HomeMy WebLinkAboutNS-1710 - Amending Santa Ana Municipal Code by Adding Section 36-43 Thereto Prohibiting Commercial Advertising Noise on Public Streets ...EJC:mb
12/07/83
ORDINANCE NO., NS- 1710
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SANTA ANA
AMENDING THE SANTA ANA MUNICIPAL CODE
BY ADDING SECTION 36-43 THERETO PRO-
HIBITING COMMERCIAL ADVERTISING NOISE
ON PUBLIC STREETS AND ADDING ARTICLE X
TO CHAPTER 36, CONSISTING OF SECTIONS
36-450 THROUGH 36-464 INCLUSIVE, REGU-
LATING THE OPERATION OF ICE CREAM TRUCKS.
THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA ANA DOES
ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1: That the Santa Ana Municipal Code is
hereby amended by adding a section, to be numbered 36-43,
which said section reads as follows:
Sec. 36-43. Amplification devices.
No driver of a vehicle shall operate or permit
operation of any radio system, loudspeaker, ~o~ other noise
device intended to make sound audible outside the vehicle
when the vehicle is ~being operated upon a~y street and the
purpose of such sound is to advertise for commercial purposes.
SECTION 2: The City Council finds and determines
that commercial vehicles operating on city streets with sound
amplifying equipment which produces sound audible outside
such vehicles are detrimental to the public health, welfare
and safety.
SECTION 3: That the Santa Ana Municipal Code
is hereby amended by adding Article X to Chapter 36, which
article shall read as follows:
ARTICLE X.
ICE CREAM TRUCKS
Sec. 36-450. Ice Cream Trucks; purpose and intent.
The City Council expressly finds that vehicles in
which ice cream, confections and other frozen dessert products
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page two
are carried for purposes of retail sale on the public streets
pose special dangers to the public health, safety and welfare
of children and residents in the City of Santa Ana. It is
the purpose and intent of the City Council, in enacting this
article, to provide responsible companies and individuals
who engage in the operation of ice cream trucks with clear
and concise regulations to prevent safety, traffic and
health hazards, as well as to preserve the peace, safety and
welfare of the community.
Sec. 36-451. Definitions.
As used in this article:
(a) Ice Cream Truck means any vehicle, as that
term is defined in the California Vehicle Code, which is
equipped or primarily used for retail sales on any public
street, alley or highway within the City of Santa Ana of ice
cream, ice milk, popsicles, sherbets, frozen yogurt, frozen
dessert products and confections of any kind. The inventory
of these vehicles is not necessarily limited to ice cream,
confections or frozen dessert products.
(b) Frozen Dessert Product includes ice cream,
ice milk, popsicles, frozen yogurt, confections and chilled
desserts of any kind.
(c) Person means any natural person, firm,
partnership, association, corporation, stockholder and
includes, but is not limited to, owners, operators, drivers,
lessors and lessees of ice cream trucks.
(d) Vend or Vending means offering frozen dessert
products of any kind for sale from a motor vehicle on a
street, alley, highway or public place within the City of
Santa Ana and includes the movement or standing of an ice
cream truck for the purpose of searching for, obtaining or
soliciting retail sales of frozen dessert products.
(e) Ice Cream Vendor shall mean any person, as
defined in this article, who (1) conducts or permits or
causes the operation of ice cream trucks; (2) owns, operates,
controls, manages or leases ice cream trucks; ~or (3) contracts
with persons to drive and vend from ice cream trucks.
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page three
(f) Operator shall mean any person who drives,
operates or vends from an ice cream truck and shall include
the driver and assistant on each ice cream truck.
(g) Vendor's Permit shall mean a permit issued by
the City of Santa Ana authorizing the holder thereof to
engage in the business of ice cream vending.
(h) Operator's Permit shall mean the permit
issued to any person who drives or operates an ice cream
truck, vends, sells or assists in selling products from an
ice cream truck.
(i) Safety Inspection Sticker shall mean a sticker
affixed to an ice cream truck evidencing that it has been
inspected by the Santa Ana Police Department and found to be
in safe operating condition.
