in devastating loss of life, injury, and destruction, impacting
countless innocent civilians. By advocating for a ceasefire, we can contribute to halting this tragic loss and
suffering. A ceasefire will provide much -needed relief and create a window for humanitarian aid, which is
desperately required in the region.
Furthermore, supporting a ceasefire aligns with our city's values of promoting peace, human rights, and
international cooperation. It is an opportunity for Santa Ana to be a leader in advocating for global peace and
stability.
Time is of the essence. Every moment we delay, more lives are at risk. I urge you to take immediate action and
support a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. Let us stand together for peace and humanity.
Sincerely,
Leah Hassouneh
Orange County Resident
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sunya Vakil <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:52 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Simon Khan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:53 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Simon Khan
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Nimra Siddiqi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:54 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Atif <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:55 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress. This resolution calls for
Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims contribute
immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique. By passing a resolution demanding an immediate
and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a
commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes. Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our
community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate crimes due to the dehumanization
of Palestinians in the media and within our governments. Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against
injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives of all individuals, regardless of their
background or nationality. Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our
community.
We look forward to your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Atif Butt
Araiza, Fatima
From: Omar Ashmawey <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:55 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Omar Ashmawey
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: amber ismail <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:56 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sadia M <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:56 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate
crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sadia Moinuddin MD
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tauqeer Razzaqui <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:56 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Tauqeer Razzaqui
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Adam Overton <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:57 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19: Vote YES in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Dear Santa Ana Mayor and City Councilors,
My name is Adam Overton and I am a member of the Jewish community in Orange County. I urge you to
please vote YES to pass this resolution in support of a ceasefire in Gaza.
The Oct 7th attacks of Hamas on innocent Israeli citizens were an absolute catastrophe, completely intolerable,
and evil. But the Israeli government's military response far exceeded any plausible justification of "self
defense", and has resulted in unbelievable, unprecedented numbers of innocent Palestinians killed, the
magnitude of which the world has never seen.
We have seen from the ceasefire a week ago that diplomacy, negotiations can work and resulted in the release
of dozens of Israeli hostages -- as well as dozens of Palestinian women and children who had been arrested
without charge by Israel police forces. But Israel has decided to halt the ceasefire and as of yesterday has now
resumed by invading Southern Gaza, where the remainder of Palestinians have fled to at the demand of Israeli
Defense Forces.
We are witnessing in realtime a genocide of a people and we must act immediately to convince Israel to cease
fire.
As a Jew is hard to see such inhumanity being done to another people by a nation that claims to represent the
Jewish people. It is scary to see such military behavior delegitimize Israel and the United States in the eyes of
the world. Israel's actions are killing innocent Palestinians, and endangering the lives of all Jews and Americans
around the world, and I believe this overreaction will delay any chance of peace being reached for generations.
What we've all seen over the 75 years of the Israel/Palestine conflict is that no military option there can bring
peace, only diplomacy can. Your leadership is dearly needed in this moment. Please stand for humanity and life
and peace and call for an immediate ceasefire and end to this catastrophe.
Sincerely,
Adam Overton
plusnoneplusggmail.com
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tasneem Bholat <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:57 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:58 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Erum Sethi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Zeenath Masood < on behalf of zeenathm04@gmail.com
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:59 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Zeenath Masood, MD
Araiza, Fatima
From: Aisha Memon <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:59 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Araiza, Fatima
From: Natalie Camarena <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:00 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda item #19 - Call in support of a ceasefire in Gaza
Hi,
My name is Natalie and I am a resident of Santa Ana. I am writing to you to urge you to vote "yes" on the
resolution in support of a ceasefire in Gaza. We are watching a genocide take place and our city needs to call for
a ceasefire.
Thank you,
Natalie Camarena Lopez
Araiza, Fatima
From: hanna hamideh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Yasser Abdel-Aziz <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:01 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I would like to speak at the city council meeting today please.
I support Ceasefire for in Gaza and I oppose sending any tax money to Israel to commit mass Genocides
Yasser Abdel-Aziz
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sadaf Lakhia <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:03 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sadaf
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mustafa Khan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:03 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Mustafa Khan
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Najjia Shahabuddin <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:04 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Najjia S. Ahmed, MD
Alcala, Abigail
From: Tanzeela Mirza <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:04 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
26
Alcala, Abigail
From: Safaa AbdelFatah <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:04 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Safaa Abdelfatah
Sent from my iPhone
25
Alcala, Abigail
From: Syeda Hafsa Sultana <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:08 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
24
Alcala, Abigail
From: Noor Kurdi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:09 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Noor Kurdi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
23
Alcala, Abigail
From: Amani Manasrah <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:10 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Cease fire in Gaza
End the war on children end colonization
Sent from my iPhone
22
Alcala, Abigail
From: Usman Naz <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:10 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Usman Naz
Santa Ana, CA 92705
21
Alcala, Abigail
From: Alaa Milbes <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:10 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
20
Alcala, Abigail
From: Nelly Nino <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:10 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nelly Nino
Santa Ana, CA 92705
19
Alcala, Abigail
From: Sana Kamdar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:11 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sana Kamdar
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
18
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ashraf Habbak <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:13 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Dear Mayor and City Council,
Please support a ceasefire in Gaza to stop the genocide and humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Thank you,
Ashraf Habbak
17
Alcala, Abigail
From: Arif Shaikh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:13 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Arif Shaikh
North Tustin, CA 92705
16
Alcala, Abigail
From: Asim Khan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:15 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Asim Khan
Santa Ana, CA 92705
15
Alcala, Abigail
From: Nawal Atoura <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:17 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my mobile Device.
Please excuse any brevity or errors. (Emails are sometimes dictated and not read)
This is my personal work email address.
13
Nawal Atoura, Esq
14
Alcala, Abigail
From: Nitin K <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:20 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nitin K
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
12
Alcala, Abigail
From: Magdalena Chavez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:21 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Magdalena Chavez
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
11
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ahlia Kattan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:21 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Alia Kattan
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
10
Alcala, Abigail
From: Yahoo <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:26 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a very heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices
to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the atrocities of the maniacal war on Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million
Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on
the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, upholding our American values, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the
backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community to uphold the virtues of
Humanity & our American values. We look forward to your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Harrier Cagatay
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Suhaib <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:27 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:28 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 12:15 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Beverley Lieberman
Email
Address
Irvine, California 92612
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
I write today to share my concerns about the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire to be considered at the December 5, 2023, meeting.
The resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided. It makes a false equivalency between babies taken
by terrorists as hostages to prisoners convicted of violent crimes who are not hostages by any definition. It uses inaccurate terms
like ethnic cleansing, genocide, and apartheid which are all too often used to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people.
Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian
crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas accountable for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in
harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The proposed ceasefire resolution distorts the facts and does not include a forceful condemnation of Hamas or its terrorist attack
on Israel on October 7. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that is insulting to the 6
million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. And most insulting is that the
resolution "vows to combat antisemitism" while it actually promotes and amplifies it.
I urge you to reject the resolution.
Sincerely
Bev Lieberman
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
To the Santa Ana City Council,
Carson Blumen-Green <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:29 PM
eComment
Vote YES for Ceasefire Resolution
Devastating can't even begin to encompass the amount of death and suffering Palestinians are experiencing right
now, thousands of them being children. Israel is continuing their indiscriminate bombing in Gaza, displacing
almost 2 million Palestinians and cutting off their access to medical care, food, electricity, and water. More than
15,000 civilians are dead with numbers increasing. More than 50 Palestinian journalists have been targeted and
killed.
Do not stand by silently as these atrocities continue and VOTE YES for a ceasefire.
Thank you for your time,
Carson B.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Aisha Patel <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:29 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Aisha
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Suhana shereef <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:34 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Suhana Shereef
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Omid Rahmani <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:34 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
O. Rahmani
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ms. Baltazar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:36 PM
To: Bacerra, Phil; Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment; Vazquez, Benjamin;
Phan, Thai; Lopez, Jessie; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate
crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
M6nica Baltazar
Sent from Proton Mail for iOS
Alcala, Abigail
From: Deena Hantuli <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:44 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support a ceasefire
Hello,
I'm reaching out to you to urge you in standing a stand with humanity by demanding a complete ceasefire in Gaza. A
genocide is taking place against innocent Palestinians (it's been ongoing for over 75 years), and it needs to stop. We
need to stand up against the massacre and genocide. We need to stop aiding the genocide. We need our tax dollars to
fund for education, healthcare, housing, and safety of our American people domestically. Our tax dollars shouldn't be
sent to fund for a genocide. I urge you to call for a complete ceasefire.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Noreen Rahman <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:47 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
23
Alcala, Abigail
From: Aisha Hanif <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:48 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Get Outlook for Android
22
Alcala, Abigail
From: Maryam Ashraf <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:50 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. I am a resident of Santa Ana.
It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to the call for justice and
humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
Byy passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate
crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Resident of Santa Ana
Maryam Ashraf
Santa Ana, CA 92705
21
Alcala, Abigail
From: Teodora Cristea <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:53 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Teo Crisp
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
20
Alcala, Abigail
From: Deborah -Debbie Gruner <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:56 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19 for 12/5 Santa Ana City Council Meeting
Council members agenda item 19. for today's meeting is extremely concerning. I am not a resident of California
but I was born there, and am a citizen of the United States of America.
More importantly I respect Geneva convention, and have a problem with rape being used as a weapon of war, as
well as a problem with elderly people and children being taken from homes, as well as a problem with peacefull
civilians being attacked.These are not legally acceptable actions of war, not since 1948, and should never be
supported in a court of law.
Although calling for a ceasefire may seem harmless, well meaning, and good hearted because such calls tend to
air on the side of wanting peace for the world .... in this case, it is a call to uproot the basic values I mentioned
above, that exist in civilized society.It is not good enough to claim ignorance, if you intend to be the lawmakers
of this SOCIETY.
A lawmaker has a responsibility to know the meaning of the word apartheid, and to know the meaning of the
word blockade. Lawmakers have a responsibility to not co-opt such important words and to not misappropriate
them, so that their impact when invoked is not watered down.
Demanding a ceasefire from a defensive state that aims to go in to retrieve its civilians, who are still being held
captive and were brutally kidnapped in the most inhuman ways, is not acceptable. (YOU CAN LITERALLY
WATCH ON YOUR PHONE what happened on October 7th,and YOU ALL ARE RESPONSIBLE to do so if
you plan on having an opinion on the issue)
The reason Egypt, UAE, and Jordan helped with the recovery of some hostages and also are EXTREMELY
resistant to the concept of opening their doors to refugees from Gaza, is because they know who HAMAS is and
even THEIR limits on what is acceptable in war were crossed during the October 7 attack. They agree with
Israel on the core values I initially mentioned.
