Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCORRESPONDENCE - 65CUc fil4'�. yCity Council Meeting Correspondence 3/19/2019 Item 65C REVIEW APPLICATIONS SUBMITTED FOR WARD 4 CITY COUNCIL OFFICE VACANCY; No. CONDUCT INTERVIEWS OF CANDIDATES TO FILL WARD 4 CITY COUNCIL OFFICE VACANCY; AND CONSIDER MAKING AN APPOINTMENT TO FILL VACANCY IN CITY COUNCIL OFFICE, WARD Bate of Name Representative of In Favor of In opposition Comment Correspondence RA*. of RA*. 1 3/1412019 Norma Wilson Yes 2 3/17/2019 Paul Gonzales Santa Ana Resident Yes 3 3/17/2019 Giau Thanh Nguyen Vietnamese Interfaith Council In Yes America 4 3/19/2019 Connie Hamilton Yes 5 3/19/2019 Tri Ta Mayor, City of Westminster yes 6 3/1912019 Bobi Keenan yes 7 3/21/2019 Dean and Norma Wilson Yes g 3/2212019 Tish Leon Yes 9 3/22/2019 David Hastie Yes *RA - Recommended Action Friday, March 22, 2019 Page 1 of 1 Orozco, Norma From: Barraza, Eric Sent: Thursday, March 14, 2019 9:09 AM To: Norma Wilson; City Council Subject: RE: Appoint Phil Bacerra for Ward 4!" Hello, On behalf of the Mayor and City Council, thank you for emailing your comments. I have forwarded your email to the appropriate staff for review. Best Regards, Eric Barraza I Management Intern City Manager's Office City of Santa Ana 20 Civic Center Plaza Santa Ana, CA 92701 Direct(714) 640-9788 ebarraza5@santa-ana.org -----Original Message ----- From: Norma Wilson < Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2019 8:25 PM To: City Council <CityCouncil@santa-ana.org> Subject: Appoint Phil Bacerra for Ward 41" Phil Bacerra is the best choice to fill this vacancy! He cares about Ward 4 and best yet, the entire city of Santa Ana. Dean Wilson Lopez, Kenia From: Paul Gonzales < Sent: Sunday, March 17, 2019 9:24 AM To: eComment Subject: Comments to Council for March 19 Meeting Attachments: Comments to Council 03-17-19.pdf Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Hello, Please ensure that the attached letter is submitted to members of the Council for consideration at the 4/19 meeting. Thank you, Paul Gonzales N March 17, 2019 To the Honorable Members of the Santa Ana City Council, On Tuesday, March 19, you will consider agenda item 65C—review of applicants for the vacant Ward 4 Council seat. The agenda includes two potential actions you might take. I am writing to encourage you to choose option 2b: convene a special meeting on another date prior to April 1. With the appointment of an individual to the Ward 4 seat, the Council has an opportunity to turn the page on a painful and embarrassing chapter of our City's history. The residents of Santa Ana deserve to be represented by an honorable leader who demonstrates integrity and a people -centered approach to leadership. Although neither of the candidates we had to choose from in the 2018 Ward 4 election demonstrated these characteristics, we now have the chance to correct that and ensure that the Ward 4 seat is occupied by a leader of strong character. The people of Santa Ana also deserve the opportunity to weigh in on who should represent them. If it pushes the decision to appoint an individual to the Ward 4 seat to a later date, the Council will demonstrate good faith to the community by allowing residents more time to get to know the six individuals who have submitted applications for this appointment. This extra time will make it possible for residents and community groups to assess the candidates' backgrounds, qualifications, and histories of service to the community in order to make well-informed recommendations to Councilmembers with respect to whom they should appoint. As Santa Ana's elected officials, you have an obligation to act in a manner that is aligned with the needs and values of the community you serve. To do so in this situation requires that you commit to a transparent appointment process that welcomes and honors input from your constituents. Accordingly, a decision to delay the appointment in order to allow more time to make this important decision will demonstrate your commitment to the people of Santa Ana. Thank you, _V1Z Paul Gonzales Santa Ana Resident Lopez, Kenia From: Ken Nguyen < Sent: Sunday, March 17, 2019 4:30 PM To: eComment; City Council Subject: Letter to Mayor and Council Members of Santa Ana Attachments: Letter of Support to Ken Nguyen.PDF Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Please forward the attached letter to Mayor and Council Members of Santa Ana. Thank you, Vietnamese Interfaith Council in America R VIETNAMESE INTERFAITH COUNCIL IN AMERICA HOT f)6NG ITN TON VITT NAM TAT HOA ;I 2114 W. McFadden Ave, Santa Ana, CA. 92704 March 17, 2019 Honorable Mayor Pulido and Council Members City of Santa Ana 20 Civic Center Plaza Santa Ana, CA. 92701 Dear Mayor and Council Members: The Vietnamese Interfaith Council in America consists of Vietnamese spiritual leaders of Buddhist, Cao Dai, Catholic, Christian, Hoa Hao and Orthodox religions in the United States, Our missions are to promote cooperation; and respect amongst people of various religions, to encourage people of all faiths to work together for mutual