Sec. 36-452. PERMIT REQUIRED
(a) No person shall operate or cause the operation
of an ice cream truck in the City of Santa Ana without a
vendor's permit issued pursuant to the provision of this
article and any othe~ license.or permit required under any
other chapter of this code for each and every ice cream
truck.
(b) No person shall drive or vend from any vehicle
defined as an ice cream truck in the City of Santa Ana
without an operator's permit issued pursuant to the provisions
of this article.
Sec. 36-453. PE~IT TERM AND RENEWAL
The term of vendor and operator permits, unless
sooner suspended or revoked, shall be for a period of one
(1) year. Upon the expiration of such term, the permittee
may renew the permit for additional one (1) year terms by
submitting new applications in conformance with sections 36-
454 and 36-455 together with such permit renewal fee as may
be established by resolution of the City Council.
Sec. 36-454.
APPLICATION FOR ICE CREAM VENDOR
PERMIT; CONTENTS; REQUIRED FEE.
(a) Any person desiring to obtain a permit to
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page four
operate or cause the operation of one or more ice cream
trucks shall make application to the chief of police or his
designated representative. Prior to submitting such appli-
cation a nonrefundable fee, as established by resolution of
the City Council, shall be paid to the department of finance
to defray, in part, the cost of the investigation and report
required by this article. The department of finance shall
issue a receipt showing that such application fee has been
paid. The receipt, or a copy thereof, shall be supplied to
the chief of police at the time such application is filed.
Permit issuance fees required under this article shall be in
addition to any license, permit or fee requi~r~d under any
other chapter of this Code.
(b) Neither the filing of an application for a
permit, nor tke payment of an application fee, shall authorize
the vending from, operation or management of an ice cream
truck until such permit has been granted or renewed.
(c) Each applicant for a permit to conduct business
as an ice cream vendor shall furnish the following information:
(1) The present or proposed address from
which the business is to be conducted;
(2) The full true name under which the
business will be conducted;
(3) The full true name and any other names
used by the applicant;
(4) The present residence and business
addresses and telephone numbers of the applicant;
(5) A description of the merchandise which
the ice cream trucks will vend;
(6) The number of vehicles to be owned,
operated or controlled by the applicant and the makes, body
styles, years, serial and engine numbers, state license
plate numbers, and names and addresses of the registered
and/or legal owners of each vehicle;
(7) A description of the logo, color scheme,
insignia, and any other distinguishing characteristics of
applicant's vehicles;
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page five
(8) A policy of insurance in the manner and
form required by this article from a responsible, solvent
insurance carrier authorized to issue public liability and
property damage insurance in the State of California;
(9) The full true names and residence addresses
of all persons employed or intended.to.be employed or with
whom the applicant has contracted or intends to contract as
drivers, operators or attendants;
(10) Certification, from the Santa Ana Police
Department, evidencing that each and every ice cream truck
to be owned, operated or controlled by the applicant has,
within two months prior to the date the applicaton is received
by the Chief of Police, passed a safety inspection and is
eligible for the issuance of a safety inspection sticker.
(11) The applicant, if an individual; or each
of the directors, officers or stockholders holding more than
five percent (5%) of the stock of the corporation; or each
of the partners, including limited partners, or profit
interest holders, managers or other persons principally in
charge of the operation of the existing or proposed business
of vending from ice cream trucks, shall also furnish the
following information:
((a)) California driver's license or identification
number of the above-described natural persons;
((b)) Date of birth of the above-described
natural person;
((c)) The permit history of the above-described
natural persons for the three-year period immediately
preceding the date of the filing of the application,
including whether such person, in previously
operating in this or any other city, county, state
or territory, has ever had any similar license or
permit, or franchise revoked or suspended, and if
so, the circumstances of such suspension or revocation;
((d)) Ail criminal convictions suffered by the
above-described natural persons, including ordinance
violations, but excepting minor traffic offenses
(any traffic offense designated as a felony shall
not be construed as a minor traffic offense),
stating the date, place, nature and sentence of
each such conviction;
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page six
(12) The applicant, if other than an in-
dividual, shall also furnish the following information:
((a)) Each business address of the applicant
for the three-year period immediately preceding
the date of the applicatio~ and' the inclusive
dates of each such business;
((b)) The nature of the business or firm for
the three-year period immediately preceding the
date of the application;
((c)) The permit history of the applicant for
the three-year period immediately preceding the
date of the filing of the application, including
whether such applicant, in previously operating in
this or any other city, county, state or territory,
has ever had any similar license or permit, or
franchise revoked or suspended, and if so, the
circumstances of such suspension or revocation;
((d)) Ail criminal convictions suffered by the
applicant including ordinance violations, stating
the date, place, nature and sentence of each such
conviction;
(13) Such other identification and/or information
as the chief of police or his designated representative may
require in order to discover the truth the matters required
to be set forth in the application.
