Laserfiche WebLink
RECOMMENDATION: <br />RECOMMENDATION: <br />Adopt a resolution approving a Certificate of Appropriateness for Historic Exterior <br />Modification Application No. 2006-06. <br />Commissioner Seeley presided over the public hearing. Chairman Cook-Giles <br />and Commissioners Bustamante and Macres abstained. <br />Senior Planner Vince Fregoso presented the staff report and recommendation. <br />' Mr. Fregoso discussed the scope of the application with regard to the new entry <br />door on the primary elevation (west); secondary door on east (rear) elevation; <br />and third door on south (side) elevation; and the new windows (two) on the front <br />(north/west) elevation and second boarded-up on the east (rear) elevation The <br />new windows and doors were installed without benefit of a permit and are of a <br />Victorian style rather than Tudor Revival architecture as proposed by staff and <br />consistent with the Secretary of Interior Standards. <br />Mr. Fregoso noted that the applicant agreed to remove the current doors and <br />windows and replace them with appropriate doors and windows. <br />Commission commented that there should be a photograph of the original doors <br />to use as a guide for the new door. <br />The public hearing was opened. <br />Kristen Bjorklund Hunter voiced concern regarding the need to maintain the <br />residence's structural integrity and the desire for Tudor-style doors and windows. <br />The public hearing was closed. <br />MOTION: Continue the item to allow Ms. Hunter time to provide the Commission <br />with a photograph showing the original door/windows. <br />Mr. Trevino discussed concerns with the continuation of the item. Ms. Otto <br />recommended that historic consultant, Leslie Neumann determine the <br />appropriateness of replacement door, and then inform the Historic Commission <br />with a memorandum and a picture of the proposed doors. <br />Mr. Trevino stated that the doors/windows are not the defining character features <br />of the historical structure. Commission is reviewing the rehabilitation standards <br />of the structure. The timing issue could delay the applicant from obtaining <br />permits. <br />Commissioner Lutz expressed a desire to replicate the original door. <br />SUBSTITUTE MOTION: <br />Adopt a resolution approving a Certificate of Appropriateness for Historic <br />Exterior Application No. 2006-06 and directed staff to review proposed doors and <br />windows with consultant, Leslie Heumann. <br />MOTION: Macres SECOND: Lutz <br />' VOTE: AYES: Corpin, Lutz, Macres, O'Callaghan, Seeley (5) <br />NOES: None (0) <br />ABSENT: Schaefer (1) <br />ABSTAIN: Bustamante, Chinn, Cook-Giles (3) <br />4. Public Comments (items not on the agenda) <br />No comments were made. <br />Historic Resources Commission Minutes 5 September 7, 2006 <br />