Laserfiche WebLink
that each historical building has characteristic scale and mass unique to its particular style, and <br />such qualities should be recognized and incorporated into additions and expansions. <br />Again the Application is consistent with these regulations, as it proposes a desirable and <br />necessary addition to existing improvements in a manner that: preserves and does not physically <br />alter historic and architectural features of the Residence; preserves design elements, details and <br />materials utilized in the existing Residence in a historically sensitive and accurate manner; is <br />physically separated from the existing Residence thereby clearly delineating the old construction <br />from the new; and is of a height, scale, design, and material that complements the overall <br />character, scale, proportion, massing, and detailing of the Residence. <br />Perhaps most on point, however, is the Design Standard's discussion of fencing for historically <br />significant residential properties. The Standards note that fencing of appropriate material and <br />design may do much to contribute to the historical flavor of neighborhoods, and may "positively <br />affect the aesthetic quality of a neighborhood and increase property values." The relevant <br />sections include design considerations, characteristics, and principles, as well as photographs for <br />acceptable designs for varying architectural styles. It is of note that none of these photographs <br />provide samples of acceptable designs for two (2) story residences, or for residences constructed <br />in the Italian Renaissance Revival style <br />Such design considerations indicate that fencing: should be ornamental in nature and constructed <br />of material complimentary to the main structure on the property and compatible with the <br />neighborhood; should be designed to complement the architectural style and character of the <br />main dwelling and neighborhood; kept as low as possible while still performing their intended <br />decorative or screening functions; gates should be designed to match the fence pattern, design, <br />and materials; and may include wrought iron if compatible with the residence's architectural <br />style and reflective of historical patterns and features. Designs or features not recommended by <br />the Standards including front yard fences with an exaggerated design or a fortressing look; cinder <br />block, plain concrete block, or chain link front yard fences; front yard fencing designed for <br />fortressing purposes; or removal or radically changing important architectural features that <br />define the overall character of the fencing. <br />The Application is consistent with these guidelines, as the proposed wall: is ornamental in nature <br />and constructed of stucco with wrought iron gates which are compatible with Residence; is <br />compatible with the existing neighborhood which boasts residences, fencing, walls, and <br />vegetation of unique designs, colors, and styles, and of varying heights; is only as tall as <br />necessary to preserve its decorative and screening function, while simultaneously remaining <br />compatible with the architecture and scale of the Residence; and includes iron gates that mirror <br />iron features adoring the Residence. The design of the proposed wall is not exaggerated and does <br />not create a fortressing look given: the styling and scale of the Residence; entry gates providing <br />sight -lines to the Residence; and availability of unobstructed views over the wall, particularly <br />given the Residence's location on an elevated grade. at a grade above that of the public right-of- <br />way. <br />2) That the granting of a variance or minor exception is necessary for the preservation and <br />enjoyment of one (1) or more substantial property rights. <br />