If opposing foreign countries are capable of uniting in recognizing the importance of the basic values
highlighted by Geneva convention, why can't you? I question what could possibly motivate you council
members to consider such horrendous acts like the ones executed on 10.7 as acceptable.
At least acceptable enough for you to demand that the country in charge of retrieving the civilians, and ensuring
such attacks do not repeat, stop their retrieval and securing of its borders.
Should a formal investigation be made of funding accepted by council members, what would be found?
The blood of the hostages still being held captive, will be on your hands, if you demand that the only force on
Earth willing to go in and save them,be told to stop trying to.
Not to mention the blood shed resulting in the emboldening of terrorist organizations who not only become
supported financially but now morally by people not caring enough to be responsible for their own words or
18
votes
Institutional support for Palestine before Hamas is unseated means institutional support for Hamas.
I REPEAT Institutional support for Palestine before Hamas is unseated means institutional support for Hamas.
Hamas, the terrorist organization, classified by OSCE and the United States as a terrorist organization.
Hamas is still in charge of the Health Ministry of Gaza and the Education Ministry of Gaza. Which is why
Hamas leaders are billionaires, because each time a war happens they receive billions of dollars in aid that goes
to them instead of to the Palestinians. Which is also why Gaza looks like an open air wasteland instead of
something like Singapore and also why you won't necessarily be helping Palestians by supporting Gaza.
Demanding a ceasefire is not only irresponsible towards Israelis who only aim to protect themselves from what
has been recognized by the ICC's prosecutor as gross human rights violations, but is also irresponsible towards
the Palestinians who are living under what can only be described as a terrorist regime if one aims to be accurate
with their language.
Your proposal antisemitically mentions words being used to show a clear intention of ethnic cleansing on behalf
of Israel, and ignores actions, specifically the actions of directly targeting elderly and child civilians in a mass
shooting, raping, beheading and brutalizing attack on October 7th, the actions done by HAMAS as an ACTUAL
attempt at ethnic cleansing.
I know weed is legalized there now but you shouldn't be writing law while under the influence.
Your proposal also claims to combat antisemitism while ignoring the 1.2 million Jewish California
residents.Who by the way are very present in email communications opposing this proposal last I checked 142
residents opposing this proposal, to only 2 in favor, probably associated with the two drug addicts that
suggested the proposal Yes I read all the emails.
Such a text like the one suggested in agenda item 19, as a proposal, has no credibility in the eyes of the truthful.
If you think a simple vote means nothing, I don't know why you would bother being council members. You
have a responsibility to the truth you so openly claim to value on your website. I hope to see you take that
responsibility seriously, because there are lives that can die when you don't.
Do the right thing and stand behind the Geneva Convention or I will question why you don't, with every
resource at my disposal.
19
Alcala, Abigail
From: Daniah Zughbi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:00 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Daniah Zughbi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
17
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ayesha Zia <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:00 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Ayesha azia
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
16
Alcala, Abigail
From: Abdulrahim Milbes <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:06 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
13
Alcala, Abigail
From: Flores, Gaston
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:10 PM
To: eComment
Subject: FW: Contact the City Council Submission
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:09 PM
To: Flores, Gaston <GFlores@santa-ana.org>
Subject: Contact the City Council Submission
Name
Sharon Sobel
Email
Address
Santa Ana, California 92705
United States
Map It
Phone
(
Who is this message for?
• Mayor Valerie Amezcua
• Mayor Pro Tern Jessie Lopez
• Councilmember Thai Viet Phan
• Councilmember David Penaloza
• Councilmember Phil Bacerra
• Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez
• Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez
Comments or questions
December 5, 2023
Dear Santa Ana City Councilmembers,
I write to express my opposition to the Santa Ana Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire
This proposed Resolution includes inflammatory rhetoric that is divisive and one-sided, fails to condemn the Hamas or its
terrorist massacre on October 7, demonstrates bias by blaming only Israel and ascribes no agency or responsibility for any other
groups or parties. It also uses inaccurate terms like "ethnic cleansing," "genocide," and "apartheid," which are all too often used
to justify bigotry towards the Jewish people. It weaponizes the phrase "Never Again" and references the Holocaust in a way that
is insulting to the 6 million Jews and countless others who were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime.
Additionally, the Resolution perpetuates an offensive moral equivalency by calling criminals arrested in Israeli prisons "hostages"
like the babies, children, families, elderly folks who, if not murdered, were kidnapped by Hamas terrorists and held hostage in
Gaza. Ultimately, this Resolution makes a mockery of fighting antisemitism by vowing to "combat antisemitism" while
weaponizing language that too often is used to justify and/or promote antisemitism.
11
To be clear, this is not a war Israel started nor wanted. Two things can be true: Our hearts break at the loss of innocent life in
both Israel and Gaza, and the worsening humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza. At the same time, we can hold Hamas
accountable for their attack targeting men, women, children, and the killing, mutilation and kidnapping of babies, the elderly, the
disabled on October 7, as well as for deliberately putting innocent Palestinians in harm's way in pursuit of their nefarious goals.
The barbaric, antisemitic terrorist organization Hamas committed the most lethal massacre of Jews since the Holocaust, brutally
murdering more than 1,200 civilians, with more than 4,500 including men, women, and children injured. Hamas also kidnapped
more than 200 men, women and children — including babies as young as 9-months-old and elderly Holocaust survivors — who
were kidnapped and taken as hostages into Gaza by Hamas. These are mostly civilians. We mourn the devastation and
tremendous loss of life in Gaza, where thousands of Palestinians, including children, have been displaced, injured, or killed in
the ensuing violence.
This is a time when we should be calling out both antisemitism and anti -Muslim hate in our community, and recognize that many
members of our community are deeply impacted by what is going on in Israel and in Gaza. Santa Ana City Council members
should be seeking to bring us together and ensure that our community is welcoming and inclusive for people from all faiths,
ethnicities, and cultural backgrounds.
A resolution calling for a ceasefire that fails to condemn Hamas as a terrorist organization or fails to call for the safe return of the
hostages, does just the opposite. In fact, this type of
resolution could actually promote hate against the Jewish people and further divide our community.
We have seen time and time again that tensions in the Middle East can lead to an increase in antisemitic incidents, ranging from
harassment to violence, targeting Jewish institutions and Jewish individuals in America.
Jews across the US, and indeed, the world, are experiencing this now, even in our community.
In addition, city councils should not be focusing on international matters. City councils should be focusing on matters that directly
affect our city: safety and security, housing, food and job insecurity, schools, traffic issues.
We urge you to reject this resolution and welcome the opportunity to discuss this issue with you further. Thank you for your
consideration.
Sincerely,
Rabbi Sharon L. Sobel
Senior Rabbi
Temple Beth Sholom of Orange County
12
Alcala, Abigail
From: Syed Iftikhar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:12 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
10
Alcala, Abigail
From: Charlie Tarazi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:16 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Santa Ana City Council Resolution to Call for Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I am writing to encourage that Santa Ana City Council vote "Yes" on the upcoming resolution to call for a
ceasefire and deescalation in Gaza to protect Palestinian lives and make sure Palestinians in Orange County
have a voice.
Thank You,
Charlie Tarazi
Alcala, Abigail
From: Emine Y <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:16 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Emine Yildiz
Alcala, Abigail
From: Cat C <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:18 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Dec. 5: Comment on Agenda item 19
Hello,
My name is Cathy, and I am writing to comment on Agenda Item 19: Discuss and Consider Directing the
Interim City Manager to Prepare a Resolution for City Council's Consideration to Call in Support of a Ceasefire
in Gaza — Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez.
I would like to express my support for this resolution. I am part of a growing international chorus calling for a
permanent ceasefire in Gaza, an end to all of this brutal carnage. UNICEF Executive Director Catherine Russell
has said "Gaza is, again, the most dangerous place to be a child."
I believe that a permanent ceasefire is a vital part of addressing the growing anti-semitism and Islamophobia we
are seeing across the country. Calling for a permanent ceasefire is not anti-semiticit is staying in touch with
that part of our humanity that recognizes the unbearable devastation of wiping entire families off of the civil
registry, of destroying the small bodies of children, of displacing over a million people (some of whom have
already lived through displacement), of the elderly, ill, and disabled trying to make it to a "safe" space, of
healthcare providers, journalists, rescue workers being targeted and killed. The loss is unfathomable.
Generations will live with this trauma —if they even survive.
The pursuit of liberation and justice is not just for certain fronts or reserved for the higher echelons of
government. Speaking up at a local community level matters. It matters to those we call neighbors, our children
(who are watching our actions), and yes, even those on the other side of the world.
I do not wish violence or marginalization of any group. The flourishing of one group should not depend on the
oppression of another. I am pleading for our collective conscience.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Cathy C.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Tanzeem Islam <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:19 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Council members,<BR><BR>I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of
urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity
with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.<BR><BR>We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of
Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking
number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity
and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right side of history.<BR><BR>The destruction of vital
infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in urgent need of
humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.<BR><BR>This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in
human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa
Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana
unique.<BR><BR>By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the
opportunity to demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate
crimes. <BR><BR>Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the
rise of hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.<BR><BR>Let
Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives of
all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.<BR><BR>Thank you for your time, consideration, and the
crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City Council's passing of this humanitarian
resolution.<BR><BR>Sincerely,<BR><BR>Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sincerely,
Tanzeem Islam, MD
5
Alcala, Abigail
From: Orion Meicht <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:19 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Council members
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their
atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivise more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Orion
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Natasha Got <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:24 PM
To:
eComment
Cc:
Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Natasha Gottlieb
3
Alcala, Abigail
From: Nargis Kher <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:24 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item 19 - Demanding Ceasefire
Dear Santa Ana City Council Members,
I wholeheartedly, urge you to please vote yes for immediate and permanent ceasefire in Gaza. We have a
moral responsibility as the most powerful nation in the world to stand up against oppression. Our tax dollars are
being used for weapons. I urge you to vote no for anymore of weapons purchase or any use for Israel of US
dollars.
Santa Ana and orange county have diverse communities and we ask you to represent this voice to the
government.
Thank you!
Alcala, Abigail
From: Asma Mian <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:24 PM
To: eComment
Subject: ceasefire in Gaza
Hi,
I am writing to you to implore your council to core and support a permanent ceasefire in Gaza. We have
witnessed such massive destruction and innumerable loss of life that something has to change and the only way
forward is permanent ceasefire.
Please search your conscience and side with humanity
And the only correct and just stance, which is ceasefire and an end to all hostilities and bombs on Gaza's
civilian population.