(d) The applicant, if a natural person or, if
the applicant is a partnership or corporation, the
designated responsible managing officer, shall
personally appear at the police department of the
City of Santa Ana and produce proof that the
required application fee has been paid and shall
present the application containing the information
and supporting documentation required by subsection
(c) of this section;
(e) When any change occurs regarding the written
information required by subsection c of this
section prior to or after issuance of a permit,
the applicant shall give written notification of
such change to the chief of police within two
weeks after such change;
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page seven
Sec. 36-455.
APPLICATION FOR OPERATOR'S
PERMIT; CONTENTS; REQUIRED FEE
(a) Any person desiring to obtain an operator's
permit for an ice cream truck shall make application to the
chief of police or his designated representative. Prior to
submitting such application a nonrefundable fee, as established
by resolution of the City Council, shall be paid to the
department of finance to defray, in part, the cost of the
investigation and report required by this article. The
department of finance shall issue a receipt showing that
such application fee has been paid. The receipt, or a copy
thereof, shall be supplied to the chief of police at the
time such application is filed. Permit issuance fees required
under this article shall be in addition to any license,
permit or fee required under any other chapter of this Code.
(b) Neither the filing of an application for a
permit, nor the payment of an application fee, shall authorize
the vending from or operation or management of an ice cream
truck until such permit has been granted or renewed.
(c) Each applicant for an operator's permit shall
furnish the following information:
(1) The present or proposed address from
which the business is to be conducted;
(2) The full true name under which the
business will be conducted;
(3) The full true name and any other
names used by the applicant;
(4) The present residence address and
telephone number of the applicant;
(5) California driver's license number of
the applicant;
(6) Acceptable written proof that the
applicant is at least eighteen (18) years of age;
(7) The applicant's h~ight, weight, color
of eyes and hair, and date of birth;
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page eight
(8) Two (2) photographs of the applicant,
at least two (2) inches by two (2) inches in size,
taken within the six-month period immediately
preceding the date of the application;
(9~) The business, occupation or employment
history of the applicant for the three-year period
immediately preceding the date of the application;
(10) The permit history of the applicant,
for the three-year period immediately preceding
the date of the filing of the application, including
whether such applicant, in previously operating in
this or any other city, county, state or territory,
has ever had any similar license or permit, or
franchise revoked or suspended, and if so, the
circumstances of such suspension or revocation;
(11) Ail criminal convictions suffered by
the applicant, including ordinance violations, and
traffic offenses;
(12) Acceptable written proof that the
applicant is insured under a policy of insurance
in the manner and form required by this article
from a responsible, solvent insurance carrier
authorized to issue public liability and property
damage insurance in the State of California;
(13) Certification from the Santa Ana
Police Department that the applicant has successfully
completed, within two months of the date the
application is received by the Chief of Police, a
special training course in traffic safety, based
upon a curriculum devised and carried out by the
Santa Ana Police Department;
(14) Such other identification and/or
information as the Chief of Police or his designated
representative may require in order to discover
the truth of the matters required to be set forth
in the application;
(d) The applicant shall personally appear
at the police department of the City of Santa Ana
and produce proof that the required application
ORDINANCE NO NS-1710
Page nine
fee has been paid and shall present the application
containing the information and supporting docu-
mentation required by subsection (d) of this
section.
(e) When any change occurs regarding the written
information required by subsection (d) of this
section prior to or after issuance of a permit,
the applicant shall give written notification of
such change to the chief of police within two
weeks after such change.
(f) If the applicant is an individual who intends
to own, operate and drive his or her own ice cream truck, it
is not necessary to pay a separate fee for the operator's
permit application.