understanding, to help protect religious freedom, to celebrate faith traditions, and to be advocates for justice. Vietnamese Interfaith Council in America is proud to support to Ken Khanh Nguyen for appointment to to the Santa Ana City Council representing Ward 4, Ken Nguyen has continually been a highly regarded and respected leader in the Vietnamese - American community for over 40 years. Ken Nguyen is a compassionate and caring individual who has given an enormous amount of time and effort in volunteer services, It is credit to his selfless service and positive role in the community that he was appointed as the External Affairs Officer on the Vietnamese Interfaith Council in America in 2014, He is the only layperson who serves on the council and has been an integral partner for community events and outreach, Ken Nguyen effectively bridges the gap between different organizations, advocates for people in the community and would be an asset to any organization he serves, It is therefore with great confidence that we strongly support a vote of approval to appoint Ken Nguyen to serve the residents of Santa Ana by representing Ward 4 on the City Council, Sincerely, Professor Giau a h Nguyen Chairman Lopez, Kenia From: Barraza, Eric Sent: Tuesday, March 19, 2019 12:33 PM To: Subject: RE: Petition for Phil Bacerra Hello Connie, On behalf of the Mayor and City Council, thank you for submitting your comments. I have forwarded your petition along with the relevant documents to the appropriate staff for review. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions. Best Regards, Eric Barraza I Management Intern City Manager's Office City of Santa Ana 20 Civic Center Plaza Santa Ana, CA 92701 Direct(714) 640-9788 ebarraza5@santa-ana.org -----Original Message ----- From: Connie Hamilton < Sent: Tuesday, March 19, 2019 11:51 AM To: Mitre -Ramirez, Norma <NMitre-Ramirez@santa-ana.org> Cc: City Council <CityCouncil@santa-ana.org> Subject: Petition for Phil Bacerra Norma, I am attaching the paperwork regarding the petition asking that our council members appoint Phil Bacerra to the Ward 4 Council position. I understand this matter will be discussed at this evening's city council meeting. Here is the link to the petition: https://www.ch a nge. o rg/p/citycou nci I-sa nta-a n a -o rg-sa nta-a na-city-cou n ci I -appoint -ph i I-bace rra-for-wa rd- 4?recruiter=720939680&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=copylink&utm_campaign=sha re_petition&utm_ter m=share_petition On the attached signature sheet, some of the home cities of the petition signers got a bit skewed. My husband's home city, for example, shows as "Costa Mesa", which is not correct.:-) Thanks, Connie change,,org Recipient: Letter: Keeping Santa Ana Safe citycouncil@santa-ana.org , mpuiido@santa-ana,org, vsarmiento@santa-ana.org , dpenaloza@santa-ana.or9. , jSolorio@santa-ana.org , ivillegas@santa-ana,org , ciglesias@santa-ana,or9. Greetings, Santa Ana City Council: Appoint Phil Bacerra for Ward 4! Comments Name Location Date Comment Connie Hamilton US 2019-02-25 Phil has always been available to help the residents with their issues and certainly has my vote of confidence. Art Pedroza Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 Appointing Phil to replace Roman is the right thing to do! bobi keenan santa ana, CA 2019-03-04 I live in Ward 4 and want representation on the City Council without delay. I am opposed to the City of Santa Ana spending our limited funds on a special election. The people of Santa Ana were wronged by Roman Reyna's fraudulent registration to run and by his spurious campaign tactics. Make this wrong right by appointing Phil Bacerra to represent Ward 41 David Jirik Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 I voted for Phil and was dismayed at the large amount of money spent on the slur tactics against him in the election. I think he's a voice of reason that the City Council needs desperately Tom Lutz Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 Tom Lutz Wendy Nuval Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-07 Thank you all for your support of Phil! We are so grateful and humbled by it. Jeffrey Dickman Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 I have known Phil for many years and he does have the experience and knowledge to serve as Ward 4 Council person.Phil is accessible, easy to speak with and versed in the business of the city. I trust him to remain objective and focused on the needs of the community.We need more open space and linear recreation, an updated General Plan, and growth which protects neighborhoods from negative impacts.I really don't see anyone else better suited for the Ward 4 seat than Phil Bacerra. David De Leon Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Phil would instantly become one of the most knowledgeable representatives at city council with this appointment. Julie Chay Tustin, CA 2019-03-12 Phil is the logical choice to fill the vacant seat. And the best choice for Santa Ana. It's my second home as an active member of the Church of the Messiah. Jon