DA Letter_Redacted - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

shooting over his left shoulder. Officer Esquivel recalled Officer Ayala firing seven or eight rounds. Officer Esquivel stated that he believed Officer Ayala was encountering a threat to his life because he had never before heard Officer Ayala scream the way he was screaming at that moment. Jfficer Esquivel stated that he saw a female, later identified as Gonzalez, exit the garage and run across the alley , appearing like she was "going after" Officer Ayala. Officer Esquivel stated that, while he did not see any firearms on Gonzalez, he believed Gonzalez was going to engage Officer Ayala in a gunfight, so he withdrew his weapon and fired at her. He saw Gonzalez take maybe a step or two and collapse in the alley. Officer Esquivel recalled having no visual of Gonzalez's right arm when she collapsed, as it was underneath her. He recalled moving back down the alley toward his car, where he saw Officer Ayala standing next to him. He watched Officer Ayala reengage Gonzalez by firing approximately three more rounds at Gonzalez . Officer Esquivel believed a few second went by before the officers then saw two heads poke out of the garage and look toward them. He thought the heads were possibly going to start shooting at the officers or try to get away. As other officers arrived, he remembered setting up a perimeter and handcuffing Gonzalez. When he pulled Gonzalez's right arm out from underneath her, Officer Esquivel noticed a lightweight, gray replica handgun that had no safety marking on it. At this point, he did not know where the two people who had peeked out from the garage had gone. Neighborhood Canvass Interviews There were no percipient witnesses to the officer-involved shooting besides Officers Ayala and Esquivel. Investigators conducted canvass interviews on the morning of June 23, 2013, as well as several additional mornings. Several residents of Townsend Street reported that they were inside their apartments at the time of the incident and had heard between seven and 10 gunshots . Many thought they had heard fireworks. One man reported hearing voices screaming after the gunshots had ended, but he could not tell what was being said. Others reported hearing voices yell, "Get on the ground" or "Don't move ." Some residents stated that they had been sleeping and awoke to the sound of gunshots, while others slept through the entire incident and were unaware anything had happened. EVIDENCE COLLECTED AT THE SCENE A forensic scientist employed by the OCCL collected the following evidence at the scene: • 20 cartridge cases • six apparent bullet jacket fragments • four bullet fragments • one piece of metal • one bullet jacket fragment • one bullet • one bullet with apparent blood • one gray plastic toy gun with apparent blood • one syringe loaded with apparent blood • sunglasses The cartridge cases, bullets, and bullet fragments were strewn throughout the alley from 810 S. Raitt Street and 809 S. Townsend Street to 729 S. Townsend Street. Holes and strike marks were in the east walls, garage door frame, garage door, and pillar of 809 and 805 S. Townsend Street and 729, 730, and 802 S. Raitt Street. EVIDENCE ANALYSIS Findings at Autopsy On June 26, 2013, at 9:00 a.m., an autopsy was conducted by Dr. Etoi Davenport , a forensic path ologis t for the Orange )unty Sheriff-Coroner. Dr. Davenport located nine wounds on Gonzalez's body, described as follows: 6