Sec. 36-456. INVESTIGATION OF APPLICATIONS
The chief of police shall have a reasonable
period of time in which-ho investigate the appli-
cation and background of the applicant for a
vendor's permit or an ,operator's permit. The
chief of police, or his representative, shall,
within thirty (30) days after the date of the
filing of the application, render a written
recommendation to the city manager, as to approval
or denial of the application for the permit or
renewal thereof.
Sec. 36-457. ISSUANCE OF PERMIT
The city manager, within ten (10) days after
receiving the application and aforementioned
recommendation from the chief of police, shall
grant the vendor's permit or operator's permit
only if he finds that all of the following
requirements have been met:
(a) The required fees have been paid;
(b) The application conforms in all respects
to the provisions of this chapter;
(c) The applicant has not knowingly made
a material misrepresentation of fact in the
application;
ORDINANCE NO.
Page ten
NS- 1710
(d) The applicant has fully cooperated
in the investigation of the application;
(e) The applicant if an individual; or
any of the directors, officers or stockholders
holding more than five percent (5%) of the stock
of the corporation; or any of the partners, including
limited partners, or profit interest holder,
manager or other person principally in charge of
the operation of the existing or proposed business
of vending from an ice cream truck or a natural
person employed or contracted with to be a driver
has not been convicted or pleaded nolo contendere
or guilty within five (5) years prior to his
application for a permit to a misdemeanor or
felony crime of moral turpitude or drug-related
misdemeanor or felony crime, including but not
limited to: the sale of a controlled substance
specified in California Health Safety Code ~
11054 through 11058; the sale, distribution or
display of harmful or obscene matter; indecent
exposure; selling or disposing of lottery tickets;
permitting gambling, pool selling or bookmaking;
or in the case of applications for an operator's
permit, alcohol or drug-related traffic offenses.
The investigating city employee is specifically
authorized to obtain state summary criminal history
record information as provided for in section
11105 of the California Penal Code. Any complaint
for the above-listed charges pending before a
court of law shall cause the application to be
considered pending until adjudication of the
complaint.
Sec. 36-458. DENIAL OF PERMIT
(a) If the city manager does not find that all
of the requirements set forth in Sections 36-
454(c) or 36-455(c) have been met, he shall deny
the application for vendor's or operator's permit.
In the event the application for the permit is
denied by the city manager, written notice of such
denial shall be given to the applicant specifying
the ground or grounds of such denial. Notice of
denial of the application for the permit shall be
deemed to have been served if it in fact is personally
ORDINANCE NO. NS-1710
Page eleven
served on the applicant or when deposited in the
United States mail with postage prepaid and addressed
to the applicant at his or her residence address
as set forth in the application for the permit.
(b) Any applicant whose application for an ice
cream vendor or operator's permit has been denied
by the City Manager may appeal such denial to the
City Manager, as provided by Chapter 3 of this
Code.
Sec. 36-459. REVOCATION OF PERMIT.
(a) Any vendor's or operator's permit may be
suspended or revoked by the City Manager or his designated
representative for any of the following reasons:
(1) Falsehood of any information supplied
by the permittee upon which issuance of the permit
was based;
(2) Failure of the permittee to notify
the Chief of Police within two (2) weeks, of any
change occurring subsequent to the issuance of the
permit in the information supplied by the permittee
upon which issuance of the permit was based;
(3) Failure of the permittee, or of any
employees or subcontractors of the permittee, to
comply with the regulations set forth in sections
36-457 through 36-463, inclusive;
(4) Violation by the permittee, or any
employee, subcontractor or independent contractor
of the permittee, of any state law or municipal
ordinance while in the course of conducting vending
operations from ice cream truck pursuant to the
permit.
(5) Violation by the permittee of any offense
set forth in section 36-457(c).
ORDINANCE NO. NS-1710
Page twelve
(b) No such suspension or revocation shall become
effective until the permit holder has been notified in
writing of the right of such permit holder to appeal the
suspension or revocation pursuant to the provisions of
Chapter 3 of this Code. Notification of the permit holder
shall be made either by personal delivery or by certified or
registered mail, return receipt requested, addressed to the
permit holder at such permit holder's residence address as
set forth on the application for a permit. If a timely
appeal is filed, the suspension or revocation shall be
stayed and shall become effective only upon decision of the
City Council. Otherwise the suspension or revocation shall
become effective after the timely appeal period has expired.
