CORRESPONDENCE - NON-AGENDA - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

R. Leonard, C.S.R., Inc. Certified Shorthand Reporters 818.995.2449 SHEET 10 PAGE 37 PAGE 39 09:45:13 1 THE WITNESS: NO, 09:45:13 1 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION, RELEVANCE, 09:45:13 2 MR, BISNO: COUNSEL, WHERE IS OR HOW IS WHERE IN 09:45:13 2 THE WITNESS: YES. 3 CALIFORNIA LIKELY TO LEAD TO RELEVANT EVIDENCE? 09:45:13 3 Q BY MR, RUBINER: FOLLOWING YOUR GRADUATION WHAT 09:45:13 4 MR. RUBINER: IT COULD LEAD "IO THE PLACE THAT HE 4 WAS YOUR FIRST FULL-TIME JOB? 5 T00K THE COURSE AT WHICH COULD LEAD TO EVIDENCE AS TO 09:45:13 5 A WORKING FOR A KAPLAN FAMILY IN THEIR REAL 6 THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THE COURSE WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT BE 6 ESTATE BUSINESS. 7 RELEVANT TO THE REAL ESTATE TRANSACTIONS INVOLVED IN 09:45:13 7 0 WHERE WAS THAT? 8 THIS CASE TO WHICH YOUR CLIENT CLAIMS TO BE AA EXPERT. 09:15:13 8 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 09:45:13 9 MR. BISNO: DESPITE MY OBJECTION, HE'S ANSWERED 09:45:13 9 THE WITNESS: LOS ANGELES. 10 YOUR QUESTION. 09:45:13 10 Q BY MR, RUBINER: YOU SAID YOU WORKED FOR THE 09:11:13 11 Q BY MR. RUBINER: ARE YOU A MEMBER OF ANY 11 EAPLAN FAMILY. IS THERE A PARTICULAR ENTITY YOU WORKED 12 PROFESSIONAL SOCIETIES CONCERNING REAL ESTATE? 12 FOR? 09:15:13 13 A NO. 09:45:13 13 A I DON'T RECALL THE NAME OF THEIR ENTITY. 09:45:13 14 Q DO YOU HAVE A CONTRACTOR'S LICENSE? 09:45:13 14 Q WHO WAS YOUR SUPERVISOR? 09:45:13 15 A NO. 09:45:13 15 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. D9:45:13 16 Q OTHER THAN THE -- STRIKE THAT. 09:45:13 16 THE WITNESS: IT WAS OWNED BY BEN AND BILL KAPLAN. 09:45:13 17 HAVE YOU EVER TAKEN ANY COURSES IN FINANCE? 17 THEY WERE BROTHERS. 09:11:13 18 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. VAGUE AS TO TIME. 09:45:13 18 Q BY MR. RUBINER: WHAT WAS YOUR JOB? 09:45:13 19 THE WITNESS: I DON'T RECALL. 09:45:13 19 A IT WAS PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, PROPERTY 09:45:13 20 Q BY MR. ROBINER: WHAT WAS YOUR FIRST FULL-TIME 09:45:13 20 DEVELOPMENT. THERE WAS NO -- WHATEVER THEY ASKED FOR AT 21 JOB? 21 THE TIME. 09:45:13 22 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION, RELEVANCE. D9:45:13 22 Q HOW LONG DID YOU WORK FOR THE KAPLAN FAMILY? 09:45:13 23 THE WITNESS: PROBABLY WORKING AT A GOLF COURSE 09:15:13 23 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 24 WHEN I WAS 17 CALLED BEEKMAN COUNTRY CLUB. 09:45:13 24 THE WITNESS: TWO YEARS. 09:15:13 25 Q BY MR. RUBINER: AND WHERE WAS THAT? 09:45:13 25 Q BY MR. RUBINER: I BELIEVE YOU TESTIFIED THAT 37 39 PAGE 36 PAGE 40 09:45:13 1 MR, BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE, 1 YOU GRADUATED FROM THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORE AT 09:45:13 2 COUNSEL, WORKING AT A GOLF COURSE AS HIS FIRST 2 ALBANY IN 1993, SO DID YOU WORK FOR THE KAPLANS FROM 3 JOB, HOW IS IT RELEVANT WHERE THE GOLF COURSE WAS? 3 1993 TILL 1995? 09:45:13 4 Q BY MR. RUBINER: WHAT WAS THE NAME OF THE GOLF 09:45:13 4 A I THINK IT WAS '91 TO '96. 5 COURSE? 09:45:13 5 Q DID YOU HAVE AN OFFICE? 09:15:13 6 A BEEKMAN COUNTRY CLUB. 09:45:13 6 A YES. 09:15:13 7 Q AND THIS WAS A FULL-TIME JOB? 09:45:13 7 Q WHERE WAS THAT? 09:45:13 B A YEAH. 09:45:13 8 MR. PISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 09:15:13 9 Q WHAT WAS YOUR POSITION? 09:45:13 9 THE WITNESS: PALMS, CALIFORNIA. 09:45:13 10 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 09:45:13 10 Q BY MR. RUBINER: AND YOU WORKED FOR -- DID YOU 09:45:13 11 THE WITNESS: GREENSXEEPING. 11 REPORT -- WHO DID YOU REPORT TO WHILE YOU WORKED FOR THE 09:15:13 12 Q BY MR. RUBINER: HOW LONG DID YOU WORK THERE? 12 KAPLAN FAMILY IN 1991 TO 1996? 09:45:13 13 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 09:45:13 13 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE, OBJECTION. 09:15:13 14 THE WITNESS: I THINK, THERE FULL SUMMERS WHILE AT 14 VAGUE AS TO TIME. 15 COLLEGE. 09:45:13 15 THE WITNESS: BEN KAPLAN. 09:45:13 16 Q BY MR. RUBINER: WHAT WAS YOUR NEXT FULL-TIME 09:45:13 16 Q BY MR, RUBINER: YOU SAID THAT YOU WERE IN 17 JOB? 17 PROPERTY MANAGEMENT AND PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT; IS THAT D9:45:13 18 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 18 RIGHT? 09:45:13 19 THE WITNESS: WORKING AT DUTCHESS COUNTRY CLUB. 09:15:13 19 A YES. 09:15:13 20 Q BY MR. RUBINER: WHEN DID YOU WORK AT DUTCHESS 09:45:13 20 Q AND WHAT DID YOU DO WHILE WORKING FOR THE 21 COUNTRY CLUB? 21 KAPLAN FAMILY IN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT? 09:45:13 22 MR. BISNO: OBJECTION. RELEVANCE. 09:45:13 22 MR. BISND: OBJECTION. VAGUE AS TO TIME, 09:45:13 23 THE WITNESS: DURING COLLEGE. 09:45:13 23 THE WITNESS: WE HAD A PORTFOLIO OF PROPERTIES AND 39:45:13 24 Q BY MR, RUBINER: WHAT WAS YOUR FIRST -- WERE 24 WE WORKED ON KEEPING THE PROPERTIES FULLY LEASED, 25 YOU A FULL-TIME STUDENT WHILE YOU WERE IN COLLEGE? 25 MARKETING THE PROPERTIES AND WORKED OUT A VARIETY OF 381 40 Dalesandro vs. Ogulnick Deposition of Ryan Andrew Ogulnick, Vol. 1 August 13, 2012