Gothold Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 I believe that the damaging things that were said about Phil during the campaign were false, and politically motivated. Ithink Phil truly does have what's best for Santa Ana as his top priority. Norma Roberts Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-14 Phil is a good person for the job. He is bright, earnest, honest, and Wilson professional; eager to serve the people of Santa Ana. Ann Thompson Santa Ana, US 2019-03-17 I'm for Phil being immediately appointed to this position. Timothy Rush Cerritos, CA 2019-03-18 He is absolutely the very best qualified applicant. Not to mention he would be seated already but for the illegal candidacy of Mr. Reyna. PETITION Santa Ana City Council: Appoint Phil Bacerra for Ward 4! Phil Bacerra has been a Ward 4 resident for years and was the first to declare his Ward 4 candidacy intentions back in December of 2017. No other contender declared candidacy for this position until the last minute . The one person who ran against him filed his candidacy at the last minute and did so by fraudulent registration. This contender then proceeded to run a campaign of slur tactics against his opponent, Phil Bacerra, in the final stages of the election and barely edged a victory. Through a court order, he was required to tend his resignation and vacate this Ward 4 council seat, due to his fraudulent registration activity. We feel that since Phil ran a respectful campaign and had endorsements from many of the residents, past council members, planning and board commissioners (as well as receiving 44% of the vote) it would be most efficient to simply appoint him to this council seat and avoid holding an expensive, special election. We encourage you to do the right thing and appoint Phil Bacerra to the Ward 4 Council position for Santa Ana. Thank you. The residents below support the appointment of Phil Bacerra to the Santa Ana Ward 4 Council position: ' kc TUR UANE ADDRESS ! FMAI s I� rg-t �iR- C V F,e �L41.4 � I change,,org Recipient: Letter: Keeping Santa Ana Safe citycouncil@santa-ana.org , mpuiido@santa-ana,org, vsarmiento@santa-ana.org , dpenaloza@santa-ana.or9. , jSolorio@santa-ana.org , ivillegas@santa-ana,org , ciglesias@santa-ana,or9. Greetings, Santa Ana City Council: Appoint Phil Bacerra for Ward 4! Signatures Name Location Date Connie Hamilton us 2019-02-25 darrell hamilton Costa Mesa, CA 2019-02-26 Laura chapman Santa Ana, CA 2019-02-27 Miros Gonzalez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-02 Nancy Murphy Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 2019-03-02 Shaun Abbott Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-02 Jeff Bickel Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-02 Carl Overmyer Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-03 Anne Oostdyk Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-03 Patrick Murphy Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-03 Art Pedroza Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 bobi keenan santa ana, CA 2019-03-04 David Jirik Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 Tom Lutz Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 Don Harvey Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-04 Jeff Qualey Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-05 Carl Benninger Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-05 Sylvia Salenius Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-06 Marisela Gomez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-06 Ignacio Rincon us 2019-03-06 Name Location Date Javier Garcia Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-06 Cathy Godoy Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-06 Karina Espinoza Garden Grove, CA 2019-03-06 Carol Frank Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-06 Wendy Bacerra Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-07 Nio Lindsey Huntington Beach, CA 2019-03-07 robert mccalla Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 Alan Scales Irvine, CA 2019-03-11 Jeffrey Dickman Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 dee tucker Laguna Woods, US 2019-03-11 Kurt Kurtti Irvine, CA 2019-03-11 Phil Schaefer Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 Irma Jauregui Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 Victoria Betancourt Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 Cherie Kerr Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 Dale Helvig Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-11 David Leon 501 N Main St, CA 2019-03-11 Norma Wilson Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Brandon Turonek SANTA ANA, CA 2019-03-12 Jennifer Schutza Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 David De Leon Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Alejandro Haro Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Name Location Date Philippa Turonek Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 �o oJi €-s US 2019-03-12 Louise Belley Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Margaret Santos Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Joline