Thank you,
Alcala, Abigail
From: fatima salihi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:27 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
24
Alcala, Abigail
From: Rawaa Kassar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:28 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Dear Mayor and City Council,
Please support a resolution for a ceasefire to stop the genocide in Gaza.
Thank you,
Rawaa Kassar
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:31 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support ceasefire
I implore the city council of Santa Ana to support a permanent ceasefire in Gaza and an end to Israeli occupation so that
we can really move towards meaningful peaceful solution
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Alexandra Noyes <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:32 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda #19 Ceasefire - Jew says YES
Hello! I am a Jew who works in Santa Ana and I urge you to adopt the ceasefire resolution.
Israel is in violation of a slew of not only international laws but also Jewish laws.
Support of Palestinians oppressed and attacked by Israel is not antisemitism.
Alexandra Noyes
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Cathy H <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:34 PM
eComment
Penaloza, David
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Alcala, Abigail
From: RKF <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:36 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Rowan Fakhro
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
Sierra Badua <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:38 PM
eComment
VOTE YES ON THE RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF CEASEFIRE
I'm writing to you as a resident of Orange County to strongly urge you to show solidarity with Palestinians who
are being ethnically cleansed and forced from their homelands.
Santa Ana is a beautiful city that prides itself on its diversity and progressive ideas. Please be a leader in Orange
County and stand proudly with Palestine against the horrific genocide they are facing.
Thank you for taking the time to read this.
Sincerely,
Sierra Badua
Sierra Badua
she/her/hers
Alcala, Abigail
From: leandra salama <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 1:25 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19 - Call in Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I have worked and lived in Orange County for five years. This is my home and as a diverse and compassionate city, standing in
solidarity with Palestinians promotes peace, justice, and human rights. Supporting a cease-fire now resolution reflects our commitment
to a peaceful coexistence, fostering understanding, and advocating for a just resolution to stop the genocide of innocent civilians. We
must act now and I hope my city listens to its Palestinian community members during this dire time.
Thankyou
Alcala, Abigail
From: reggie peralta <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:40 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire
Hi,
I would like to urge all members of the City Countil to vote for the
Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People in Support of a
Ceasefire. It is unconscionable that our government is sending weapons and
money to Israel as it invades and openly threatens genocide against the
people of Gaza, so the absolute least our city can do is speak out against
the bloodshed and demand an immediate ceasefire to stop the killing.
- Reggie Peralta
1
Alcala, Abigail
From: Laila Umar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:44 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Laila Umar
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Wafa Bennis Bennani <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:45 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: AOL <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:46 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Asmaa Ahmed
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Nathalie Alvarez <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:49 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Call for Immediate Ceasefire in Gaza
Members of the Santa Ana City Council,
Please stand in solidarity with the Palestinian people and call for a ceasefire in Gaza immediately. As
representatives of this community, I urge you to make your stance clear for our state representatives to hear. It
is time for California's representatives to understand that we, the constituents, have no desire or intention in
supporting this genocide. Your call for a ceasefire is crucial in letting our senators and representatives be aware
of their constituents' needs. This community will remember your actions today and will consider them in the
next election. Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Nathalie A.
Alcala, Abigail
From: Taliha Yasin <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:51 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Good afternoon,
For the past 2 months now, there has been an ongoing genocide occurring in Gaza with the murder of innocent women
men and children amounting to over 12,000 killed and over 2 million made homeless and displaced. We are asking you
from the bottom of my heart to gather the strength to ask for a ceasefire now! It's been 60 days of daily bombardment
in the most recent offensive against Gaza and you will be complicit in this genocide If you at the very least don't ask for a
ceasefire today.
Regards,
Taliha
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Sana Ahmed <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:55 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Sana S. Ahmed
Santa Ana, CA 92707
Alcala, Abigail
From: Emel M <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:57 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Emel
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Azawi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:57 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Dr. Samar Azawi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: iman salem <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:57 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Iman Salem
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Alcala, Abigail
From: Lillian Bitar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:57 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a ceasefire in Gaza
Enough blood!!!! Ceasefire now!!!
Alcala, Abigail
From: Rehana Mowjood <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:58 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Tehana
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Alcala, Abigail
From: Ayesha Hussain <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:58 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Ayesha Hussain
Alcala, Abigail
From: Bill Bitar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:59 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support of a ceasefire in Gaza
CEASEFIRE NOW!!!
Alcala, Abigail
From: Fatima Abdelhafeez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 3:00 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Fatima Abdelhafeez
Alcala, Abigail
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Steven Dov Lando <
Tuesday, December 5, 2023 2:57 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Steven Lando
Araiza, Fatima
From: Saagar Shaikh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:00 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Laila El Hasan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:08 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Regarding Gaza
Dear Councilmembers,
I write regarding the ongoing bombardment campaign in Gaza by Israel. In 1948, Zionists ethnically cleansed
over 750,000 Palestinians in the Nakba, and it has displaced many more in the past 75 years. As a consequence,
there are over 150,000 Palestinians in the United States, many of them being Orange County residents.
The majority of our elected officials are not representing the Palestinian American community. They are also
not representing Arab Americans and American Muslims, or their safety interests, as hate crimes against
Palestinians, other Arabs, and Muslims rapidly increase, including, but not limited to, the brutal stabbing to
death of Palestinian American six -year -old Wadea Al-Fayoume by his landlord in Illinois, the stabbing of his
mother, the murder of a Muslim woman, Dr. Talat Jehan Khan, in Texas, and the shooting of three Palestinian
college students in Vermont, Hisham Awartani, Tahseen Ahmed, and Kinnan Abdalhamid. As a result of the
shooting, Hisham Awartani is reportedly paralyzed from the chest down.
Aside from the violent hate crimes, members of these communities have experienced regular harassment and
threats in racist incidents in their daily lives. Palestinian Americans, as well as other Arab Americans, American
Muslims, and allies of Palestinians, have been harassed and threatened at universities, and lost their jobs for
advocating for the recognition of human rights for Palestinians, and speaking up against Zionism, a supremacist,
settler colonial project that was realized through the killing of over 15,000 Palestinians in over 70 massacres,
and the destruction of 531 Palestinian villages by Zionist settlers.
Many Nakba survivors are still alive, some of them living in Gaza. Gaza's population is one largely comprised
of refugees, with roughly three-quarters of Gazans being indigenous to other Palestinian villages that were
ethnically cleansed. These refugees were ghettoized into what is now known as the Gaza strip, with the
remaining Gaza population comprised of Palestinians indigenous to Gaza.
The Zionist settler colonial project is ongoing, with Palestinian communities in the West Bank and East
Jerusalem facing frequent attacks from Zionist settlers who terrorize, assault, and often kill Palestinians to either
steal Palestinians' homes or destroy them to build over them. The Israeli government not only enables, but
supports these actions by settlers, with the Israeli army supplying bulldozers to facilitate this ethnic cleansing.
Since October 7, there has been a spike in the frequency and severity of settler terrorism against Palestinian
villages. Palestinians are unable to defend themselves against Israeli violence because the West Bank is under
military occupation by Israel, which forbids Palestinians from owning weapons.
This has all been happening while in Gaza, according to Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, Israel has killed at
least 21,022 Palestinians, 19,660 being civilians, 8,312 children, 4,270 women, 212 healthcare workers, and 76
journalists as of today. Over 37,000 Palestinians have been confirmed to be injured. However, Palestinians are
unable to account for a complete death toll, with telecommunications destroyed by Israeli airstrikes, electricity
cut off by the Israeli government, and 126 health facilities destroyed in the shellings. Thousands more have
likely been killed, many being trapped under the rubble.
In addition, 1,780,000 of the 2.2 million Palestinians in Gaza have been displaced from their homes, with
60,000 units destroyed. 262 schools, 95 mosques, and 3 churches have been damaged. These numbers don't
even touch on the environmental contamination from thousands of bombs and use of illegal white phosphorus,
and devastation of wildlife.
It is foolish to argue that this targeting of civilians of all ages and destruction of health systems and
infrastructure are not deliberate. This is a genocide. Some argue against this case because not all Gazans have
been killed yet, and because of the claim that Israel could easily kill all Gazans if its leaders wished. However,
the system of determining whether a series of massacres constitutes a genocide is based on international law
rather than individual opinions.
Raz Segal, the program director of genocide studies at Stockton University, described Israel's current campaign
as "a textbook case of genocide". Craig Mokhiber, who resigned from his director position at the United
Nations, used the same language. The UN Convention on Genocide requires that an event meet at least one of
five conditions, combined with proven genocidal intent, to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, racial, ethnic,
or religious group. The current bombing campaign in Gaza meets the conditions of killing members of a group,
causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group, and deliberately inflicting on the group
conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part, according to attorney
Lara Elborno. Elborno says that Israel's actions meet the legal definition of genocide under the Rome Statute as
well as the Genocide Convention.
According to Elborno, meeting the conditions of genocide require intent and action, and Israel has fulfilled
both, with over 100 statements of genocidal intent expressed at the highest levels of Israeli military and
government in the past two months.
Today, the House of Representatives passed a resolution that declares anti -Zionism as a form of antisemitism.
This bill is a threat to freedom of speech and smears the thousands of Palestinian Americans who advocate to
end the slaughter of their families and condemn the ethnic cleansing of their families by a supremacist settler
colonial project. The idea that criticizing an ethnonationalist, settler colonial movement or a foreign government
will be framed as a form of bigotry sets a dangerous precedent and has no place in a democracy.
Moreover, our government's support for this genocide has no place in a country that champions itself as a
beacon of human rights and democracy. Israel's actions are only possible through American support. For this
reason, it is my responsibility to advocate for a ceasefire in Gaza, as well as an end to all U.S. aid to Israel. I am
familiar with Santa Ana's legacy of advocacy and justice, and I have faith that many others would be proud to
share this sentiment.
Thank you for your time.
Best regards,
Laila El Hasan
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Natalie Goldfinger <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thankyou
Araiza, Fatima
From: saagar shaikh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: BollywoodBoys Podcast < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Adeel Syed <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Ennis Machta <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Ennis Machta
Araiza, Fatima
From: Bakr Teebi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Bakr
Araiza, Fatima
From: Muddassir Mayet <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:01 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Mudassir Mayet
Araiza, Fatima
From: Fatima Wahab <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:02 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Fatima Wahab
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Suzan Kesbeh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:04 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19 - Call in Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I have lived in Orange County for twenty years now. This is my home and as a diverse and compassionate city,
standing in solidarity with Palestinians promotes peace, justice, and human rights. Supporting a ceasefire now
resolution reflects our commitment to peaceful coexistence, fostering understanding, and advocating for a just
resolution to stop the genocide of innocent civilians. We must act now and I hope my city listens to its
Palestinian community members during this dire time. Thank you.
