HomeMy WebLinkAboutPOWERPOINT - 75A_Ward Presentation_Consultant
10/16/2018
RedistrictingOverview
City of Santa Ana
City Council Public Hearing
October 16, 2018
75A
1
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by City of Santa Ana
There are a number of criteria that have been used
nationally and upheld by courts.
Relatively equal size -people, not citizens
•
Contiguous –districts should not hop/jump
•
Maintain “communities of interest”
•
Follow city/county/local government lines
•
Keep districts compact –appearance/function
•
2
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by Local Agencies
There are a number of criteria that have been used
nationally and upheld by courts.
Relatively equal size -people, not citizens
•
Contiguous –districts should not hop/jump
•
Maintain “communities of interest”
•
Follow city/county/local government lines
•
Keep districts compact –appearance/function
•
3
1
10/16/2018
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by Local Agencies
The “equal size” for the purposes of redistricting comes
from the 2010 Census population.
2010 Population: 324,585
•
Median District Size: 54,098
•
5% Deviation Largest: 55,450
•
Smallest: 52,745
4
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by Local Agencies
There are a number of criteria that have been used
nationally and upheld by courts.
Relatively equal size -people, not citizens
•
Contiguous –districts should not hop/jump
•
Maintain “communities of interest”
•
Follow city/county/local government lines
•
Keep districts compact –appearance/function
•
5
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by Local Agencies
There are a number of criteria that have been used
nationally and upheld by courts.
Relatively equal size -people, not citizens
•
Contiguous –districts should not hop/jump
•
Maintain “communities of interest”
•
Follow city/county/local government lines
•
Keep districts compact –appearance/function
•
6
2
10/16/2018
Communities of Interest
Bringing like people together for representation
What is a community of interest includes ethnic and
language minorities and other groups.
Communities covered by the Voting Rights Act
•
Latinos
•
Asians
•
African Americans
•
Religious communities
•
Other Nationality/Ethnic communities
•
7
City of Santa Ana
Latino and Asian Communities
There are densities of Latino and Asian population that
will need to be considered in line drawing process.
•For ethnic populations we are concerned with the “Citizen Voting
Age Population” (CVAP) as calculated by the US Census annually
through the American Community Survey.
•Base ethnicity of the City shows 17% Asian and 60% Latino CVAP.
However, these populations are not evenly distributed -there are
strong concentrations of each in parts of the district.
8
City of Santa Ana
Latino and Asian Communities
9
3
10/16/2018
10
11
12
4
10/16/2018
13
Communities of Interest
Bringing like people together for representation
Other communities, generally known as “communities
of interest” can be determined by the council or the
public. Some examples are:
People living near an industry
•
(agricultural, aerospace, downtown)
Senior Citizen communities
•
Coastal / River access communities
•
Environmental Interests
•
Homeowners or Renters
•
14
15
5
10/16/2018
16
17
18
6
10/16/2018
19
20
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by Local Agencies
There are a number of criteria that have been used
nationally and upheld by courts.
Relatively equal size -people, not citizens
•
Contiguous –districts should not hop/jump
•
Maintain “communities of interest”
•
Follow city/county/local government lines
•
Keep districts compact –appearance/function
•
21
7
10/16/2018
Traditional Redistricting Principles
Should be followed by Local Agencies
There are a number of criteria that have been used
nationally and upheld by courts.
Relatively equal size -people, not citizens
•
Contiguous –districts should not hop/jump
•
Maintain “communities of interest”
•
Follow city/county/local government lines
•
Keep districts compact –appearance/function
•
22
Community Meetings
Significant outreach has been conducted
We have held multiple community hearings within
different communities around Santa Ana.
Top Concerns voiced:
Keeping neighborhoods together
•
Considering socioeconomic factors, including rental
•
vs. homeowner, income, education, etc…
Process: How and why this is happening, the role of
•
the voters vs. courts in deciding.
23
Online System
Map drawing feature available online
Map drawing has been submitted by the public. These
aren’t full plans, but identified communities of interest.
Top themes:
What neighborhoods should be related
•
Areas that are communities outside of
•
neighborhoods.
Using rental and income data to draw modified
•
district in plan D to capture more low income and
renters.