Martin Santa Ana, US 2019-03-12 Agustin De la Riva Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Ruby Woo Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Winifred Troy Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Davin Gumm Long Beach, US 2019-03-12 Griselda Gonzalez Los Angeles, CA 2019-03-12 Fortino Rivera Pasadena, CA 2019-03-12 Monica Moralez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 AURORA IBARRA Anaheim, CA 2019-03-12 Connor Deley Secaucus, US 2019-03-12 Julie Chay Tustin, CA 2019-03-12 L Borik Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Dori Estabrook Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Danielle Swindell Elizabeth, US 2019-03-12 Vincent Conde Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-12 Cesar Macias Portland, US 2019-03-13 Sydnee Fark Arvada, US 2019-03-13 Larry Hitterdale Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Name Location Date Albert Cortes Santa ana, CA 2019-03-13 Berenice Ballinas Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Scott Ostlund Santa ana, CA 2019-03-13 Norm Fisher Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Jeff Smith Ontario, CA 2019-03-13 Rose Dennis Murrieta, CA 2019-03-13 Laura T. Garcia Santa Ana, US 2019-03-13 Lorraine Le Stephens North Tustin, CA 2019-03-13 Jeff Katz Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Jamison Power Westminster, CA 2019-03-13 Jeffrey Kaas Cedar Rapids, US 2019-03-13 Nicole Sanchez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Malak Mahmoud Medford, US 2019-03-13 roxanne litow Portland, US 2019-03-13 Deepa Deshatty San Diego, US 2019-03-13 Barbara Moore Costa Mesa, CA 2019-03-13 Jon Gothold Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Melvin Steiner Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-13 Debbie McEwen Sherman Oaks, CA 2019-03-14 Raul Quinonez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-14 Amborski Amborski Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-14 Adam Trinidad Azusa, CA 2019-03-14 Name Location Date Pat Trinidad Santa Ana, US 2019-03-14 Jasmine Trinidad Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-15 Connie Major Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-15 Eric Figueroa Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-15 Jean Poppa Los Angeles, CA 2019-03-15 Desi Reyes Los Angeles, CA 2019-03-15 sandra albear Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 MIchael Kanter Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 Lisa Tran Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 Susan Salvati Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 Brett Atkins Santa Ana, US 2019-03-16 Martha Moriel-Quinonez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 James Marlin Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 EvelynkayOceguera Anaheim, CA 2019-03-16 Adrienne Flynn Santa ana, CA 2019-03-16 Ginell Laske Orange, CA 2019-03-16 Pete Major Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-16 Monica Horner Huntington Beach, CA 2019-03-16 Ann Thompson Santa Ana, US 2019-03-17 Carolyn Hoerling Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Benjamin Nation Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Felice Ip Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Name Location Date Daniela Sanchez Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Sharon Casares Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Citlaly Emigdio Los Angeles, US 2019-03-17 Trinh Le Santa Ana, US 2019-03-17 Elizabeth Perez Garden Grove, CA 2019-03-17 Donna Lewis Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Susan Rich Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Shagufta Kashif Sammamish, WA 2019-03-17 trinette shelton Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Carlos Aguirre Mexico, Mexico 2019-03-17 Lori Karaguezian Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-17 Tina Alaniz Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-18 hujb oubih Catonsville, US 2019-03-18 Adriana Viveros Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-18 Michael Christiansen Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-18 june evinger Covina, CA 2019-03-18 Timothy Rush Cerritos, CA 2019-03-18 James Kendrick Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-18 Grant Beattie Santa Ana, CA 2019-03-19 Nhan Truong Santa ana, CA 2019-03-19 twoiTy of WeSTm nsTer Mayor Tri Ta March 18c', 2019 a Honorable Mavor and Council Members City of Santa Ana 20 Civic Center Plaza a Santa Ana, CA. 92701 Dear Mayor Polido and Council Members: 1 would like to express my support to Ken Khanh Nguyen to be appointed to the Santa Ana City Council representing Ward 4. Ken is one of the unique community leaders that put his people first before himself. He is a selfless man who quietly engages in a diverse cross-section of our society, always trying to improve the lives of the community members. His efforts have helped Little Saigon to flourish and become an educational and cultural asset to the County. lie led important projects in the City of Westminster such as the Vietnam War