Best regards,
Suzan K
Araiza, Fatima
From: M. Kh. <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:07 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: sheeshkababwins <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:09 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote for permanent ceasefire in Gaza
Dear Santa Ana City Council,
As a concerned citizen I am writing to ask you to vote in favor of a permanent ceasefire in Gaza. There is ample
evidence from multiple international human rights organizations that prove Israel's attack on Gaza is a war
crime and genocide. This mass murder of civilians is being funded by our taxpayer dollars. It is unacceptable.
Sincerely,
Hoveda Mufti
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G iAT Device
Araiza, Fatima
From: Maliha Ahmed <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:09 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Maliha Hussain
Araiza, Fatima
From: rhea mathew <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:09 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers, I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of
urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in
Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire. We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation
of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a
heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa
Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right side of history. The
destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and
is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress. This resolution calls for Santa
Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims contribute immensely
to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are integral parts of
the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique. By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent
ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to
protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes. Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a
source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in
the media and within our governments. Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry
and sends a clear message that we value the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or
nationality. Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look
forward to your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution. Sincerely, Rhea Mathew Santa Ana, CA
92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Deena Hantuli <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:15 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support a ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I'm reaching out to you to urge you in standing a stand with humanity by demanding a complete ceasefire in Gaza. A
genocide is taking place against innocent Palestinians (it's been ongoing for over 75 years), and it needs to stop. We
need to stand up against the massacre and genocide. We need to stop aiding the genocide. We need our tax dollars to
fund for education, healthcare, housing, and safety of our American people domestically. Our tax dollars shouldn't be
sent to fund for a genocide. I urge you to call for a complete ceasefire.
-Deena
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tamana Haris <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:16 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Respected City Council:
Fand Jamil <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:17 PM
eComment
Agenda Item #19" Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
I am writing to express my deep concern and urgency regarding the ongoing conflict in Gaza. The
humanitarian crisis unfolding demands our immediate attention and action.
As a resident and concerned citizen of Brea, Orange County, I urge the City Council to consider and pass a
resolution calling for an immediate and complete ceasefire in Gaza. The escalating violence has resulted in
immeasurable suffering, loss of life, and widespread displacement. It is crucial that our local government takes
a stand for peace and advocates for an end to the hostilities.
The impact of the conflict in Gaza goes beyond borders, affecting not only the lives of those directly involved
but also resonating with our shared sense of humanity. By passing a resolution in support of an immediate
ceasefire, this City Council can contribute to the global call for peace and play a role in fostering dialogue and
understanding.
I believe that as representatives of our community, you have the power to influence positive change and send
a strong message that our city stands for peace, compassion, and justice. By taking this step, we can
encourage other municipalities to join in the effort to address the humanitarian crisis and promote diplomatic
solutions to conflicts around the world.
I kindly request that you advocate for the passing of a resolution in support of an immediate and complete
ceasefire in Gaza. Your leadership on this issue would be greatly appreciated by the residents of our city who
are deeply concerned about the impact of the conflict on innocent civilians.
Thank you for your attention to this matter, and I look forward to hearing about positive developments in our
city's stance on promoting peace and humanitarian values.
Sincerely,
Fand Jamil
Brea, CA 92821
Araiza, Fatima
From: tali rosenberg <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:18 PM
To: eComment
Cc: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza, David
Subject: Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Council Members
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Tali Rosenberg
1
Araiza, Fatima
From: Zahir Surmawala <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:22 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Zahir Surmawala
92705
Sent from my mobile device
Araiza, Fatima
From: Walter Muneton <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:23 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
President of GGUSD
Board of Education
Walter Muneton, LCSW, PPSC
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Sam Moss <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:23 PM
eComment
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers
Vazquez and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism
directly. Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that
followed their atrocities is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis
and the Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally
displaced due to the actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This
resolution calls Israel's prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing
populated civilian locations, hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly
over time, will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to
continue in their goal to eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli
casualties. The people of Gaza deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not
set a precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire
Resolution. The City of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of
innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana
community and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you
Araiza, Fatima
From: Noor <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:03 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Noor teebi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my Android
Araiza, Fatima
From:
elana rams <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:25 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Vote NO on the Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Thank you,
Elana BLUMENTHAL
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Hadeer S <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:32 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to
lend your voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with
Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have
massacred 20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children
and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and
inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a
graveyard and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community,
Arabs and Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their
voices, experiences, and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the
opportunity to demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the
backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the
rise of hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that
we value the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look
forward to your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Hadeer Soliman
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tamara M <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:33 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Tamara M
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Kenia Rios <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:38 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Faryal Arif <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:43 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Faryal Arif
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Heather Kobbe < >
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 12:49 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Abdul Yousef <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:45 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Abdorruhman Yousef
Santa Ana, CA 92704
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Yaser Yousef <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:47 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mansour <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:48 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Mansour
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Carolina Vilchis <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:56 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Re: Solidarity with Palestine
To the Santa Ana City Council,
I am writing this letter in support of the resolution you will be voting on today in Solidarity with the Palestinian
People for a Ceasefire.
I was born and raised in Santa Ana and graduated from Saddleback HS. I then graduated from Stanford
University and majored in Xicana Studies. I also have a Masters in Public Health from UCL As a professional
who lives and works in the community I am urging the Santa Ana city council to vote for the resolution that
shows Solidarity with the people of Palestine and demands an end to genocide and apartheid.
Having majored in Xicana Studies at Stanford University helped me become more aware (although I was
already aware due to how my parents raised me) of the importance of showing solidarity as Xicanas and people
of color with the Palestinian people, especially because the U.S. is complicit due to its support of Israel,
including financial support and supplying them with weapons of mass destruction. At Stanford I was involved
in MEChA's leadership and since I was a representative for the Students of Color Coalition, I remember when
my friend Omar Shakir who now works for Human Rights Watch, approached me to see if MEChA would co
host an event with Students for Justice in Palestine to bring awareness to Palestine and how our struggles are
interconnected since we too are dealing with a physical wall the represents US imperialism, and the real and
violent effects that these physical walls have on our people. This was around 2007, but sadly violence continues
to escalate and U.S. involvement persists.
Human rights continue to be abused in Palestine and as privileged people living in the First World, we have the
obligation to speak out and vote for leadership at the local, state and federal level who are against genocide and
aparteid. I really hope that the city council can be on the right side of hxstory when you all have the power to
speak out against injustice and vote in support of the Resolution in Solidarity with the Palestinian People for a
Ceasefire.
Best,
Carolina Vilchis
Araiza, Fatima
From: Y.H. Salem MD <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:56 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Nazik Aytjanova <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:57 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Nazik Aytjanova
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Teri Saydak <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 3:58 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Teri Saydak
Ward 6
Santa Ana, CA 92707
Araiza, Fatima
From: Leena Badawiya <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:03 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19 Call for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
We must stand in solidarity with Palestinians and call for a ceasefire immediately. Over 20,000 Palestinians have been
killed in the last 2 months, and our tax dollars are funding this. Ceasefire now and we must end this brutal occupation.
Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Fatima Wahab <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:04 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Fatima Wahab
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:04 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Rania Siddiq
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Esmy Ruiz <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:09 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19 - Call in Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Hello,
I have worked and lived in Orange County for five years. This is my home and as a diverse and compassionate city, standing in
solidarity with Palestinians promotes peace, justice, and human rights. Supporting a cease-fire now resolution reflects our commitment
to a peaceful coexistence, fostering understanding, and advocating for a just resolution to stop the genocide of innocent civilians. We
must act now and I hope my city listens to its Palestinian community members during this dire time.
Thank you.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Mudassir <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:14 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Syed Ahmed
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Santa Ana Council Members,
Deena Badawiya <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:19 PM
eComment
Agenda Item #19-Call in Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
I am reaching out today as a United States citizen that is appalled and disheartened at the lack of humanity our
government has shown during this time. However, I am not naive to think that the US government represents its
people to the best of its abilities. That is why I understand that our cities are better to voice the needs of the
people better than our federal government.
I ask that you take action to support a ceasefire in Gaza. These are innocent civilians: they are you, they are me,
they are our brothers, sisters, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews --they are people just like us. We must see ourselves
in them. If we were in their position, we would want ordinary people like ourselves to come out in support of
our salvation. I urge you to see your connection to these people and support them by supporting a ceasefire.
Please do not let the wonderful city of Santa Ana, with its rich representation of various people of color, to be
on the wrong side of history.
Best,
Deena Badawiya
Araiza, Fatima
From: Angie Ellaboudy <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:21 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone. Please excuse brevity, spelling, and grammar errors.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:21 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Saleem Gibani
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sondos Kholaki <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:24 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
-Sondos
Sent from my mobile device
Araiza, Fatima
From: notify@proudcity.com on behalf of Michael Wauschek <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:30 PM
To: !City Clerk
Subject: New submission from Contact the Clerk of the Council's Office
Name
Michael Wauschek
Email
Message
Hello my name is Michael Wauschek I am a concern citizen
thanks for your support a ceasefire it's the only the stop the genocide of their own its no war its a slaughter of Palestines. Iseral
even publicly admitted that they are animals but the one that accused of others are themselves or it gotten them in their minds
of it. As well just a ceasefire to flow in aid to them. Then take away our $ for their military complex. Once we cut them. I wouldn't
alote of things will change very quickly.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Hall, Jennifer
Sent:
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:33 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
FW: New submission from Contact the Clerk of the Council's Office
From: notify@proudcity.com <notify@proudcity.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 5, 2023 4:30 PM
To: !City Clerk <CityClerk@santa-ana.org>
Subject: New submission from Contact the Clerk of the Council's Office
Name
Michael Wauschek
Email
Message
Hello my name is Michael Wauschek I am a concern citizen
thanks for your support a ceasefire it's the only the stop the genocide of their own its no war its a slaughter of Palestines. Iseral
even publicly admitted that they are animals but the one that accused of others are themselves or it gotten them in their minds of
it. As well just a ceasefire to flow in aid to them. Then take away our $ for their military complex. Once we cut them. I wouldn't
alote of things will change very quickly.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Shadia Shalabi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:33 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Shadia Shalabi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: brandi glenn <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 2:56 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Brandi
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Ehaab Zubi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:38 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Ehaab Zubi
Araiza, Fatima
From: Iman & Ehaab Zubirafi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:39 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Iman Seirafi
Araiza, Fatima
From: Yvette Perez <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:41 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Madiha Khurshid <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:45 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Madiha Khurshid, D. O.