24
8
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
Current Districts
25
26
City of Santa Ana
Neighborhoods
27
9
10/16/2018
28
29
30
10
10/16/2018
31
32
33
11
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
School Districts
34
35
City of Santa Ana
Congressional
36
12
10/16/2018
37
City of Santa Ana
Current Lines
Current Lines123456
Population 53,095 54,480 54,772 54,794 53,563 53,881
Deviation (1,003) 382 674 696 (535) (217)
-2%1%1%1%-1%0%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 22,613 16,410 30,800 24,668 20,426 25,502
43%30%56%45%38%47%
Latino CVAP 14,944 13,103 13,853 14,606 14,713 12,843
66%80%45%59%72%50%
White CVAP 4,743 1,947 9,260 5,348 2,548 3,551
21%12%30%22%12%14%
African American CVAP 485 148 316 613 428 568
2%1%1%2%2%2%
Asian CVAP 2,187 1,003 6,897 3,694 2,525 8,068
10%6%22%15%12%32%
38
Current Lines123456
Population 53,095 54,480 54,772 54,794 53,563 53,881
Deviation (1,003) 382 674 696 (535) (217)
-2%1%1%1%-1%0%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 22,613 16,410 30,800 24,668 20,426 25,502
43%30%56%45%38%47%
Latino CVAP 14,944 13,103 13,853 14,606 14,713 12,843
66%80%45%59%72%50%
White CVAP 4,743 1,947 9,260 5,348 2,548 3,551
21%12%30%22%12%14%
African American CVAP 485 148 316 613 428 568
2%1%1%2%2%2%
Asian CVAP 2,187 1,003 6,897 3,694 2,525 8,068
10%6%22%15%12%32%
39
13
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
Plan A
PLAN AABCDEF
Population 54,539 54,399 53,751 53,680 54,038 54,176
Deviation 441 301 (347) (418) (60) 78
1%1%-1%-1%0%0%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 27,031 20,808 27,179 25,585 17,295 22,526
50%38%51%48%32%42%
Latino CVAP 11,893 15,300 13,168 14,900 14,170 14,636
44%74%48%58%82%65%
White CVAP 2,915 2,345 10,335 5,373 1,807 4,622
11%11%38%21%10%21%
African American CVAP 263 444 394 748 93 616
1%2%1%3%1%3%
Asian CVAP 11,494 2,525 2,776 4,267 995 2,317
43%12%10%17%6%10%
40
PLAN AABCDEF
Population 54,539 54,399 53,751 53,680 54,038 54,176
Deviation 441 301 (347) (418) (60) 78
1%1%-1%-1%0%0%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 27,031 20,808 27,179 25,585 17,295 22,526
50%38%51%48%32%42%
Latino CVAP 11,893 15,300 13,168 14,900 14,170 14,636
44%74%48%58%82%65%
White CVAP 2,915 2,345 10,335 5,373 1,807 4,622
11%11%38%21%10%21%
African American CVAP 263 444 394 748 93 616
1%2%1%3%1%3%
Asian CVAP 11,494 2,525 2,776 4,267 995 2,317
43%12%10%17%6%10%
41
42
14
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
Plan B
PLAN BABCDEF
Population 53,864 54,497 54,367 53,794 54,269 53,792
Deviation (234) 399 269 (304) 171 (306)
0%1%0%-1%0%-1%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 27,760 26,316 26,164 22,589 22,235 15,360
52%48%48%42%41%29%
Latino CVAP 11,212 15,234 17,814 15,467 11,933 12,407
40%58%68%68%54%81%
White CVAP 3,216 5,529 5,061 4,200 7,637 1,748
12%21%19%19%34%11%
African American CVAP 269 751 508 393 445 182
1%3%2%2%2%1%
Asian CVAP 12,482 4,486 2,407 2,163 1,938 898
45%17%9%10%9%6%
43
PLAN BABCDEF
Population 53,864 54,497 54,367 53,794 54,269 53,792
Deviation (234) 399 269 (304) 171 (306)
0%1%0%-1%0%-1%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 27,760 26,316 26,164 22,589 22,235 15,360
52%48%48%42%41%29%
Latino CVAP 11,212 15,234 17,814 15,467 11,933 12,407
40%58%68%68%54%81%
White CVAP 3,216 5,529 5,061 4,200 7,637 1,748