(c) No person whose permit is revoked shall be
eligible to apply for a new permit for a period of one (1)
year following such revocation.
Sec. 36-457. ICE CREAM TRUCK REGULATIONS.
(a) Each ice cream truck shall have a current,
valid County of Orange health inspection sticker affixed to
the lower right side of the windshield and a current, valid
Santa Ana Police Department inspection sticker affixed to
the left side of the rear of the ice cream truck.
(b) Each individual who drives, operates or vends
from an ice cream truck shall have on his person a current,
valid California Driver's License, which he shall make
available for inspection by law enforcement officials upon
request.
(c) Each operator's permit holder shall be issued
an identification card which will also serve as the operator's
permit. The permit holder shall wear or carry such card in
a visible position upon his or her person at all times while
vending from an ice cream truck, and shall produce the same
for inspection upon request. Each permit holder shall
immediately surrender to the Chief of Police any operator's
permit issued by the City of Santa Ana upon the suspension,
revocation or expiration of such permit or upon leaving
employment as an ice cream truck operator.
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page thirteen
Sec. 36-458. PROHIBITED CONDUCT.
(a) No person shall vend from an ice cream truck
which is stopped, parked or standing on any public street,
alley or highway:
(1) Within five hundred (500) feet
of any school property, park, playground or
recreational facility;
(2) When the posted speed limit on the
public street, alley or highway is thirty-five
(35) miles per hour or greater;
(3) When the ice cream truck is parked
in violation of any other provision of this Code,
including, but not limited to, Section 36-136(c),
or the California Vehicle Code;
(4) When any part of the ice cream truck
is open to prospective customers other than on the
side of the vehicle next to the right side of the
street, alley or highway;
(5) When the ice cream truck is not stopped,
parked or standing on the right side of the street,
alley or highway;
(6) When the prospective customer is standing
or sitting in another vehicle; or
(7) When the prospective customer is located
in that portion of the street, alley or highway
which is open to vehicular traffic.
(b) No person shall back an ice cream truck to
make or attempt a sale.
(c) No minor shall ride in or on an ice cream
truck.
(d) No more than two (2) individuals shall be in
or on a vending ice cream truck.
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page fourteen
Sec. 36-459. INSURANCE PROVISIONS.
(a) It shall be unlawful for any person to own,
lease, drive, operate or cause or permit to be driven or
operated any ice cream truck in the City of Santa Ana unless
such person has submitted with his application for permit a
motor vehicle liability insurance policy, covering each ice
cream truck, issued by a solvent corporation holding a
certificate of authority to do insurance business in the
State of California, which policy shall conform in all
respects to the requirements of this chapter.
(b) The required motor vehicle liability policy
shall insure the owner, driver, and any other person using
or responsible for the use of any ice cream truck with the
consent, expressed or implied, of such owner, driver or
person, against loss from the liability imposed upon such
owner, driver or person by law for injury to, or death of,
any person, or damage to property growing out of the maintenance,
operation or ownership of any ice cream truck in an amount
of one million dollars ($1,000,000.00), combined single
limit, no aggregate.
(c) Every insurance policy and every certificate
of motor vehicle liability insurance filed within the City
pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall contain the
following endorsements:
(1) It is hereby understood and agreed that,
notwithstanding expressions consistent with or
contrary thereto in this policy contained, the
policy is expressly issued to cover a motor
vehicle regulated by the provisions of Chapter 36,
article X of the Santa Ana Municipal Code. This
policy shall inure to, and be for the benefit and
protection of, anyone who shall sustain any damages
or injury, or to the heirs, personal representatives,
adminJ, strators, executors or assigns of any such
person who may be so damaged or injured or suffer
death, by reason of the operation of the motor
vehicle or from the defective condition thereof.
Liability under this policy shall in no manner be
abrogated or abated by the death or dissolution of
the feasor or the insured.
(2) There is continuing liability up to
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page fifteen
the full amount of the policy, notwithstanding any
action or recovery thereon.