Emergency medicine physician
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Bridget Kominek <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:45 PM
To: eComment
Subject: 12/5/23 City Council Meeting Agenda Item 19
Good afternoon. I am a resident of the city of Santa Ana, and I am writing to express my support of the creation
of a resolution to call in for a ceasefire in Gaza (item 19 on today's meeting agenda). I am proud to live in a city
that is a leader both locally and statewide advocating for human rights, justice, and peace. Thank you for your
consideration of this proposal.
Sincerely,
Bridget Kominek
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Kayla Asato <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:48 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Environmental Justice Letter of Support for a Ceasefire (agenda item 19)
Hello city council,
This is a letter by OCEJ and environmental Justice orgs in support of Agenda Item 19 for a ceasefire
https:Hdocs.google.com/document/d/1WyJhbN9A7eDSR4DjCubRItL3ogwb3 ueTItgzBaI4lE/edit
Sincerely,
Kayla Asato
Political Director at OCEJ
December 4, 2023
Stanton City Council members
Stanton City Hall
20 Civic Center Plaza
Santa Ana, CA 92701
Dear Councilmembers Phan, Vazquez, Lopez, Bacerra, Hernandez, Penaloza, and Mayor
Amezcua,
We write to you to express our solidarity with Palestinian, Jewish, and Arab -American
activists pushing for this ceasefire resolution. Orange County Environmental Justice, along
with the undersigned, condemns the recent murder of civilians, including those by Hamas in
Israel, those by the State of Israel in Gaza and the West Bank, and those by Israeli armed
settlers in the West Bank. The atrocities committed thus far have resulted in over 23,000
Palestinian deaths, including over 9,000 children, and the displacement of 1.8 million civilians in
Gaza, which surpasses the total casualties of the Nakba of 1948, when half of the entire
Palestinian population was forced out of their ancestral villages and into the open-air prison
known as Gaza in order to create the state of Israel. In addition to mass murder and
displacement, the Israeli government continues to deny food, water, electricity, fuel, and
medicine to Gaza as a weapon of war, resulting in the United Nations declaring this collective
punishment to be a war crime.
As an environmental justice organization, we cannot ignore the impact of military
polluters and their role in poisoning our communities in Stanton and bombing
Palestinian Gaza and the West Bank. Companies like Raytheon supply military equipment to
the Israeli government AND contribute to the high levels of pollution across Stanton. Companies
like Boeing have helped to accelerate the delivery of bombs to Israel to aid in the suppression
and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians AND contribute to huge swaths of pollution across the city
of Huntington Beach and the neighboring cities of West Orange County.
In addition, according to the UN environment program, "destruction of environment during
conflicts not only affect public health directly in the immediate aftermath - through air and water
pollution - but also affects long term recovery due to the destruction of livelihood depending on
environmental resources," according to Muralee Thummarukudy, Director of the G20 Global
Land Initiative. In addition, explosive weapons with wide area effects can have a devastating
impact on civilians and civilian objects in populated areas. Blast and fragmentation effects cause
immediate deaths and injuries. Beyond these direct effects, civilian populations can also be
exposed to severe and long-lasting indirect effects - also referred to as reverberating effects'.
When critical civilian infrastructure is damaged or destroyed, such as energy networks, water
and sanitation systems, the provision of essential services such as healthcare is disrupted.
These services are often interconnected and, as a result, damage to one can negatively affect
services elsewhere, causing harm to civilians that can extend far beyond the weapon's impact
area.
December 4, 2023
As an environmental justice organization, we also must acknowledge the impacts of
settler colonialism and its role in destroying the land and removing Indigenous peoples
across OC and Palestine. In Orange County and Long Beach, we work with the Acjachemen
and Tongva Nations to protect their sacred sites and restore the health of their ancestral lands
and waters, often against the military polluters and industries that continue to poison their home.
The Acjachemen and Tongva peoples, like the Palestinian peoples, have cared for their
homelands for thousands upon thousands of years —since time immemorial —and their livelihoods
and wellbeing are tied to the wellbeing of the lands and waters they call home. Similarly, the
Acjachemen and Tongva peoples and the Palestinian people have been repeatedly forced off
their land and subjected to genocidal violence by settler governments. Native activists here and
around the country call on us to recognize the similarities between these struggles just as
Native peoples here were forced into smaller and smaller reservations and concentration camps
until their lands were completely taken, Palestinian peoples are being pushed off their lands into
smaller and smaller camps that continue to be bombarded, with the Israeli government openly
calling for their extermination and the appropriation of their lands. We must learn the lessons of
U.S. history and prevent the same atrocities from befalling the Palestinian people.
It should be clear that the call for a ceasefire and an end to the genocide against
Palestinian people does not equate to anti -semitism—Palestine is a place held sacred for
Jewish, Muslim, and Christian peoples, and prior to the establishment of Israel in 1948, people
of all religions were safe and welcome there. Palestinians are not all one religion, and when the
state of Israel commits war crimes such as collective punishment, murdering civilians,
assassinating journalists, murdering UN health officials, bombing schools and hospitals, and
forcibly removing Palestinians from their homes, they are committing these atrocities against
Palestinian Jews, Palestinian Christians, and Palestinian Muslims. Furthermore, the Israeli
government continues to discriminate against its own Arab -Jewish citizens, while mass
sterilizing Ethiopian Jewish immigrants to the country. The call for a ceasefire and an end to the
genocide is not a call for violence against Jewish people, but a call to protect civilians and to
value the lives of all people, regardless of their religion.
It is for reasons such as these, that we cannot sit by and watch what is happening in Palestine.
We urge the city of Stanton to join the California cities of Richmond, Cuadahy, and Oakland to
call for a ceasefire and adopt the resolution presented before you tonight. As one of the leaders
of social justice in OC, we urge the city of Stanton to become the first city in Orange County to
adopt a ceasefire resolution.
Sincerely,
Orange County
Environmental Justice
Asian Pacific Environmental Network Santa Ana Active Streets
SI PACIFIC
1 1 1 rl 1 r
1
i 1
NETWORK
rr� r
,r
r
0
tr
Ill,
rillll>l � uu
nai/d
SANTA ANA ACTIVE STREETS
December 4, 2023
The Santanero Project
Crece Urban Farms
Araiza, Fatima
From: Milbes Mustafa <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:53 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Nahid Salim <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:55 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Hello Santa Ana City Council,
Marilynn M <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 4:56 PM
eComment
Support Palestine Resolution
My name is Marilynn and I am a Santa Ana Resident. I am asking for the current city council of Santa
Ana to be on the right side of history and demand for them to vote YES on the resolution in support of
a ceasefire to be in solidarity with the Palestinian People. It is important that our city officially takes a
stand against an ongoing genocide.
-Marilynn Montano
Araiza, Fatima
From:
shades em <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:02 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
SUPPORT PALESTINE RESOLUTION
i am writing as a orange county high school of the arts alumni (ocsa) and resident of santa ana asking my city
council to please support the palestine resolution.
enough innocent palestinian lives have been lost. i am not okay with my tax dollars, energy, and time going
towards a genocide.
please support this resolution to stop the genocide in gaza against the palestinian people.
shayda milani
Araiza, Fatima
From: Syed Ibrahim <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:04 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: A-Hamid Sukar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:07 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Abdulhamid sukar
Garden grove CA 92844
Araiza, Fatima
From: Rewa Ousman <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:10 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Rewa Ousman
Brea, CA 92821
Best Regards,
Rewa Ousman, Esq.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Haneen Jarrar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:14 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Haneen Jarrar
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Leslie Tucker <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:16 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Please stop Antisemitism at your meeting tonight
I am very dismayed that two of the City of Santa Ana Councilmen feel the need to get involved in
international affairs as I see this is on your agenda:
Discuss and Consider Directing the Interim City Manager to Prepare a Resolution for City Council's
Consideration to Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza — Councilmembers Vazquez and Hernandez
The job of the council people "is the governing body of the City, except as otherwise provided in the
Charter, and enacts ordinances subject to the approval or veto of the Mayor. It orders elections,
levies taxes, authorizes public improvements, approves contracts, and adopts traffic regulations."
How on earth does Gaza play into your agenda, unless you are hoping to continue the antisemitic
and anti -Israel propaganda?
Unfortunately, most people are uneducated on the Middle East and forming opinions without the
education is just showing your ignorance.
The charter of Hamas, the "government' of Palestine, is to annihilate Israel and the Jewish people.
When Hamas first took over the Palestinians in the 80's they started with suicide bombers until Israel
put up a fence/border around the area. They then took up rocket launching and thankfully, Israel is a
very tech savvy country so they were able to build an Iron Dome to stop the rockets from killing
innocent Israelis.
The Palestinians used all their international funding from the U.S. that was to build schools and
educate their people, and instead, built over 300 miles of tunnels to hide out their terror organization
and infiltrate Israel.
Here is Hamas' charter https:Havalon.law.vale.edu/20th century/hamas.asp
called their Covenant that states in Article 7 "The Day of Judgement will not come about until
Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The
stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Article
Eight: "Allah is its target, the Prophet is its model, the Koran its constitution: Jihad is its path and
death for the sake of Allah is the loftiest of its wishes.".
Israel walked away from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and had every Israeli leave the area. Did the
Palestinians do anything positive with those Israeli homes, businesses, greenhouses? NO. So, why
are they still attacking Israelis when there are zero Israelis in the Gaza Strip??? Because in their
charter that is listed above, they want Israeli wiped off the planet.
Aren't you curious why Arabs are chanting, "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free". Because
they want the land between the river to the sea, which is Israel, to be gone. They have freedom from
Israel as Israelis no longer live there; they don't have freedom from their own terror government
Hamas.
The idea that Israel is in the midst of genocide is ridiculous as on Oct. 7th, it was Hamas who
attacked, raped, burned people alive, shot people (over 1500) and took over 240 hostages,
many of which are still stuck as hostages in the tunnels mentioned. The Palestinians asked for
this war on Oct. 7th as who wouldn't defend their people? In fact, they still have 135+ hostages. Do
you want a ceasefire and let these hostages rot?? Also, since Hamas is in the tunnels, Israel has to
bomb to find the tunnels as they've already found some that are in hospitals and schools!!!
There is no genocide as Israel gave a few weeks warning to the Palestinians before they counter
attacked. They dropped flyers from the sky telling them to leave. They sent text messages telling
them to leave. They worked with the U.N. for relocation of people. The Israelis are not bombing for
the sake of bombing and trying to kill Palestinians. Hamas needs to come out of their 300 terror miles
and give up the hostages and Israel would stop. Israel has every right to defend itself (as the U.S. did
on 9/11 when a different terrorist organization attacked us). Hamas is using their people as their
shields to continue the propaganda that Israel is "bad", when in fact, Hamas started this, raped
women, cut off their breasts, burned families alive and tells their own people to stay and get killed.