12%21%19%19%34%11%
African American CVAP 269 751 508 393 445 182
1%3%2%2%2%1%
Asian CVAP 12,482 4,486 2,407 2,163 1,938 898
45%17%9%10%9%6%
44
45
15
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
Plan C
PLAN CABCDEF
Population 53,852 53,158 55,083 54,848 53,494 54,148
Deviation (246) (940) 985 750 (604) 50
0%-2%2%1%-1%0%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 29,015 23,568 20,253 22,779 27,823 16,981
54%44%37%42%52%31%
Latino CVAP 11,277 15,473 14,647 16,220 13,426 13,029
39%66%72%71%48%77%
White CVAP 4,012 4,101 2,507 4,161 10,533 2,077
14%17%12%18%38%12%
African American CVAP 283 712 487 330 423 313
1%3%2%1%2%2%
Asian CVAP 12,846 3,057 2,450 1,706 2,905 1,410
44%13%12%7%10%8%
46
PLAN CABCDEF
Population 53,852 53,158 55,083 54,848 53,494 54,148
Deviation (246) (940) 985 750 (604) 50
0%-2%2%1%-1%0%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 29,015 23,568 20,253 22,779 27,823 16,981
54%44%37%42%52%31%
Latino CVAP 11,277 15,473 14,647 16,220 13,426 13,029
39%66%72%71%48%77%
White CVAP 4,012 4,101 2,507 4,161 10,533 2,077
14%17%12%18%38%12%
African American CVAP 283 712 487 330 423 313
1%3%2%1%2%2%
Asian CVAP 12,846 3,057 2,450 1,706 2,905 1,410
44%13%12%7%10%8%
47
48
16
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
Plan D
PLAN DABCDEF
Population 53,515 52,395 52,744 56,104 54,425 55,402
Deviation (583) (1,703) (1,354) 2,006 327 1,304
-1%-3%-3%4%1%2%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 26,472 22,302 14,018 28,648 25,658 23,321
49%43%27%51%47%42%
Latino CVAP 10,813 14,772 10,901 15,789 16,595 15,187
41%66%78%55%65%65%
White CVAP 3,058 4,651 1,799 9,696 5,332 2,861
12%21%13%34%21%12%
African American CVAP 193 459 193 444 429 840
1%2%1%2%2%4%
Asian CVAP 11,776 2,182 964 2,354 2,964 4,134
44%10%7%8%12%18%
49
PLAN DABCDEF
Population 53,515 52,395 52,744 56,104 54,425 55,402
Deviation (583) (1,703) (1,354) 2,006 327 1,304
-1%-3%-3%4%1%2%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 26,472 22,302 14,018 28,648 25,658 23,321
49%43%27%51%47%42%
Latino CVAP 10,813 14,772 10,901 15,789 16,595 15,187
41%66%78%55%65%65%
White CVAP 3,058 4,651 1,799 9,696 5,332 2,861
12%21%13%34%21%12%
African American CVAP 193 459 193 444 429 840
1%2%1%2%2%4%
Asian CVAP 11,776 2,182 964 2,354 2,964 4,134
44%10%7%8%12%18%
50
51
17
10/16/2018
City of Santa Ana
Plan D 2
PLAN D 2 ABCDEF
Population 53,515 54,646 54,038 54,656 54,075 53,655
Deviation (583) 548 (60) 558 (23) (443)
-1%1%0%1%0%-1%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 26,467 21,702 15,110 29,145 25,417 22,583
49%40%28%53%47%42%
Latino CVAP 10,803 15,902 10,983 15,405 16,231 14,733
41%73%73%53%64%65%
White CVAP 3,058 3,495 2,532 10,198 5,458 2,661
12%16%17%35%21%12%
African American CVAP 193 417 316 363 453 816
1%2%2%1%2%4%
Asian CVAP 11,776 1,696 1,119 2,740 2,964 4,084
44%8%7%9%12%18%
52
PLAN D 2 ABCDEF
Population 53,515 54,646 54,038 54,656 54,075 53,655
Deviation (583) 548 (60) 558 (23) (443)
-1%1%0%1%0%-1%
18+ Citizens (CVAP) 26,467 21,702 15,110 29,145 25,417 22,583
49%40%28%53%47%42%
Latino CVAP 10,803 15,902 10,983 15,405 16,231 14,733
41%73%73%53%64%65%
White CVAP 3,058 3,495 2,532 10,198 5,458 2,661
12%16%17%35%21%12%
African American CVAP 193 417 316 363 453 816
1%2%2%1%2%4%
Asian CVAP 11,776 1,696 1,119 2,740 2,964 4,084
44%8%7%9%12%18%
53
54
18
10/16/2018
55
19