Laserfiche WebLink
A windshield survey of the Lacy neighborhood, as defined in a previous historical resources study, <br /> with the exception of the portion located in the French Park District, was conducted on December <br /> 30, 2010. The boundaries of this neighborhood are Civic Center Drive on the north, Poinsettia <br /> Street on the east, Fourth Street on the south, and Spurgeon and French Streets on the west. The <br /> purpose of the windshield survey was to determine the potential for a historic district in the <br /> neighborhood. <br /> 403 EVALUATION <br /> 4.3.E Use of Criteria of Significance <br /> Resources were evaluated using the criteria of significance for listing in the NRHP, CRHR, and <br /> SARHP Section 3, ~eg~~ator}r ~rame~vork~. The NRHP and CRHR criteria mirror each other. The <br /> SARHP criteria are mostly complementary. SARHP Criteria 1, 2, and 3 spe[I out architectural <br /> significance somewhat more specifically than NRHPICRHR Criterion C13. Similarly, SARHP <br /> Criteria ~ a through d and ~ address historical association and linkage with important persons in a <br /> manner mare relevant to Santa Ana than NRHP/CRHR Criteria All and BIZ, NRHPICRHR Criterion <br /> Dl4 and SARHP Criterion 5 are directed toward the evaluation of archaeological properties and <br /> were not utilized in this Historical Assessment. It is possible that, given the variation in criteria, <br /> properties found eligible for the SARHP ar even the CRHR may not be eligible for the NRHP. <br /> Primarily, this difference in conclusions is due to the Santa Ana practice of categorization, as <br /> Landmark, Key, ar Contributive, which has enabled the City of Santa Ana to create tiers of <br /> significance. As a general rule, all properties categorized as Landmark and most properties <br /> categorized as Key will be eligible for the NRHP and CRHR. Properties categorized as Contributive <br /> would be eligible for the NRHP or CRHR in many cases only if they are contributors to a potential <br /> historic district. The question of required levels of integrity also differentiates the three types of <br /> designation. <br /> 4.3.2 Required Levels of Integrity <br /> Na~ivrra~ Regls~er of His~orrc Paces <br /> The NRHP defines ir~tegrit}~ as the ability of a property to convey its significance.' There are seven <br /> aspects to i ntegrity: <br /> ~ Location is the place where the historic property was constructed ar the place <br /> where the historic event occurred, <br /> ~ Design is the combination of elements that create the form, plan, space, structure, <br /> and style of a property. <br /> ~ Setting is the physical environment of a historic property. <br /> ~ Materials are the physical elements that were combined or deposited during a <br /> particular period of time and in a particular pattern ar configuration to form a <br /> historic property. <br /> ~ workmanship is the physica[ evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or people <br /> during any given period in history or prehistory. <br /> 13 U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service. Accessed ~ February .2~~ 1. ~iatianal Register Bulletr'n 15; How <br /> tc~ Ap~~~ly the Natiar~a~ Register Criteria for evaluation, pp. 44~-49d Washington, Dc. Available at: <br /> ~~~~:~p:11~~vww.nps.gavlnrlpubl icationslbul letinslnrb15 <br /> <br /> :~°r e':~:tio~ District Project Nr`storical ,4ssessment <br /> ;9~:,;~y Za 11 .~aaphas nviranmer~tal, lrrc. <br /> .`;';'~'~~.~JCTSI1471I1~7?-QD7lDacumentslHistoricaf Assessmer~tlFinall4 ~ethads.Dac ~:a~ Page ~-3 <br /> <br />