I'm curious, did you vote on condemning Russian when they invaded Ukraine? Will you be voting
about the conflict of Armenia?
For some reason, your antisemitism has passed the litmus test because you are not doing your jobs
and focusing on the city.
Here are some resources to learn about the Middle East as clearly, you don't understand what is
happening, nor the history of the area.
Here is a book you can read about the Israel by Noa Tishby https://www.amazon.com/Israel-Simple-
Guide-Misunderstood-Country/dp/1982144947/ref=asc df 1982144947/?tag=hyprod-
20&linkCode=dfO&hvadid=532676525181 &hvpos=&hvnetw=q&hvrand=13587290908296043925&hv
pone=&hvptwo=&hvg mt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmd l=&hvloci nt=&hvlocphv=9031549&hvtargid=pla-
1391883379911 &psc=1 &mcid=33c6a16f4d3d368283dd6639e4c6c36e&qclid=CiOKCQiAsburBhCIAR
IsAExmsu5T9FOOgTiNOWT7wOiWYhmT7po6zSXMTyAv5Ci5hnbllT4ocByW000aArFkEALw wcB
These are short videos to start learning:
https://www.prageru.com/video/a-palestinian-explains-hamas
https://www.pragerLi.com/video/does-israel-occupy-the-west-bank
Does Israel Occupy the West Bank?
PragerU
I.....lo inany flir es Ir have you IhFawd that Isim6F "o°::°::upiesl'
hFatIheii that's tiiLie C. i even what it imeans? If:.UgFaine.-
1,/ / I.I)I t,C,"1,,'1"0111
A Palestinian Explains Hamas I PragerU
i to do we mak'.e Iliife Ibettei� hmr those who IIive in Gaza?
Accmding to 1=4Iestilnian poktica�i w4yst [3)asseim F:.id, we
shaft Iby recognizing who is reaHy—
www� I") tj E" I'], 'L 1" 0 111
https://www.facebook.com/watch/?extid=CL-UNK-UNK-UNK-IOS GKOT-
GK1C&mibextid=v7YzmG&v=1028228768381369
Brigitte Gabriel translates and exposes written
Muslim Brotherhood plan to destroy the United
States I The Muslim Brotherhood has been
working to destroy the United States from within
for DECADES, this is their secret written plan
exposed. I By Brigitte Ga
11he IMusIliim [:1)mtheiJiood lass Ibeei�)woik,,.iir)gtodestiroytI�ieU..Jir)ited
States fmim within fm D[::.CA1D[:.:.S, this is thek seciret wHtten IpIIan
exposed,
VVVVVV. r�
This is a 30 minute video:
https://www.pragerLi.com/video/ep-310-israel-is-at-war
Please do the right thing,
Leslie
Ep. 310 — Israel Is at War I PragerU
Ovei� the weekend, i laimas aunched the 1most biajta�i
attadk. on 1s1m611 in the nation's Ihistc. y, i lundi�eds of
smeks weie Ib1raitaHy toftuired, kidinapped, and—
www. I") Itj E" PAL 1" 0 111
3
Araiza, Fatima
From: amira shalabi <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:16 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sam Jarrar <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:18 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sam Jarrar, CPA. Jarrar & Associates CPAs Inc. Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Carolina Mendez <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:26 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Item #19
Hello,
My name is Carolina Mendez, resident of Anaheim and member of Chispa, an OC-based political home for
Latinx young people in the county. Many of our members are residents of Santa Ana, and tonight I am one of
many non-residents who are standing in support with their call for you to demand a ceasefire now.
I'm writing to you to express my support of Item 419.
Recent Data for Progress polls (Nov 22-25) indicate a growing desire for a permanent ceasefire among U.S.
voters, with 66% of likely voters, and 79% of Democrats, supportive. Despite this, our national leaders,
including the President and Congress, have remained largely unresponsive.
Appeals made to Democratic Representatives like Rep. Katie Porter and Rep. Lou Correa have similarly been
disregarded. It's imperative that local officials like you demonstrate their commitment to peace and justice by
raising their voices against the atrocities inflicted upon our Palestinian brethren. History illustrates that genuine
demands for justice often originate from the grassroots level— we ask that you listen to them.
We implore you to stand on the right side of history and echo our call for a ceasefire. Take the opportunity to
demonstrate your political courage and have the resolve to align with the wishes of your constituents. They have
clearly communicated their desire for peace. Now it's your turn to listen and act.
Respectfully,
Carolina Mendez
Araiza, Fatima
From: Arshia Siddiqui <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:30 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Arshia
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Rula Said <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:33 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Rula Said
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Tracy La <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:34 PM
To: eComment; Amezcua, Valerie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil; Penaloza,
David; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan
Cc: Indigo Vu;
Subject: VietRISE Public Comment in Support of Agenda Item 19 - Ceasefire in Palestine
Attachments: 2023-12-05 VietRISE Public Comment in Support of Agenda Item 19.pdf
Hello,
Attached is VietRISE's public comment in support of agenda item 19 - calling for a ceasefire in Palestine.
Thank you,
Tracy
Advancing social justice and building power with working-class Vietnamese and
immigrant communities in Orange County.
Garden Grove, CA 92843 I wwwvietrise.org I @vietriseoc
December 5, 2023
Dear Mayor Amezcua and Santa Ana City Council Members,
My name is Tracy La and I am the Executive Director at VietRISE, a community non-profit
organization based in Orange County, CA. VietRISE advances social justice and builds power with
working-class Vietnamese and immigrant communities in Orange County. On behalf of VietRISE, I
am writing in strong support of agenda item #19 and urge you to further discuss and pass the
resolution in support of a sustained ceasefire in Gaza.
For an agonizing 75 years, the people of Palestine have endured displacement, violence, and occupation
by the state of Israel. In just the past eight weeks, Israel's bombing campaign in Gaza has killed more
than 15,000 Palestinians, wounded over 40,000 people 2, and displaced most of the 2.3 million
residents of Gaza3. Since World War II, the United States has given more than $260 billion in military
and economic aid to Israe14. Due to Israel's total control over Gaza, the region has been described as
"the world's largest open air prison 5." Therefore, our tax dollars have aided the state of Israel in causing
the death of tens of thousands of Palestinians, the violation of Palestinian human rights, and the
displacement of millions. In this context, experts such as Raz Segal, the program director of genocide
studies at Stockton University, have called Israel's killing of Palestinians in Gaza a "textbook case of
genocide"
While the genocide happening in Palestine is an international matter, local voices and decisions like this
one can have an impact in urging our country's leadership to call for an end to the state of Israel's
bombing campaign in Gaza, an immediate ceasefire in order to save Palestinian lives, and to discontinue
the use of our tax dollars for military aid to Israel. As a city that has pushed for inclusive communities,
this resolution in support of a sustained ceasefire is one way to further demonstrate Santa Ana's
commitment to justice. The humanitarian crisis in Gaza is deeply alarming, and the impact of the
' United Nations. (2023, May 15). UN marks 75 years since displacement of 700,000 Palestinians. The United
Nations. bk2a.//news.un.orq/en/storv/2023/05/1136662
2 Sawafta, A. (2023, December 5). More than 15,900 Palestinians killed in Gaza since Oct. 7 - Palestinian health
minister. Reuters.
httgs:// reuters.com/world/middle-east/more-than-15900-galestinians-killed-gaza-since-oct-7-galestinian-health-
mi n i ste r-2023-12-05/
3 Masoud, B. (2023, December 5). Gaza families flee again to shrinking, overcrowded pocket of land. Reuters.
httgs:// neuters.com/world/middle-east/gaza-families-flee-again-shrinking-overcrowded-pocket-land-2023-12-05/
4 Wolf, C. (2023, October 10). How Much Aid Does the U.S. Give to Israel? U.S. News.
httgs:// usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2023-10-10/how-much-aid-does-the-u-s-give-to-israel
5 Hovring, R. (2018, April 26). Gaza: The world's largest open-air prison. Norwegian Refugee Council.
httgs:// nrc.no/news/2018/april/gaza-the-worlds-largest-open-air-prison/
6 Burga, S. (2023, November 14). Is What's Happening in Gaza a Genocide? Experts Weigh In. Time.
httgs://time. com/6334409/is-whets-haggen ing-gaza-genocide-experts/
Advancing social justice and building power with working-class Vietnamese and
immigrant communities in Orange County.
Garden Grove, CA 92843 I www.vietrise.org I @vietriseoc
violence extends far beyond the borders of the region. By taking a stand and passing this resolution,
Santa Ana has the opportunity to show that our local leaders prioritize human rights and the
well-being of communities around the world.
We also want to address the claims of anti-semitism from many people who are attempting to obscure
the true nature of the occupation, genocide, mass displacement, and near continuous air strikes for the
past two months in Palestine. Zionism, the movement for Israel to exist on Palestinian land, is a
political ideology and movement'. Criticizing Zionism is to critique a flawed political ideology that has
led to the death and displacement of millions of Palestinians. It is not anti-Semitic to say that
Palestinians have a right to their land and homes, to live without fear of being bombed, to travel within
their own country without restrictions, and to determine for themselves the future of their country.
We stand in solidarity with Palestinians in their fight for liberation, self-determination, and justice.
To conclude, we urge you to support agenda item 19, and, at the very least, we implore you to
advocate for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza. It is crucial that our federal elected officials hear from
you that a ceasefire must happen immediately. Your time and consideration on this matter are
appreciated.
Sincerely,
M
Tracy La
Executive Director of VietRISE
' The Economist. (2023, April 27). How Zionism has evolved from a project to an ideology. The Economist.
economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2023/04/27/how-zionism-has-evolved-from-a- ro ect-to-an-ideolo
Araiza, Fatima
From: Najah Salam <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:34 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Maria Baeza <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:39 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19" Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza
Good evening,
I am a Santa Ana native currently residing in ward 6. I am requesting that the Santa Ana City Council passes a
resolution as soon as possible supporting an IMMEDIATE AND PERMANENT CEASEFIRE in the Gaza
Strip.
It is imperative that our local officials here in Orange County use their power, influence, and platform to speak
out for the humanity of our Palestinian brothers and sisters.
Many have relatives and family members who are directly impacted by the atrocities committed on the ground. We ask
that Santa Ana City Council be the voice for our communities that are being actively silenced and further marginalized.
Since October 7, members of our communities feel most of the public statements by elected officials furthered
islamophobic and anti -Palestinian sentiment. These statements put our communities at greater risk of hate crimes.
Our government is pouring billions of dollars into funding war crimes, while budgets to support our most vulnerable
communities here are being slashed. Our tax dollars should be invested in providing affordable housing, healthcare, early
childhood education, social services, infrastructure, mental health and other important services to the community.
