Laserfiche WebLink
HEMA No. 2021-03 – Mayberry Residence (2405 North Bonnie Brae) <br />July 1, 2021 <br />Page 2 <br />1 <br />8 <br />3 <br />3 <br />combination of stucco and brick, and a tall brick chimney. The roof material is composition <br />shingles and designed with exposed and shaped rafter tails and rounded shadow boards <br />with wrapped roofing at the roof rakes with rounded end caps. The home has a detached <br />three-car garage to the north of the property, located along North Benton Way, which <br />provides a large concrete driveway leading to the garage. The front elevation offers a long <br />sweeping steeped front-facing gable roof with an arched brick gable entry, and <br />multipaned narrow casement windows. The front yard is landscaped with a brick walkway <br />leading to the entry. <br />Project Description <br />The proposed exterior modifications will include a 446-square-foot addition for an <br />expanded kitchen, basement, and new bathroom; a 340-square-foot rear covered porch; <br />a 126-square-foot rear garage addition; and 630 square feet of new detached accessory <br />structures. The site will also be improved with a new in-ground pool and spa in the rear <br />yard and interior renovations to an existing mudroom, laundry room, den, and kitchen. <br />The expanded kitchen area is proposed along the west side of the house, approximately <br />15 feet behind the primary building facade facing Bonnie Brae, while the new bathroom <br />is proposed along the north elevation and approximately three feet west of the building <br />façade along Benton Way. Both areas of the residential addition incorporate a compatible, <br />lower pitched, hipped roof design with exposed rafters that connects with the covered <br />porch, which wraps around the northwest edge of the residence. Three new wood <br />casement windows and two new wood french doors are proposed along the north and <br />west elevations of the addition and remodeled mudroom, while all other windows and <br />doors of the residence will remain the same. <br />The garage remodel consists of the replacement of garage doors with carriage style steel <br />sectional garage doors, an overall six-foot rear extension, and relocated wood windows <br />and new man door at the rear. Like the addition to the main residence, the garage addition <br />will be lower than the existing garage height. It will contain two sweeping shed roofs on <br />the sides of the addition with a cross-gable roof at the center. The addition will be clad <br />with stucco finish to match the existing garage. <br />The rear and side yards will be improved with three new accessory structures. The <br />approximately 314-square-foot pavillion structure located west of the new pool and spa <br />will contain two storage rooms and a central fireplace. Two arbors, containing <br />approximately 216 square feet and 100 square feet each, are proposed west and east of <br />the main residence. <br />Analysis of the Issues <br />As proposed, the project will follow the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards (SOIS) for <br />the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, <br />Restoring, & Reconstructing Historic Buildings (Kay D. Weeks and Anne E. Grimmer, <br />  <br />Historic Resources Commission 1 – 60 9/8/2022 <br />