Memorial and the Little Saigon Business District Monument signs. In addition, he has helped organizing many annual public events such as the Christmas Wish Program, the Tet Parade, the Moon Festival and many others as part of his goal to build a multicultural county to promote cultural awareness and togetherness. Ken has a significant and sustained influence through his non -biased, positively focused interest in the community's needs. He has made significant inroads within city and county government, opening lines of communication necessary for the growth and success of the City. Ken's contributions to the City of Westminster have been greatly appreciated, and we are confident that his efforts and expertise would benefit other cities as well. Therefore, we strongly encourage you to vote to appoint Ken Nguyen to serve on the Santa Ana City Council representing Ward 4. Sincerely, Tri Ta Mayor 8200 Westminster Boulevard ^ Westminster, California 92683 !I phone (714) 366.0376 Office (714) 548.3172 Email TTa@westminster-ca.gov Orozco, Norma From: bobi keenan < Sent: Tuesday, March 19, 2019 3:25 PM To: eComment; Orozco, Norma Subject: Appoint Phil Bacerra as Councilman of the 4th Ward I will not be able to attend the meeting tonight due to illness. I hope the Council will decide to fill the 4th Ward Council Seat by appointing Phil Bacerra and save us the cost of a special election. Even if it were scheduled at the next regular election, there would still be unnecessary tax monies spent. More importantly, it would leave a significant population in our City unrepresented for a long time. This is a no-brainer. Please Seat Phil Bacerra and lets get on with the business of the City. Thank you. bobikeenan RA Orozco, Norma From: Dean And Norma Wilson < Sent: Thursday, March 21, 2019 12:47 PM To: eComment Subject: Appointing Phil Bacerra to fill the vacancy on the city Council. Please appoint Phil Bacerra to the vacancy. Thank you Sent from my iPhone I Mitre -Ramirez, Norma From: Sent: Friday, March 22, 2019 12:45 PM To: Solorio, Jose; Villegas, Juan; Pulido, Miguel; Iglesias, Cecilia; Sarmiento, Vicente; Penaloza, David Cc: City Council; Mitre -Ramirez, Norma Subject: Ward 4 #NeverPhil Importance: High Greetings Mayor, Mayor Pro -Tem & Council I felt it important that I email you regarding your appointment for Ward 4 City Councilmember. 15C I believe that you should seriously consider doing a special election and partner with SAUSD. This would just make sense and you can split the cost of the special election with them. 2nd the appointment of the next council member please DO NOT consider Phil Becerra! The accusation of his abuse to his formal girlfriend, are true. There was no conspiracy on getting the message out about his character. When Griselda de Santos, approached me with her concerns of him running, she was in pain of seeing his signs posted everywhere. Seeing his signs brought back the abuse she endured and triggered all those feelings anger, hurt & fear. We did the only thing we could and that was share his abuse and behavior on social media. We felt it was the only way to get the message out and it worked. If someone picked it up and used the information to send political campaign material, that is on them, not Griselda. However the truth got out and that is WHY he lost the campaign. It's truly a shame that Roman Reyna did what he did, but please don't punish the constituents by appointing a known abuser. I know all of you believe in nonviolence and are against domestic violence. Some of you even belong to organizations, helping women who have been abused. Some of you, if not all of you know women, who have been abused and you know that these feelings are real It take years to get over the trauma, if she ever gets over it, PTSD is real! Please appoint with your conscience and what is best for Santa Ana. #NEVERPHIL #IBELIEVEHER Thank You Tish Leon U Mitre -Ramirez, Norma From: David Hastie < Sent: Friday, March 22, 2019 3:49 PM To: eComment Subject: Ward 4 City Council Vacancy Item 65C Good Afternoon, I am writing to voice my support for the only logical choice to fill the Ward 4 City Council vacancy, Phil Bacerra. Had Mr. Reyna not been on the ballot, as it has been proven he was not qualified for, I believe Mr. Bacerra would have won the November election. He is qualified and a dedicated member of the Santa Ana community. I have known Mr. Bacerra personally and professionally for over 10 years. As a partner and manager of Memphis at the Santora and as a member of Downtown, Ines Marketing Committee, I had many opportunities to discuss Santa Ana's development and business climate with Mr. Bacerra. He knows how to balance the needs of business owners, residents, developers, and governments. His skills and intelligence would be an asset to the council. As a resident of Santa Ana, I am concerned that proceeding toward a special election would be expensive and a strain on our city's already fragile budget. Please appoint a council member this evening. Please appoint Phil Bacerra--the only logical choice. Thank you, David Hastie `9j