We look to Santa Ana City Council for leadership when it matters most. Santa Ana is Orange County's hub for social
justice. Actions taken by the Santa Ana city council have a ripple effect that transcends the city's boundaries and shapes
the policies of the county, be it on the issue of sanctuary cities, public budget, or police oversight, inspiring communities
across the county to follow suit.
-Maria Del Rosario Baeza
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:46 PM
To: eComment
Subject: In regards to Palestine Solidarity and Ceasefire
Good afternoon,
I hope this email finds you well. There has been a lot of discourse and debate over what's going on overseas and the
atrocities being committed against innocent human lives. I understand that Israel is an ally of the US and I have done a lot
of research on the history of this conflict. At this point we are long past the sentiment of who was there first, who belongs
where, who did what. The tally needs to be zeroed out and peace needs to be achieved for the sake of the tens of
thousands of innocent lives being lost. Any terrorist attack SHOULD be condemned, but turning a nose up at one while
eagerly turning a blind eye to another is morally reprehensible. As the saying goes an eye for an eye and the world goes
blind. That phrase has taken a whole new meaning for me during these past few months, seeing the vicious response by
Israel to the events that happened on October 7th. I understand the fear of the people and their Government... that's
something many experienced here when 9/11 happened. However you cannot like fear and hatred dictate policy or how
innocent civilians are being treated. This is a tactical response to what is my understanding the 3rd strongest militia in that
area (Hamas), but just a brutal disregard for human life. Press are being fired upon, innocent men, women and children
are being fired upon and so many in power seem to not care. It's disgusting and makes me sick to the pit of my stomach.
Even worse so, knowing that our tax money is quite possibly being used to help fund these vicious attacks in response to
the events of October 7th.
This isn't about anti-Semitism, this isn't about our ally's and whatever agenda they or our Government might have, this is
quite literally about the severe loss of life that many seem to be perfectly ok with. There is no justification for bombing a
hospital or neighborhood, nor is there any justification for saying that there are no innocent civilians (Source: 'No Innocent
Civilians in Gaza', Israel President Says as Northern Gaza Struggles to Flee Israeli Bombs) this is quite literally one of the
worst things I've had to see in my entire life and it's being televised across social media on the daily. It HAS to stop, there
is no other way to put it. These people deserve to live and be treated fairly and without brutality. I just don't know how else
to say it and I can't believe there's actual discourse over this matter. I literally just want people to live, that's it. Can we all
agree upon that?
- Ben Yehdigo
Araiza, Fatima
From: Asma Ahmad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:51 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: B. <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:55 PM
To: Vazquez, Benjamin; Penaloza, David; eComment; Lopez, Jessie; Hernandez, Johnathan;
Bacerra, Phil; Phan, Thai; Amezcua, Valerie
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have
massacred 20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and
displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a
unique opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress. This resolution calls for
Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims contribute
immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique. By passing a resolution demanding an immediate
and permanent ceasefire,
Santa Ana has the opportunity to demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families
from the backlash of hate crimes. Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for
people experiencing the rise of hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within
our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely, Amina
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Sarah Berry <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 5:56 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Agenda Item #19- Call in Support for a Ceasefire in Gaza
Please, we need a ceasefire! It's very important for humanity. Take the time to really use your heart and your humanity
to realize what is going on is terrible and those lives are worth saving. This is terrible what's happening over there and it
cannot continue like this.
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Fariborz Bibayan <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:10 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Regards,
David Bibayan
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Nada E <
Sent:
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:18 PM
To:
eComment
Subject:
Ceasefire
The community demands a ceasefire. Our tax paying dollars are going outside while there are so many issues to be
resolved in this country from healthcare to homelessness. We are also supporting a genocide, and the Arab and Muslim
communities in this country are being treated horrendously. We say stop the racism.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Manahil Haroon <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:21 PM
To: eComment
Subject: City Council Meeting - Public Statement.
Good Evening,
My name is Manahil Awan and I'm a Policy Fellow at The Council on American -Islamic Relations, Los Angeles
Chapter (CAIR-LA).
I would like to thank Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez and CouncilmemberJohnathan Hernandez for
bringing forth this the Resolution in support of the Palestinian People of Gaza, and calling for a ceasefire. I
implore you to lend your voices to the call forjustice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with
Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have
massacred 20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and
displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a
unique opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate
crimes.
We urge the Santa Ana City Council to vote yes in support of the resolution calling for a permanent ceasefire
and an end to the genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people in Gaza. Thank you for your time,
consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City Council's passing
of this humanitarian resolution.
Thank you.
Best,
Manahil H. AWan I Policy and Advocacy Fellow
Council on American -Islamic Relations, California
Greater I osAngeles Area Office
I Anaheim, CA 92801
*Disclaimer: This email may contain confidential and privileged material, including attachments, for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) named
above. Please do not review, use, copy, forward, or in any way distribute or disclose the contents of this e-mail including any attachments unless you
are the intended recipient(s) named above. If you are not the intended recipient, or authorized to receive this message for the recipient, please
contact the sender by reply email and delete all copies of this message. This email does not by itself establish an attorney -client relationship and
may not constitute legal advice. *
Araiza, Fatima
From: Manahil Haroon <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 1:52 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Manahil Haroon
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Steven Frankel <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:17 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
Why are you even discussing this? You are ill equipped to make such statements. You know nothing of military
management. You have no idea of history. You obnoxiously equate rape and burning alive and kidnapping with self
defense. Cease fire equals Hamas and terrorism winning. They have long view and know the west is gullible.
Do your job. Which isn't this.
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Stay out of foreign policy.
Read a book. Learn something
Am Yisrael Chai
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Shareef <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:22 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Shareef
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Edith Castillo <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:26 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Edith Castillo
Santa Ana, 92703
Araiza, Fatima
From: Laura Rips <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 7:41 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Gaza resolution
To whom it may concern,
I write to express deep concerns about the proposed resolution addressing the War in Gaza, particularly its
one-sided nature and potential consequences. As residents, we urge you to consider the broader impact on
our community and focus on issues that directly affect Santa Ana, such as the homeless crisis, affordable
housing scarcity, the MHA problem, and street safety.
I fear that a resolution on an international conflict over which the City Council has no authority may divert
attention from pressing local matters and invite divisive rhetoric, as witnessed in other cities. We respectfully
request that the City Council prioritize the needs of our constituents by withdrawing the proposed resolution
and redirecting attention to pressing issues within the jurisdiction of the City.
Laura Magnusen,
Araiza, Fatima
From: Khwaja Ahmad <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 6:25 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Hassan Ahmad
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: Farah Lakhany <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:14 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Farah Lakhany
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Dear Council Members,
Yana Brodskiy <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 8:21 PM
eComment
Vote NO on Ceasefire Resolution
I am writing to urge you not to participate in signing the Ceasefire Resolution submitted by Councilmembers Vazquez
and Hernandez.
Jews around the world are still reeling in the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas massacre in Israel - the single
deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Many of us have experienced and/or witnessed acts of antisemitism directly.
Adopting a resolution that fails to explicitly condemn Hamas and the wave of antisemitism that followed their atrocities
is condoning the acts of October 7th and their aftermath.
The resolution faults Israel for a war started by Hamas. The loss of life and suffering is felt by both the Israelis and the
Palestinians. The resolution minimizes the suffering of Israelis. 250,000 Israelis have been internally displaced due to the
actions of Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorists abducted 240 hostages on October 7th. This resolution calls Israel's
prisoners, many of whom have committed crimes including stabbings and bombing populated civilian locations,
hostages.
Israelis want peace and a quick end to the war. A ceasefire with Hamas, as has been demonstrated repeatedly over time,
will end in the spilling of Israeli blood. Senior Hamas leaders have indicated their intentions to continue in their goal to
eradicate the land of Israel of Jews. Hamas is the catalyst for the Palestinian and Israeli casualties. The people of Gaza
deserve a better future which is possible only once Hamas is gone.
A ceasefire would perpetuate the status quo, allowing Hamas to continue to control and terrorize Gaza. Do not set a
precedent that crimes against Israeli and Palestinian civilians pays off, by supporting this Ceasefire Resolution. The City
of Santa Ana should not inadvertently incentivize more violence, at the expense of innocent Israelis and Palestinians.
While this resolution may have been introduced with good intentions, I believe it would harm the Santa Ana community
and only fuel more hatred and conflict. Please vote no on the Ceasefire Resolution.
Yana Brodskiy, Realtor
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Victor Payan <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 9:01 PM
To: !City Clerk; eComment
Subject: Santa Ana Residents Denied Right to Speak on Agenda Item 19
Dear City Clerk,
Can you please let me know the number of people who called in via Zoom and phone to speak during tonight's
City Council meeting on Agenda Item 19, such as myself, and were denied their right to civic participation via
public comment on an important humanitarian issue affecting the Santa Ana community by Mayor Amezcua's
arbitrary and undemocratic decree that public comment would be limited to two hours?
By my tally, over 90% of the speakers tonight supported the ceasefire resolution, and it is likely that the
residents who were denied their voice tonight shared this view to the same degree.
I look forward to your response regarding the number of residents who were denied their right to public
comment on Agenda Item 19.
Thank You,
- Victor Payan
Ward 2
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 9:18 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your
voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in
Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred
20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7
million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique
opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard
and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and
Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences,
and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of
hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value
the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to
your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Bilal Khan,
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Santa Ana Council Members,
Alice ML <
Tuesday, December 05, 2023 9:21 PM
eComment
Dec 5 Council Meeting, Agenda 19
I am shocked and disheartened that two of the City of Santa Ana Councilmen feel the need to open
discussion in not just international affairs, but posed in a way that can be construed as emboldening
hate and violence toward Jewish Americans, already a horrifying 388% increase in antisemitism in
the US putting fellow Jewish Americans at great risk due to mis and disinformation pushed from the
title of this Agenda item alone. Why is this mis and disinformation? Please see below, hoping you will
take the time to understand that Hamas are a formal terrorist organization and if Americans actually
cared for Gazans and people in Palestine, they would be very pro -Israel.
There are ZERO Jews & ZERO open LGBTQ in Gaza and Palestine as Hamas would have them &
has had them killed - please check. Israel, on the other hand, has the ONLY Pride Parade in the
Middle East - please understand why this is. Gazans and people in Palestine live under Terrorist
Hamas Rule, they live under Sharia law - anti -Israel is supporting Hamas Terrorist Rule, Supporting
Sharia Law. We are beyond privileged and fortunate to live in America where we are not forced to live
under Sharia Law and radical terrorist rule.