(3) No cancellation or reduction in coverage
of this policy for any reason whatsoever shall
become effective until the expiration of thirty
(30) days after written notice of such cancellation
or reduction in coverage shall have been given to
the clerk of the council of the City of Santa Aha.
Said period of thirty (30) days to commence running
from the date said notice is actually received in
the office of the clerk of the council.
Sec. 36-460. INSPECTION OF ICE CREAM TRUCKS.
(a) Each ice cream truck for which a permit or
renewal is sought shall be inspected by the Santa Ana Police
Department to insure that the vehicle can be safely operated.
(b) In addition to other equipment required by
law, each ice cream truck shall be equipped with the following:
(1) A convex mirror mounted so that the
occupant of the driver's seat can see the area in
front of the truck which is obscured by the vehicle's
hood.
(2) A back-up alarm audible for a distance
of at least one hundred (100) feet.
Sec. 36-461. REQUIRED SIGNS AND LETTERING.
(a) There shall be displayed in a conspicuous
place on both the front and back of the ice cream truck
appropriate warning signs or lettering, e.g. "CAUTION CHILDREN."
The lettering shall not be less than six (6) inches in height
and the lettering shall be in contrast to the color of the
background upon which they are placed.
(b) There shall be displayed in a conspicuous
place on both the right and left side of the ice cream truck
lettering permanently affixed showing the name of the company
or operator of the ice cream truck and the business address
and telephone number of the owner or operator. The lettering
shall not be less than four (4) inches in height, and shall
be in contrast to the color of the background upon which
they are placed.
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page sixteen
(c) No other lettering, numbering, price lists,
signs or insignia shall be displayed on the right and left
side of the ice cream truck so as to interfere with the
visibility of the lettering required in subsection (b).
Sec. 36-462. NOISE LEVEL.
Ice cream vendors shall not operate any sound
device or music system when stopped, standing, or parked.
Sec. 36-463.
APPLICABILITY OF REGULATIONS TO
EXISTING BUSINESS.
The provisons of this article shall be applicable
to all persons and businesses described herein whether the
herein described activities were established before or after
the effective date of the ordinance enacting this article
into law. All such persons and businesses shall have thirty
(30) days from said effective date to file a completed
application for vendors' or operators' permits with the
chief of police or his designated representative.
Sec. 36-464. CONDUCTING AS A NUISANCE.
Any ice cream truck operated contrary to the
provisions of this article shall be and the same is hereby
declared to be unlawful and a public nuisance and the city
attorney may, in addition to or in lieu of prosecuting a
criminal action hereunder, commence an action or actions,
proceeding or proceedings, for the abatement, removal or
enjoinment thereof, in the manner provided by law, and may
take such other steps and may apply to such court or courts
as may have jurisdiction to grant such relief as will abate
or remove such establishment and restrain and enjoin any
person from operating an ice cream truck contrary to the
provisions of this Article.
SECTION 3: If any section, subsection, sentence,
clause, phrase or portion of this ordinance is for any
reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by the decision
of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall
not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this
ordinance. The City Council of the City of Santa Ana and
each declares that it would have adopted this ordinance and
each section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or portion
ORDINANCE NO. NS- 1710
Page seventeen
thereof irrespective of the fact that any one or more
sections, subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
portions be declared invalid or unconstitutional.
SECTION 4: Neither the adoption of this ordinance
nor the repeal hereby of any ordinance shall in any manner
affect the prosecution for violation of ordinances, which
violations were committed prior to the effective date hereof,
nor be construed as affecting any of the provisions of such
ordinance relating to the collection of any such license or
penalty or the penal provision applicable to any violation
thereof, nor to affect the validity of any bond or cash
deposit in lieu thereof, required to be posted, filed or
deposited pursuant to any ordinance and all rights and
obligations thereunder appertaining shall continue in full
force and effect.
ADOPTED this 3rd
ATTE S T:
day of- .January ,1984.
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
COUNCILMEMBERS:
Luxembourger Aye
Griset Aye
Acosta N~y
Bricken Aye
Johnson Aye
McGuigan Aye
Young Aye
CITY ATTORNI~f