Agenda 19: Discuss and Consider Directing the Interim City Manager to Prepare a Resolution for City
Council's Consideration to Call in Support of a Ceasefire in Gaza — Councilmembers Vazquez and
Hernandez
The job of the council people "is the governing body of the City, except as otherwise provided in the
Charter, and enacts ordinances subject to the approval or veto of the Mayor. It orders elections,
levies taxes, authorizes public improvements, approves contracts, and adopts traffic regulations."
How on earth does Gaza play into your agenda, unless you are hoping to continue the antisemitic
and anti -Israel propaganda?
Unfortunately, most people are uneducated on the Middle East and forming opinions without the
education is just showing your ignorance.
The charter of Hamas, the "government' of Palestine, is to annihilate Israel and the Jewish people.
When Hamas first took over the Palestinians in the 80's they started with suicide bombers until Israel
put up a fence/border around the area. They then took up rocket launching and thankfully, Israel is a
very tech savvy country so they were able to build an Iron Dome to stop the rockets from killing
innocent Israelis.
The Palestinians used all their international funding from the U.S. that was to build schools and
educate their people, and instead, built over 300 miles of tunnels to hide out their terror organization
and infiltrate Israel.
Here is Hamas' charter httpse//avalon.lawe ale.edu/20th century/hamas.asp
called their Covenant that states in Article 7 "The Day of Judgement will not come about until
Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The
stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Article
Eight: "Allah is its target, the Prophet is its model, the Koran its constitution: Jihad is its path and
death for the sake of Allah is the loftiest of its wishes.".
Israel walked away from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and had every Israeli leave the area. Did the
Palestinians do anything positive with those Israeli homes, businesses, greenhouses? NO. So, why
are they still attacking Israelis when there are zero Israelis in the Gaza Strip??? Because in their
charter that is listed above, they want Israeli wiped off the planet.
Aren't you curious why Arabs are chanting, "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free". Because
they want the land between the river to the sea, which is Israel, to be gone. They have freedom from
Israel as Israelis no longer live there; they don't have freedom from their own terror government
Hamas.
The idea that Israel is in the midst of genocide is ridiculous as on Oct. 7th, it was Hamas who
attacked, raped, burned people alive, shot people (over 1500) and took over 240 hostages,
many of which are still stuck as hostages in the tunnels mentioned. The Palestinians asked for
this war on Oct. 7th as who wouldn't defend their people? In fact, they still have 135+ hostages. Do
you want a ceasefire and let these hostages rot?? Also, since Hamas is in the tunnels, Israel has to
bomb to find the tunnels as they've already found some that are in hospitals and schools!!!
There is no genocide as Israel gave a few weeks warning to the Palestinians before they counter
attacked. They dropped flyers from the sky telling them to leave. They sent text messages telling
them to leave. They worked with the U.N. for relocation of people. The Israelis are not bombing for
the sake of bombing and trying to kill Palestinians. Hamas needs to come out of their 300 terror miles
and give up the hostages and Israel would stop. Israel has every right to defend itself (as the U.S. did
on 9/11 when a different terrorist organization attacked us). Hamas is using their people as their
shields to continue the propaganda that Israel is "bad", when in fact, Hamas started this, raped
women, cut off their breasts, burned families alive and tells their own people to stay and get killed.
I'm curious, did you vote on condemning Russian when they invaded Ukraine? Will you be voting
about the conflict of Armenia?
For some reason, your antisemitism has passed the litmus test because you are not doing your jobs
and focusing on the city.
Here are some resources to learn about the Middle East as clearly, you don't understand what is
happening, nor the history of the area.
Here is a book you can read about the Israel by Noa Tishby https://wwweamazonecom/Israel-Sim le-
Guide-Misunderstood-Countr /dp/1932144947/ref=asc df 1932144947/?tack=hy rod-
20&IinkCode=df0&hvadid=532676525296043925&hv
pone=�hvptwo=�hvmt=�hvdev=c�hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=Shvlocphy=9031549�hv�= la-
1391333379911 iAsburBhCIAR
IsAExmsu5T9FOlaTiNIWT7w0iWYhmT7oo6zSXMTvAv5Ci5hnbllT4ocBvWOU0aArFkEALw wcB
These are short videos to start learning:
https://wwwe rat eruecom/video/a-Palestinian-explains-hamas
hops://www. ra. eru.com/video/does-israel-occupy-the-west-bank
Does Israel Occupy the West Bank? PragerU
How rnany tirnes have yoti heard ffia( Israel "occtiples" [lie Wes[ Bank'? Bta
have yoti ever asked yotirselrwhelher (hal's Or even warne hi A ans'?
Etigene— ,
A Palestinian Explains Mamas PragerU
1. low do we rnake life, beuer ror (hose who live in Gaza'? According to
Palesknian poll(Ical analys( Bassern Eld, we siari by recognizing who is
really— ,
QK1 C&rnibextid=v7YzrnG&v=1 028228768381369
Brigitte Gabriel translates and exposes written Muslim
Brotherhood plan to destroy the United States 'The Muslim
Brotherhood has been working to destroy the United States
from within for DECADES, this is their secret written plan
exposed. y Brigitte Ga
"I'lle Muslim Brotherhood has been working (c) des(roy (lie LAI(ed Smes from wiffiln ror
DECADES, (his is (heir secret wrluen plan exposed,
This is a 30 minute video-
t-war
3
Ep. 3 10 — Israel Is at War PragerU
Over the weekend, I lamas latinched ffic rnosi bri.Aal attack on Israel in (lie
na(lon's hislory, I I tindreds or1sraefis were bn,aally ioru,ired, kidnapped,
and— ,
Araiza, Fatima
From: Emine YILDIZ <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 10:14 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Re: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor, Vice Mayor and Council members,
I am so disappointed in you that after listening to the testimonies and statements of all the people who spoke
tonight as well as the many many emails you received regarding this beyond urgent issue as well as the many
who were waiting in queue, including myself, who did not get to speak on the issue, that you were unable to put
aside all other hindrances and just stay "stop" to the merciless killing of innocent lives.
I cannot wrap my head or heart around what could possibly be holding you back from calling for a ceasefire, an
end to the unapologetic murdering of babies, children, mothers, fathers, uncles, aunts, grandmas and grandpas.
When it is your turn to speak, everyone speaks of the trauma, discrimination or violence that they themselves or
their families were subject to, why then can we not show empathy to the thousands upon thousands who are
literally being subject to genocide in front of our very eyes? Why?!!
True leadership is shown through actions not just words. True leadership is upholding the values we claim to
stand for despite the backlash it may bring.
Those who claim that calling for a ceasefire will bring division into the community are exactly the ones who are
perpetrating and fueling that division they refer to. How can calling for peace be a form of division. How can
we achieve unity through more killing?
Will you kindly explain this to me?!!
You claim to not be experts in international politics. Neither am L But we do not need to be experts to know
that when it our hard earned tax dollars that fund a brutal occupation and genocide overseas, it becomes as local
an issue as any other.
We are all part of one human family, and tonight you (excluding the council members who called for the
ceasefire) have failed to stand up for your fellow brothers and sisters. You have failed in showing true
leadership. What a shame...
With a heavy heart,
Emine Yildiz
OnTuesday, Deceml)er 5, 2023, 2;16 PN4, 2;m ne ' ,::eyu� -
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you
to lend your voices to the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity
with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces
have massacred 20,000 Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000
children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of
diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now
considered a graveyard and is in urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of
Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our
community, Arabs and Muslims contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural
diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are integral parts of the very fabric that makes
Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the
opportunity to demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families
from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people
experiencing the rise of hate crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and
within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message
that we value the lives of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We
look forward to your City Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Emine Yildiz
Araiza, Fatima
From:
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 10:39 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
Affy Manjra
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Araiza, Fatima
From: heba bataineh <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 10:53 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Thank you,
Heba AI-Bataineh
Araiza, Fatima
From: Miriam Weisz -Hershkop <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 11:12 PM
To: eComment
Subject: Support for Israel
Good evening, Please stand with Israel, the only democratic country in the Middle East who saw 1400 civillians
murdered without warning on October 7, 2023. Israel has a right to defend itself. Israel goes to extreme efforts
to minimize civillian casualties by sending leaflets via airplanes and making thousands of phone calls. There is
no other army that would put their own military strategies at risk (by surrendering their ability to perform
surprise attacks, which would certainly be more effective) to help the opposing people. The IDF is only acting
in self-defense of its nation. In an interview last week, Hamas stated that October 7th was just practice. Prior to
this they stated they will commit October 7th again and again and again. When terrorists say they will kill, they
need to be believed. Israel should continue to defend itself. There was a ceasefire on October 6th, but Hamas
did not abide by it. They state clearly they do not plan on abiding by any ceasefires moving forward. Asking for
a ceasefire is asking Israelis to walk into gas chambers. While that may have been the case for their
grandparents, that will not be the case now. Never again.
Araiza, Fatima
From: Afsheen <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 11:20 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone
Araiza, Fatima
From: Imad Baqai <
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2023 11:39 PM
To: Amezcua, Valerie; Lopez, Jessie; Phan, Thai; Vazquez, Benjamin; Bacerra, Phil;
Hernandez, Johnathan; Penaloza, David; eComment
Subject: Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinians in Support of a Ceasefire
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I trust this letter finds you well. It is with a heavy heart and a sense of urgency that I implore you to lend your voices to
the call for justice and humanity by passing the Resolution in Solidarity with Palestinian People in Support of a Ceasefire.
We have witnessed the injustices of the occupation of Palestine, where Israeli occupation forces have massacred 20,000
Palestinians since October 7, including a heartbreaking number of 8,000 children and displaced 1.7 million Gazans. The
world is watching, and Santa Ana, a beacon of diversity and inclusivity, has a unique opportunity to stand on the right
side of history.
The destruction of vital infrastructure of Gaza are haunting reminders that Gaza is now considered a graveyard and is in
urgent need of humanitarian intervention from local members of Congress.
This resolution calls for Santa Ana to be a leader in human rights for all people. In our community, Arabs and Muslims
contribute immensely to the rich tapestry of Santa Ana's cultural diversity. Their voices, experiences, and heritage are
integral parts of the very fabric that makes Santa Ana unique.
By passing a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire, Santa Ana has the opportunity to
demonstrate leadership, compassion, and a commitment to protecting families from the backlash of hate crimes.
Santa Ana needs solidarity, and our community can be a source of support for people experiencing the rise of hate
crimes due to the dehumanization of Palestinians in the media and within our governments.
Let Santa Ana be a city that stands united against injustice and bigotry and sends a clear message that we value the lives
of all individuals, regardless of their background or nationality.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and the crucial work you do for our community. We look forward to your City
Council's passing of this humanitarian resolution.
Sincerely,
<Name>
Santa Ana, CA 92705
Sent from my iPhone